Here’s a surprise: “When asked about voting habits, belief in God or their feelings toward race and gender, Americans are notorious for answering what they think pollsters want to hear. Church demographers say the same rings true for church attendance.”
This tidbit comes from an article by Amy Green of the Religious News Service. It turns out that more people identify themselves as Southern Baptists than actually are counted by that denomination, which claims to be the most numerous Protestant denomination in the United States.
Officially, there are 16.3 million Southern Baptists (as distinguished from other Baptist groups), and some reports indicate only 6 million attend worship on a typical Sunday. “The reality is, the FBI couldn’t find half of those if they had to,” remarked one pastor. Lest you think this is about ridiculing the Southern Baptists, rest assured, other denominations, and congregations within those denominations, have the same difficulty with counting, adding, and subtracting.
Some churches play fast and loose with their membership figures because, well, bigger is better. In some denominations there is a financial assessment based on membership numbers, so in that case, it’s not entirely negative in the eyes of the congregation if the figures slide downward a bit. Sometimes people join a church, however that occurs in a particular tradition, and are never heard from again. Member or not?
Others join one church, eventually disappear, and join another. No one bothers to inform the first church. Are they members of two churches, counted twice? Apparently, the Roman Catholic Church never removes anyone from the membership rolls until they die, or submit a written request to be removed. There are a lot of invisible Catholics among the 69 million names on the books in the U.S.
In the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ), a person can be a “participating” or “non-participating” member. To be among the former, one simply must either show up for worship once during the year or make a financial contribution. Every church in which I have served as a pastor, had membership levels far outdistancing the reality. It seems that somewhere along the line, perhaps in the same year everywhere, attempts at precise record-keeping collapsed. How many members are there in the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ)? God only knows.
It’s kind of funny that among the first questions people ask in discussions about churches is, “How many members do you have?” Rarely do you hear, “What is the focus of the ministry of your church?” or “How is the spirit of Christ manifested among the people there?” or “What difference does it make that your church is there?” Those kinds of questions might prove to be embarrassing.
But then, the New Testament doesn’t portray Jesus as saying “Make church members of all nations.” I believe the word he used was “disciples,” which means “one who embraces and assists in spreading the teachings of another…an active adherent, as of a movement or a philosophy.”
How many of those do we have?
