

| Date | New Champion | Defeated | Where | Event/Show | FACTS
| November 19, 1999 | Jeff Jarrett | Chyna *1st IC Title match |
New Haven, Connecticut | TWF RAW |
| November 22, 1999 | Chris Jericho | Jeff Jarrett | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania | TWF RAW |
| December 27, 1999 | Viscera | Chris Jericho | Minneapolis, Minnesota | ![]() |
| December 28, 1999 | Rikishi | Viscera | Atlanta, Georgia | TWF RAW |
| January 13, 2000 | Travis Wakeman | Rikishi | Anaheim, California | ![]() |
| February 14, 2000 | Ultimate Warrior | Travis Wakeman *Triple Threat Match |
Cameron, North Carolina | TWF RAW |
| February 21, 2000 | Travis Wakeman | Ultimate Warrior | Houston, Texas | TWF RAW |
| April 5, 2000 | Chris Jericho | Travis Wakeman *Triple Threat Match |
Toronto, Ontario, Canada | TWF RAW |
| May 2, 2000 | Chris Benoit | Chris Jericho | Miami, Florida | TWF RAW |
| May 23, 2000 | Val Venis | Chris Benoit | Salt Lake City, Utah | TWF RAW |
| June 28, 2000 | Ken Shamrock | Val Venis | Indianapolis, Indiana | King of the Ring 2000 |
| August 28, 2000 | Val Venis | Ken Shamrock *Lion's Den Match |
Los Angeles, California | ![]() |
| September 26, 2000 | Test | Val Venis | Toronto, Ontario, Canada | Natural Disaster |
| October 14, 2000 | Eddie Guerrero | Test | Kansas City, Missouri | ![]() |
| October 26, 2000 | Test | Eddie Guerrero | Detroit, Michigan | ![]() |
| February 2, 2001 | Billy Gunn | Test | Biloxi, Mississippi | ![]() |
| February 24, 2001 | Jake "The Snake" Roberts | Billy Gunn | Atlanta, Georgia | ![]() |
| June 6, 2001 | Roberts forfeits title on his own decision to enter drug rehab. | --- | --- | TWF RAW |
| June 27, 2001 | Kane | Won a fatal 4 way for the vacant title. | Chicago, Illinois | ![]() |
| August 31, 2001 | Rhyno | Kane | Denver, Colorado | ![]() |
| October 24, 2001 | Kane | Rhyno *Fatal 4 way elimination match |
Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania | ![]() |
| October 30, 2001 | Rhyno | Kane | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania | TWF RAW |
| April 28, 2002 | Drew Blood | Rhyno | Greensboro, North Carolina | ![]() |
| July 29, 2002 | "Stone Cold" Steve Austin | Drew Blood | Dallas, Texas | ![]() |
| August 16, 2002 | Jordan Rockwell | "Stone Cold" Steve Austin IC/European Title Unification Ladder Match |
Grand Rapids, Michigan | ![]() |
| September 7, 2002 | Mr. Perfect | Defeated Rhyno, Eddie Guerrero and Yuji Matasamo in a Fatal 4 way elimination after title was vacated when Rockwell won TWF Title. | New Haven, Connecticut | ![]() |
| October 29, 2002 | Rob Van Dam | Mr. Perfect | Charlotte, North Carolina | ![]() |
| May 31, 2003 | Matt Hardy | N/A Won title after it was brought back in a battle royale. |
Chicago, Illinois | ![]() |
| June 29, 2003 | Travis Wakeman | Matt Hardy | Lafayetee, Louisiana | ![]() |
| August 15, 2003 | Batista | Travis Wakeman | Toronto, Ontario, Canada | ![]() |
| September 27, 2003 | Chris Tirpak *Won in a triple threat |
Batista | Washington, D.C. | ![]() |
| December 30, 2003 | Kid Gundam | Chris Tirpak | Boston, Massachusetts | ![]() |
| March 25, 2004 | Shane Thompson | Kid Gundam | Calgary, Alberta, Canada | ![]() WRESTLEMANIA SPECIAL |
| September 29, 2004 | Edge | Shane Thompson | New Orleans, Louisiana | ![]() |
| December 28, 2004 | Sean O'Haire | Edge | Louisville, Kentucky | ![]() |
| January 31, 2006 | Heidenreich | Sean O'Haire | Seattle, Washington | ![]() |
| July 1, 2006 | Christian | Bahamut (title was vacated) | Greensboro, North Carolina | ![]() |
| October 6, 2006 | Bobby Lashley | Christian *Won in triple threat match |
Atlanta, Georgia | ![]() |
| February 21, 2007 | Edge | Bobby Lashley | Charlotte, North Carolina | ![]() |
| July 3, 2007 | CM Punk | Edge | Omaha, Nebraska | ![]() |
| September 8, 2007 | Kevin Thorn | CM Punk | Washington, D.C. | ![]() |
| September 30, 2008 | Mark Henry *Won in "Monster's Ball" Match |
Kevin Thorn | London, England | ![]() |
| January 30, 2009 | Jordan Rockwell *Won in Falls Count Anywhere Match |
Mark Henry | Vancouver, British Columbia | ![]() |
| July 4, 2009 | John Morrison *Awarded title after Jordan Rockwell won Universal title |
- | Portland, Oregon | ![]() |
| July 4, 2009 | Mark Henry | John Morrison | Phoenix, Arizona | ![]() |
| March 15, 2010 | John Morrison | Mark Henry *Won in Fatal 4 Way Match |
Blacksburg, Virginia | ![]() |
| July 4, 2010 | Evan Bourne | John Morrison | Tampa, Florida | ![]() |
| April 30, 2011 | Chris Jericho | Evan Bourne 2/3 Falls Match |
Raleigh, North Carolina | ![]() |
| July 17, 2011 | M.X. Ogden | Chris Jericho | Chicago, Illinois | ![]() |