According to an article in The Washington Post, some 150 protestors assembled yesterday at the Rayburn House Office Building on Capitol Hill “to deliver written rebukes to members of Congress who support President Bush’s Iraq policy.” Police were tense, because a large anti-war demonstration in Washington last weekend resulted in the arrest of almost 200 people near the Capitol. Yesterday’s action was tame by comparison.
In fact, agreements were reached prior to the festivities:
“Before leading the group into the building, one of the protest organizers, Medea Benjamin, a founder of the antiwar group Code Pink, approached the officer in charge, Capt. William Hanny of the U. S. Capitol Police.
‘Okay, if we do anything you don’t want in there, would you give us a warning first? she said. ‘We don’t want to get arrested today. We’ve got people catching planes tonight.’
‘We will give you a warning,’ Hanny replied. ‘But it’s going to be up to you.’
‘Because sometimes people want to get arrested,’ she said. ‘They do what they have to do to get arrested. This is not one of those days.’
The captain nodded. ‘Just don’t block the hallways. Don’t blow whistles. Don’t cause a disturbance. Don’t do any of that, and we’ll be okay.’”
Things have changed in my lifetime. Protests and civil disobedience seem to have more of a “Saturday in the park feel to them than what I recall from the days of the Civil Rights Movement and the Vietnam era. I also think they are less effective.
It’s almost as if the protests, marches, and days when people “do what they have to do to get arrested” largely are symbolic, and perhaps mainly are somehow therapeutic to the participants. My impression of much of the unrest in earlier struggles was that there was more of a challenge of those in authority and power, often by people with a lot to lose.
Frankly, mass-produced letters, post cards, and emails have little impact on legislators. They easily can recognize an orchestrated effort by an interest group. Getting “face time” with senators or representatives in their Washington offices is extremely difficult, unless you’re backed up by a wheelbarrow filled with cash.
My belief is that the most effective way to influence elected national officials is to make an appointment to them seem in their offices “back home,” attend a town hall type of meeting in which he or she fields questions and comments from the audience, and to write your own letter on an issue.
When you meet with, or write to a politician, always be polite (if you wish to be taken seriously); briefly note their policy positions with which you share some common ground; succinctly and clearly state your views on the issue on which you disagree; say why you disagree with them; and let them know who you represent, if you are speaking on behalf of anyone besides yourself. It also helps to develop and on-going relationship with your legislator, so that as they know what you’re thinking and how you’re reacting to the concerns of the day, more of a give-and-take approach can develop.
Protesting public policy directions and issues is a legitimate and important means of expression in our society. Doing it to put notches in your belt is a waste of everyone’s time
Treating others as you wish to be treated, and living a life consistent with the values expressed in your protest can facilitate meaningful change.
Updated: Tuesday, 18 September 2007 5:56 PM EDT
Post Comment | Permalink | Share This Post
