Indecision isn't usually considered a sin. But for your case we can make an exception. If you never make up your mind, you end up in limbo.

Unfortunately, you can't take your magazines with you when you die. This is one boring waiting room... Maybe you can get the other indesisive people around here to join you in a race. But which direction should you run? Straight? Left? Right? Why choose! Just run around in a circle, and see who will get to the end first! That should provide eternities of fun! Hopefully. After all, you're here for the rest of your afterlife.

I am ready to choose a place in Hell!
I'd rather go to heaven, thank you.

The corresponding circle in Dante's hell