Best New Sensation
Krystal
Sheridan
Hawk Mandez
Blacksnake
Torrie Wilson

Best Tag Team

Overkill - Crymson & Brian Richards

Best Theme Music
"Alive" by Linkin Park - Matt Roberts
"Break Your Neck" by Busta Rhymes - X-odus
"Burn" by Mobb Deep - Crymson
"Dead Girl Superstar" by Rob Zombie - Krystal
"Purple Pills" by D12 - Heather Helmsley

Best Manager
Heather Helmsley
The Family Man

Best Color Commentator
Jim Ross
Shane McMahon
Michael Cole
Jerry "The King" Lawler
Zack Storm

Best Pay-Per-View
Unforgiven 2
New Blood Rising
Vengeance
Royal Rumble
No Way Out

Most Hated Superstar
Crymson
Brian Richards
X-odus
Blacksnake
Cable

Most Popular Superstar
Matt Roberts
Krystal
Torrie Wilson
Zack Berbank
Edge

Hottest ICWF Diva
Heather Helmsley
Sheridan
Krystal
Stephanie McMahon
Marissa Mazzola-McMahon
Lita
Torrie Wilson
Sasha

Best Stable
Chronic Blaze
The Elite
Toxic
The Family

Best ICWF Moment

Krystal winning the Lightweight Title and Women's Title.

Best Overall Wrestler
Matt Roberts
Crymson
X-odus
Brian Richards
Krystal
Blacksnake