Listed below will be each federation that Nightmare has wrestled in, each title he has held, and if the information is available who he defeated and lost the title to.
| Federation | Title | Defeated | Reign Lasted | Lost To |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| OHY | Hardcore | N/A | N/A | Fed Closed |
| OHY | 6 Man Tag Team | N/A | N/A | Fed Closed |
| SWF | Internet | Buff Bagwell | 2 Months | Surrended Title |
| SWF | World | Ric Flair | 1 Month and 30 days | Randy Savage |
| CWA | Canadian | Chief Thunder Wolf | 2 Months | Fed Closed |
| CWF | X-Treme | Lee Blades | 3 Weeks | Fed Closed |
| WWWCW | North American | Zen | 18 Days | Zen |
| WWWCW | Tag Team Championship w/ Judge | Cali Connection | 11 Days | Hot Commodity |
