| Date | New Champion | Defeated | Where | Event/Show | FACTS
| November 19, 1999 | Big Boss Man | Al Snow *1st Hardcore Title match |
New Haven, Connecticut |  |
| November 30, 1999 | Al Snow | Big Boss Man | St. Louis, Missouri | TWF Armageddon |
| December 6, 1999 | Steve Blackman | Al Snow | Louisville, Kentucky | |
| December 27, 1999 | Cactus Jack | Steve Blackman | Minneapolis, Minnesota |  |
| March 8, 2000 | Crash | Cactus Jack | Jackson, Mississippi |  |
| May 30, 2000 | Gangrel | Crash | San Antonio, Texas | |
| June 14, 2000 | Crash | Gangrel | Ohio State University | |
| June 28, 2000 | D.W. Jones | Crash | Indianapolis, Indiana | Sunday Night Heat |
| July 11, 2000 | Crash | D.W. Jones | Chicago, Illinois | |
| July 26, 2000 | D.W. Jones | Crash | Washington, D.C. | Capitol Punishment |
| August 4, 2000 | Steve Blackman | D.W. Jones | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania | |
| August 20, 2000 | Al Snow | Steve Blackman | Indiana University | Sunday Night Heat |
| September 26, 2000 | Crash | Al Snow | Toronto, Ontario, Canada | Natural Disaster |
| October 31, 2000 | Weapon R | Crash | Minneapolis, Minnesota | |
| November 27, 2000 | Steve Blackman | Weapon R | New Haven, Connecticut |  |
| December 20, 2000 | Raven | Steve Blackman | Albany, New York | |
| March 25, 2001 | Nuke | Raven 8 man Hardcore Hell Match |
Madison Square Garden |  |
| March 30, 2001 | Nails | Nuke | Dayton, Ohio | |
| April 28, 2001 | Kane | Nails | Tampa, Florida |  |
| May 2, 2001 | Nuke | Kane *Triple Threat Match |
Lansing, Michigan | |
| May 26, 2001 | Strife | Nuke *6 Pack Challenge |
Boston, Massachusetts |  |
| October 8, 2001 | Hells Angel | Strife | Providence, Rhode Island |  |
| December 15, 2001 | Ahmed Walker | Hells Angel | Long Isalnd, New York | |
| January 10, 2002 | Rob Van Dam | Ahmed Walker | Phoenix, Arizona | |
| March 30, 2004 | Johnny Stamboli Title brought back at WrestleMania 5 |
Hardcore Invitational | Toronto, Ontario, Canada |  |
| June 27, 2004 | Dylan Jansens Won in a triple threat |
Johnny Stamboli | Salt Lake City, Utah |  |
| August 31, 2004 | Axl Irvin | Dylan Jansens | Memphis, Tennessee |  |
| September 10, 2004 | Dylan Jansens | Axl Irvin | Atlanta, Georgia | |
| November 8, 2004 | Nails | Dylan Jansens | Hershey, Pennsylvania | |
| February 8, 2005 | Edge | Nails | Des Moines, Iowa | |
| June 29, 2005 | Jordan Rockwell | Nails *Nails took title back after Edge threw it in the trash. |
Phoenix, Arizona | |
| October 25, 2005 | Shane Thompson *Wrestled as Doink the Clown |
Jordan Rockwell | Salt Lake City, Utah | |
