| Date | Location | Winner | Defeated in Finals |
| June 28, 2000 | Indianapolis, Indiana | Shane McMahon | Chris Jericho |
| June 27, 2001 | Chicago, Illinois | Nuke | Jordan Rockwell |
| June 29, 2002 | Dallas, Texas | William Regal | Rhyno |
| November 30, 2004 | Houston, Texas | Jordan Rockwell | Joe Corey |
| November 29, 2005 | Miami, Florida | Max Ogden | Jason Oliver *Team Rampage also won 6 man tag team final |
| December 5, 2006 | Anaheim, California | Money Mike | Eddie Saint James |
| February 27, 2008 | Toronto, Canada | "The Show" Joe Corey | Sylvester Terkay *Forfeited title |
| December 13, 2008 | Cleveland, Ohio | Jason Oliver | Vladimir Kozlov |
| January 7, 2011 | Detroit, Michigan | Sebastian Cain | Kevin Thorn |
