In the history of the establishment of my denomination, the Christian Church (Disciples of Christ), there were slogans developed among the frontier folks attracted to the movement. Included were: “Christian Unity is Our Polar Star;” No Creed but Christ, No Book but the Bible;” “Bible Names for Bible Things;” and “Where the Scriptures Speak, We Speak, Where the Scriptures are Silent, We are Silent.”
For a church attempting to “restore” the New Testament faith and practice, these slogans helped remind people what the church was trying to do. They illustrated the centrality of scripture to the approach undertaken by the leaders of the movement.
But, they also sometimes revealed the difficulty of the undertaking. “Where the Scriptures Speak…” could be taken a couple of different ways.
Apparently, there was a congregation in St. Louis around 1867 that became caught up in a disagreement of interpretation. The church had an organ in their sanctuary, but some felt that since the New Testament did not mention the use of musical instruments in worship, then it was not an appropriate practice. Others believed that since there was no specific prohibition of musical instruments in worship, it was allowed.
The folks in favor of playing the organ in worship somehow lost out, and left the fellowship. They started their own congregation, and eventually were able to build a meeting house. They were not, however, ever able to raise sufficient funds to acquire an organ.
So, it turned out that those who could, would not, and those who would, could not.
The fellowship was divided, the body broken, and it’s difficult to imagine that anyone was happy. Their witness to those outside the church fell far short of what it could have been, for they allowed lesser matters to tear them apart.
This seems like an example of why the forbears of our church felt emphasis on doctrines and creeds detracted from Christian unity. It’s ironic that such a division occurred within the movement.
But then, it’s ironic today when churches and Christians are divided, hostile, exclusive and judgmental.
Something has been missed, and even if we don’t realize it, the world isn’t fooled.
Updated: Monday, 12 November 2007 5:09 PM EST
Post Comment | Permalink | Share This Post
