I use my own rating system on the items in my collection. While you may end up disagreeing with my ranking, please understand that I do take quite a bit of time in creating them. Each disc is evaluated to give three ratings: sound quality, performance, and the all-important overall rating. In a future version of the track listings, I might create ratings for each song and list them.
Remember, the performance component is very subjective...I'm biased towards songs I like for example.
Anyway, when you are viewing the discs, the ratings are in this format:
overall: sound quality / performance
| Echoes | CDR | |||
| September 30, 1971 | London | soundboard? | 2.5 (3 / 2) | |
| 1 CDR | 3 tracks, 47:23 | no artwork |
|
PF-ROIO |
| Tracks: 1. Fat Old Sun 14:13 2. One Of These Days 6:52 3. Echoes 26:18 Please look over: both are better, containing the complete show with slightly longer tracks to account for crowd. Meddler is the superior of the two. If you have Meddler, please email me! Also, the title One Of These Days is identical to this Echoes. Also, there is another Echoes which is different from this one. About the date confusion (from PF-ROIO): This specific concert was played on September 30, 1971, but was broadcasted on John Peel's "In Concert" program on October 12, 1971. According to the booklet this was an entire performance in front of a live audience, which you can hear between every track (in Floyd's or Meddler, not this copy! - CDRs). The first three songs (this whole CD - CDRs) were taken from the master source...<snip>. There are many CDs of this show with different titles, check PF-ROIO by date. |
||||
| 1 | Fat Old Sun | 14:13 |
| 2 | One Of These Days | 6:52 |
| 3 | Echoes |
|
|
|
||
|
|
47:23 | |
CDRs Home | New Arrivals
Dylan CDs For Trade | Other CDs For Trade | Trades In Progress
Page updated on
