| Date | New Champion | Defeated | Where | Event/Show |
| November 21, 1999 | Jacquelyn | Tori & Ivory Triple Threat Match |
Denver, Colorado | Survivor Series |
| February 13, 2000 | Jessica Lopez | Jacquelyn 4 way, over the top rope battle royale. |
Las Vegas, Nevada | Sunday Night Heat @TWF Warfare |
| September 26, 2000 | Tori | Jessica Lopez | Toronto, Ontario, Canada | Natural Disaster |
| December 20, 2000 | Lita | Tori *Triple Threat match |
Albany, New York |  |
| February 24, 2001 | Molly Holly | Lita | Atlanta, Georgia |  |
| May 25, 2001 | Lita | Molly Holly* In a fatal 4 way |
Madison Square Garden |  |
| May 28, 2001 | Terri Gold | Lita | Tampa, Florida |  |
| May 26, 2001 | Xstasy | Terri Gold | Boston, Massachusetts |  |
| June 25, 2001 | Chyna | Xstasy | Chicago, Illinois |  |
| November 22, 2001 | Chyna officially vacated the title in order to pursue new career goals. | ---- | Minneapolis, Minnesota |  |
| November 30, 2001 | Cammie Copeland | Vacant title battle royale | Indianapolis, Indiana |  |
| February 17, 2002 | Terri Gold | Cammie Copeland | Istanbul, Turkey |  |
| March 30, 2002 | Jazz | Terri Gold | Las Vegas, Nevada |  |
| April 17, 2002 | Cammie Copeland | Jazz | Portland, Oregon | |
| May 29, 2002 | Akasha | Cammie Copeland | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania |  |
| October 29, 2002 | Terri Gold | Akasha | Charlotte, North Carolina |  |
| November 30, 2002 | Akasha | Terri Gold *Hardcore match |
Seattle, Washington |  |
| February 17, 2003 | Jessica Lopez | Akasha | Singapore |  |
| March 29, 2003 | Victoria | Jessica Lopez Won in a fatal 4 way elimination match. |
Tampa, Florida |  |
| April 28, 2003 | Alex Miran | Victoria | Minneapolis, Minnesota | |
| October 26, 2003 | Gail Kim | Alex Miran | Buffalo, New York | |
| April 19, 2004 | Victoria | Gail Kim | Syracuse, New York |  |
| July 28, 2004 | Gail Kim | Victoria *Won in a triple threat |
East Rutherford, New Jersey |  |
| December 7, 2004 | Trish Stratus | Gail Kim *Won in a battle royale |
Louisville, Kentucky |  |
| May 30, 2005 | Mystical | Trish Stratus | Portland, Oregon | |
| November 11, 2005 | Stacy Snow | Mystical | Mobile, Alabama | |
| January 31, 2006 | Melina | Stacy Snow | Seattle, Washington |  |
| May 31, 2006 | Trish Stratus | Melina | St. Louis, Missouri | |
| July 27, 2006 | Mickie James | Trish Stratus | Reno, Nevada | |
| October 31, 2006 | Ashley K. | Mickie James | Detroit, Michigan | |
| February 3, 2007 | Mickie James | Ashley K. | Chicago, Illinois |  |
| May 12, 2007 | Ashley K. | Mickie James | Norfolk, Virginia | |
| July 25, 2007 | Mickie James | Ashley K. | Vancouver, British Columbia | |
| June 30, 2008 | Luyu Dawnstar | Mickie James *Falls Count Anywhere match |
Milwaukee, Wisconsin | |
| November 6, 2008 | Melina | Luyu Dawnstar | Austin, Texas |  |
| May 11, 2009 | Monica | Melina | San Antonio, Texas |  |
| June 12, 2010 | Gina Carano | Monica *Fatal 4 Way Match |
Auburn Hills, Michigan | |
| April 30, 2011 | Kayla Karter | Gina Carano *No Holds Barred Match |
Raleigh, North Carolina |  |
