I think Eugene Robinson hits the target in his op-ed piece about Rev. Jeremiah Wright, the now-retired pastor of Trinity United Church of Christ in Chicago where Democratic presidential candidate Barack Obama is a member. Robinson reflects on Rev. Wright’s recent media explosion, most specifically his appearance this week at the National Press Club in Washington, DC.
Robinson, who is African-American, recoils at Rev. Wright’s assertion that attacks on him are attacks on the black church in America. Robinson makes it clear that Wright does not personify a monolithic ethnic church because there is wide diversity among African-American Christians and churches. As Robinson phrases it, Wright “represents one twig of one branch of a very large tree.”
It is true, Robinson maintains (and I agree), that Wright’s ministry of many years cannot be characterized by a few sound clips taken out of context. After all, Trinity Church not only grew exponentially under Wright’s leadership, it also provides numerous and effective ministries to many more city residents who are not listed on the church rolls. Countless lives have been transformed by God through the faithful efforts of Rev. Wright and dedicated members of the church. The evidence that proves this is overwhelming, and well-known to anyone who has bothered to learn the facts.
But, the whole African-American Christian experience is not wrapped up in Wright’s opinions, views, approaches, words, persona, or priorities. There is too much richness for one person to embody. This applies to theology, social consciousness, political involvement, preaching, and worship styles.
When a widely-known African-American preacher in my church tradition was caught in long-standing and repeated ethical failure, the issue of race became dominant. Some thought the outcry of criticism was racially-motivated. Others, mostly white clergy and laity, tried to make excuses for him by saying things like, “The black church is different.”
This, to me, smacked of paternalism, and underscored pervasive ignorance regarding the realities of the black church. And, the fact is, it wasn’t a case in which every African-American person in his church, or elsewhere, supported the preacher or tried to justify his actions. The multiplicity of opinions and outrage revealed that diversity extends beyond race or skin color.
