Who Moved
My Secret?
Read More/Buy

Reviews The Secret

"The Review Deemed Too
Scandalous for the Legitimate Press"

The Secret
Click Enlarge
Designed for
Internet Explorer

Medium Text  1024x768
One new photo every day ... I promise
Click Back to MW Review Books
Back to MW Review Books
Who Moved
My Secret?
Read More/Buy

Psychic Sylvia Browne
failed to foresee own criminal conviction

Sylvia Browne with Bitchin' Red Hair

Sylvia Browne:
Psychic Guru or Quack?

Blundered predictions in 1998: A 2003 Sylvia Browne Review

Blundered predictions in 2004: a Sylvia Browne review

Sylvia Browne - Caught Hook, Line and Sinker

Sylvia Browne Website
More MW Books:

Books on the Bedstand
Most Recent Purchases
Books on the Bedstand
What I'm Reading Right Now
What I Bought Yesterday
MW's List of the Best Books Lists
MW & The Da Vinci Code
Unread Library of MW

Book Buying
Price: Used Public Library
(by far cheapest)
Price: Used Half Price Books
(compare Powells)
Price: Used Powells.com
(compare HPB)
Price: New HamiltonBooks.com
Price: Current New Releases Barnes&Noble.com
Selection: New/Used Powells.com
Overall Selection, Service, Website: Barnes&Noble.com
Lowest Normal Order Shipping Cost: HamiltonBooks.com
Daedalus Books
Price New on
Weird Books:
Daedalus Books & Music.com
Affiliate Programs: Barnes&Nobel.com

Other MW Pages:

Arizona Politics
Current Events
Dr.Malamud's Blog
National Politics


Book Cover
From the Publisher:

"Fragments of a Great Secret have been found in the oral traditions, in literature, in religions and philosophies throughout the centuries. For the first time, all the pieces of The Secret come together in an incredible revelation that will be life-transforming for all who experience it.

In this book, you'll learn how to use The Secret in every aspect of your life -- money, health, relationships, happiness, and in every interaction you have in the world. You'll begin to understand the hidden, untapped power that's within you, and this revelation can bring joy to every aspect of your life ... "

Mr.Wonderful Writes:

About the size of an automobile CD wallet that might hold a handful of CDs, The Secret by author Rhonda Byrne, is a slim and eye-catching 198-paged work. However, if two of the albums inside the above-mentioned CD wallet were by comedians Richard Lewis and Lewis Black your money would have been better spent than on the $23.95 cover price of this book, or the $59.95 (now $29.99) price of The Secret DVD.

There is no denying that The Secret in all its manifestations has sold in prodigious numbers and, according to Forbes Magazine, has earned it's platinum-tressed author a cool dozen millions. On page xi of the Forward, she proclaims that, "My intention in creating The Secret was--and still is--that it will bring joy to billions around the world." That being your design, Ms.Byrne, how do you explain the $24 cover price, especially after selling tens of thousands of copies of The Secret in DVD form at $60, when a can of Coca-Cola in parts of Africa consumes a day's wages? Are these African-Africans to be denied the joy you offer?

Through wholly anecdotal evidence (for there are no footnotes) Ms. Byrne asserts and attempts to prove, that 'the secret' is the well-known 'Law of Attraction', simply with a special twist spun by her and the twenty-nine both living and dead contributors.

Sasquatch seen behind ladies The actual secret is to publish a work with such sparse text that if printed as a normal-sized book, it would make Frankl's Man's Search for Meaning appear as many pagéd as War and Peace. (By the way, your dollars would be better spent on Frankl's book, paired with a good bottle of Kosher wine.) There is such a dearth of text because, after all, how many times can you say the same thing and present less evidence than there is for Sasquatch, Alien Abductions or Water Witching? However, frequent exclamation points do help convince the reader of the 'facts' reiterated in The Secret.

In an effort to make the book appear thicker, and worthy of its almost ten-cent per page cost, large script font is inserted that consumes, including the above and below spacing, as much as six lines of normal-sized text would. Then a full page rendition of The Secret wax seal logo begins each chapter and the entire book is printed on paper thicker than first century scraped-goat-skin. Then to further pad the book, it is concluded with fourteen pages of the contributor's biographies (penned of course, by the contributors) all of which contain a handy-dandy URL listing for their web site. And that's because should you not get the results promised in The Secret, you must be doing something wrong and you should feel free to consult with any of the still-living twenty-four contributors, although I doubt their answers will also be free.

Of these two dozen coaches, I have experienced only Denis Waitley via books, tapes, VHS and a single personal appearance. And either he has become addicted to hard-rock crack cocaine, or he did not fully understand The Secret's claims prior to allowing his words to be quoted in it.

Also in the Biographies section, I see that a Bob Proctor claims the learning heritage of Dale Carnegie, Napolean Hill and former Town of Paradise Valley, Arizona resident Earl Nightingale. Myself, having taken every course and read every book authored by Mr. Carnegie and listened to two years of cassettes spoken by the basso and gravely voiced Mr. Nightingale, can assure you that both Dale and Earl, after being linked to Mr. Proctor and the teachings of The Secret, are spinning faster in their graves than pulsars and tossing off enough friction heat to comfort Amanaland, Alaska through the coldest of winters.

We read about great avatars (defn. in Hinduism, the incarnation of a god) and we soon note the each contributor has been assigned his own avatar-symbol placed to the left of any of his or her quotes. Oh my gawd. What a coincidence.

The Secret is the law of attraction, ". . . wise people have always known this. You can go right back to the ancient Babylonians . . . They are also known for creating one of the Seven Wonders of the World, the Hanging Gardens of Babylon." Dare I ask where these wise Babylonians are today in the 21st Century? Or did they forget, The Secret?

On page ten we are introduced to frequencies and learn that the law of attraction doesn't register "don'ts". So if I don't want the flu and I go get a flu-shot and don't get the flu . . . I am so confused.

On page fifteen we learn that, "Quantum physicists tell us that the entire Universe emerged from thought!" Granted, I've only read two books dealing with quantum physics, along with a multitude of magazine and newspaper articles, but I don't recall a single mention by any physicist of the universe being created by thought.  (Books I have read on quantum physics: The Quantum Zoo and The Dancing Wu Li Masters.)

We read that, "What you think about the most or focus on the most, is what will appear as your life." If that were actually the case, I'd be waking up each morning next to a minty-breathed Morgan Fairchild, and then during my morning bladder emptying, soon be shivering from the chill water that fills the depths of my toilet bowl.

Another astounding claim made on page twenty-two tells us ". . . it has been scientifically proven that an affirmative thought was hundreds of times more powerful than a negative thought." That must be why, as a parent I can tell my kids affirming thoughts for weeks and then, in a moment of non-PC anger utter a single negative comment, and know they will be recalling it decades later while tearfully reading my eulogy over my cardboard casket.

We hear about frequencies coming back from the Universe being transformed into physical desires and all I can think of is, "Am I going to have to buy an HD Receiver for those frequencies too?" Do you imagine that these frequencies were the ones the person who pummeled Dan Rather two decades ago was referencing as he asked, "Kenneth, what is the frequency?"

Here's the answer to all our weight loss diets for on page fifty-six we read, "Let go of all those limiting thoughts. Food cannot cause you to put on weight, unless you think it can."

On page eighty-two we learn that all inventions come from the Universe simply because one person held the picture of the end result in his mind. I can only think of Thomas Edison and the light bulb. The Universe sent him It's end result, but it took Edison another one thousand tries to get His end result. Oops.

There is a visualization game mentioned involving turning bills into checks, then adding a zero on to them and chanting, "More money for me! Thank you. Thank you." I tried that and all I got was a call from a Ms. Rhamadamadingdong in Mumbai OR Bangalore, India politely telling me and in perfect 19th Century English, that I was late on my Dell computer payment.

"If you have been brought up to believe that being wealthy is not spiritual then I highly recommend that you read ... you will discover that Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Joseph, Moses and Jesus were not only prosperity teachers, but also millionaires themselves, with more affluent lifestyles than many present-day millionaires could conceive of."

Readers, this is why, if you claim to be a Christian, you've got to know what is actually written in the Bible. Now I know there's a talking donkey, a giant slayed by a pebble, and a Herb-Alpert-like horn solo that blasted down the walls of Jerico, but I don't recall ever reading in the Bible of Jesus being a millionaire. That is, unless he lost all his money in the mortgage crisis of 31AD.

Marie Diamond tells us of the art director and famous producer who even though he was a " . . . gorgeous-looking man . . . " Stick Figure Datecould not get a date. She determined this was simply because he had painted portraits with women facing away from him. As soon as he brushed new art with him instead surrounded by women he had more dates than he could find the time to schedule.

I thought I'd try the same thing, although not being much of an artist, my portraits contained stick-figure women and sure enough, soon I had more two dimensional stick-figure women than I could find the time to simply pencil in.

Michael Bernard Beckwith, whose avatar is apparently, a reddish-pink bloom erupting out of a dirt clod tells us, "I've seen kidneys regenerated. I've seen cancer dissolved. I've seen eyesight improve and come back." However my eyesight is improved by old-fashion prescription glasses and using them to their fullest, I don't see any evidence verifying these astonishing claims.

Ms. Byrne tells the reader, "I never studied science or physics at school, and yet when I read complex books on quantum physics I understood them perfectly because I wanted to understand them."

Church Lady Good for you Rhonda, because genius physicist Dr. Richard P. Feynman was quoted as saying:

"I think I can safely say that nobody understands quantum mechanics" . . . But yet Rhonda does.
And here's the deal-killer for any Christian following the teachings of The Secret. For in Chapter 9, Page 164, Verse IV we read, "You are God in a physical body. You are Spirit in the flesh. You are Eternal Life expressing itself as You . . . " (Capitalization her's.) Long ago, Christians and Jews believe that God gave the millionaire Moses the Ten Commandments, of which the very first one states that Man should have no other god than Jehovah God. And here author Byrne tells us we are Gods. I'm not sure what, or who, caused her to write that down but, like in the old SNL Dana Carey/Church Lady Skit, I must ask, "Could it have been Satan?!"

Thinking about the law of attraction, the author's name is what I believe will happen to her when she passes from this life into eternity by her knowingly, and for immense profit, misleading of the lost, the downtrodden, the hopeless and the sadly ignorant. She will Byrne in hell.

Now there is nothing at all wrong with the long accepted theory of the law of attraction. (Don't ask me how one has a 'theory' of a 'law'.) A person definitely wants to dwell on the accomplishments, both physical and spiritual that he or she wishes to achieve.

Rhonda Byrnes money
She doesn't trust banks But Rhonda Byrne has managed to become a multi-millionaire by writing a book whose core claim is that 'frequencies' sent out in the correct manner are always returned from the Universe in physical form. And that simply isn't so.

However, as all charlatans know, anyone promising easy money, in both a novel and convincing way, will herself attract seemingly more money than the universe contains.

reviewed: June 24, 2007
Page 56 "If it's people you need, you'll attract it."

Begun: 06/16/2007   Finished: 06/17/2007 Purchased: May 2007
Where: Book Loaned to Me by Dear Friend

B&N Net Rank: 15

The Secret
Don't Waste
Your Money

The Secret

Rhonda Byrne

ISBN: 1582701709
ISBN-13: 9781582701707
Copyright © 2006

In the News:

October 30, 2009
Sedona, Arizona, USA

Lawsuit filed in deadly
sweat lodge ceremony

"One of the survivors of a sweat lodge ceremony near Sedona that turned deadly has filed a lawsuit."

October 23, 2009
Wall Street Journal

Self-Help Doesn't Help
And Often Hurts

"Mr. Ray draws on random elements of New Age and other psychobabble, hoping to make himself sound cosmically plugged-in..."

October 21, 2009
Flagstaff, Arizona, USA

1st sweat lodge
survivor speaks out

"Texas resident Beverley Bunn says spiritual guru James Arthur Ray pushed participants too far in what was..."

October 16, 2009
Sedona, Arizona, USA

Sweat-lodge case being
probed as homicide

"[A] woman identified as Barb told the callers that a channeler at the retreat said the deceased had an out-of-body experience and 'were having so much fun that they chose not to come back.'

October 11, 2009
Sedona, Arizona, USA

Sweat-lodge leader mum about ritual.   Sheriff: Adviser refuses to describe day of deaths

"Ray is a co-author of the popular book, 'The Secret.' He owns a multimillion dollar self-help company, James Ray International, which purports to offer individuals the tools needed to attain 'harmonic wealth,' which is also the title of his latest book. His frequent TV appearances include 'Oprah' and 'Larry King Live.'"  more Contrarian Views:

Dear readers: As everyone is trying to cash-in on The Secret, as you might imagine, these contrary views were not easy to find. The first 'negative' reference to Rhonda Byrne's billion dollar baby finally appeared at line 92 of my search engine quest.

The Secret: Does this self-help book really help?

The Secret of My Success

The Secret by Rhonda Byrnes
(An extensive review of the book. If nothing else, skim down to the "Comments" section.)

The Hubris of 'The Secret'

Critics Of 'The Secret' Bemoan Claims

Money better spent here:

* Being Happy!

The Psychology of Winning

Do It!

Power of Positive Thinking

The Magic of Believing

Get the Best from Yourself

* How to Stop Worrying
& Start Living

Pulling Your Own Strings

How to Start a Conversation
& Make Friends

It Was on Fire When
I Lay Down on It

How to Have Confidence & Power in Dealing with People

* Feel the Fear &
Do It Anyway

When Bad Things
Happen to Good People

Even Eagles Need a Push

* I'm Okay, You're Okay

Getting Unstuck

* Man's Search for Meaning

The Greatest Risk of All

The Power of Optimism

Scuttle Your Ships Before Advancing

Dare to Dream

Unlocking the Secrets of Your Childhood Memories

The Birth Order Book: Why You are the Way You Are

Secrets of Closing the Sale Slower Reading Here:

* Learned Optimism

What to Say When
You Talk to Yourself


Flow: The Psychology of Optimal Experience

Thick Face Black Heart

Influence: The Psychology of Persuasion

* books that profoundly affected me
If You Feel the
Need to Buy a DVD:

John Candy
James Belushi
Cybill Shepherd
Sean Young
Richard Lewis
Giancarlo Giannini
George Hamilton

Once Upon a Crime

If You Feel the Need
to Buy a Ridiculously
Expensive DVD:

Re-Releasing Soon!
Thomas Jane
Aaron Eckhart 
Paulina Porizkova
James LeGros
Michael Jeter
Glen Plummer
Mickey Rourke


Lewis Black @ 
Red, White & Screwed
Buy @ B&N.com

Lewis Black
Red, White & Screwed

If You Feel the
Need to Buy a CD:

Live From Hell
Richard Lewis
Buy @ Tower Records

Richard Lewis
Live from Hell