I came across a quote from Albert Camus: “Too many people have dispensed with generosity in order to practice charity.” In thinking about the differences between generosity and charity, a couple of thoughts occur to me. You will have additional thoughts.
It seems that generosity is a way of living. People are generous with their spirits. They are open to people, interested in their insights, experiences, and unique perspectives on life. People are generous with their time, allowing room for others and their needs, responding with help, wisdom, and encouragement. People are generous with their money and possessions, sharing what they have with others, contributing to their comfort, pleasure, and well-being. Generosity is relational, life-giving, and satisfying. If Camus’ observation is correct, then something valuable is lost when people drop generosity from their patterns of behavior.
Charity has many positive elements to it, as well. I suspect Camus discerned a bit of self-interest in charity, though. Perhaps he saw charity as a transaction between superior and inferior parties – a difference between the “haves” and the “have-nots.” Maybe he viewed charity as it is reflected in this vignette found on Steve Goodier’s website:
An American tourist in Tel Aviv was about to enter the impressive Mann Auditorium to take in a concert by the Israel Philharmonic. He was admiring the unique architecture, the sweeping lines of the entrance, and the modern decor throughout the building. Finally he turned to his escort and asked if the building was named for Thomas Mann, the world famous author.
"No," his friend said, "it's named for Fredric Mann, from Philadelphia."
"Really? I never heard of him. What did he write?"
"A check."
Sometimes our charity is offered with strings attached. We want a building named after us. We are angling for a tax break. We support an institution or cause that serves our interests or priorities.
Again, charity is not assumed to be negative. It is, however, different from generosity in that it could be perceived as something over which we have more control. If control is our aim, there is less of an equality of relationship and of esteem in the relationship.
I think Jesus called more for generosity than charity from his followers. He saw everyone as a child of God, and when he spoke of justice, he wasn’t referring to punishment for misdeeds or reward for good behavior. He was talking about the right of every person to fully experience life and access to the resources of God’s creation that provide sustenance for life.
Perhaps if there were more generosity in the world, there would be less of a need for charity.
Updated: Thursday, 16 August 2007 4:44 PM EDT
Post Comment | Permalink | Share This Post
