| 1947 | Jackie Robinson | Brooklyn | NL |
| 1948 | Alvin Dark | Boston | NL |
| 1949 | Don Newcombe | Brooklyn | NL |
| Roy Sievers | St. Louis | AL | |
| 1950 | Sam Jethroe | Boston | NL |
| Walt Dropo | Boston | AL | |
| 1951 | Willie Mays | New York | NL |
| Gil McDougald | New York | AL | |
| 1952 | Joe Black | Brooklyn | NL |
| Harry Byrd | Philadelphia | AL | |
| 1953 | Junior Gilliam | Brooklyn | NL |
| Harvey Kuenn | Detroit | AL | |
| 1954 | Wally Moon | St. Louis | NL |
| Bob Grim | New York | AL | |
| 1955 | Bill Virdon | St. Louis | NL |
| Herb Score | Cleveland | AL | |
| 1956 | Frank Robinson U | Cincinnati | NL |
| Luis Aparicio | Chicago | AL | |
| 1957 | Jack Sanford | Philadelphia | NL |
| Tony Kubek | New York | AL | |
| 1958 | Orlando Cepeda U | Pittsburgh | NL |
| Albie Pearson | Washington | AL | |
| 1959 | Willie McCovey U | San Francisco | NL |
| Bob Allison | Washington | AL | |
| 1960 | Frank Howard | Los Angeles | NL |
| Ron Hansen | Baltimore | AL | |
| 1961 | Billy Williams | Chicago | NL |
| Don Schwall | Boston | AL | |
| 1962 | Ken Hubbs | Chicago | NL |
| Tom Tresh | New York | AL | |
| 1963 | Pete Rose | Cincinnati | NL |
| Gary Peters | Chicago | AL | |
| 1964 | Dick Allen | Philadelphia | NL |
| Tony Oliva | Minnesota | AL | |
| 1965 | Jim Lefebvre | Los Angeles | NL |
| Curt Blefary | Baltimore | AL | |
| 1966 | Tommy Helms | Cincinnati | NL |
| Tommie Agee | Chicago | AL | |
| 1967 | Tom Seaver | New York | NL |
| Rod Carew | Minnesota | AL | |
| 1968 | Johnny Bench | Cincinnati | NL |
| Stan Bahnsen | California | AL | |
| 1969 | Ted Sizemore | Los Angeles | NL |
| Lou Piniella | Kansas City | AL | |
| 1970 | Carl Morton | Montreal | NL |
| Thurman Munson | New York | AL | |
| 1971 | Earl Williams | Atlanta | NL |
| Chris Chambliss | Cleveland | AL | |
| 1972 | Jon Matlack | New York | NL |
| Carlton Fisk U | Boston | AL | |
| 1973 | Gary Matthews | San Francisco | NL |
| Al Bumbry | Baltimore | AL | |
| 1974 | Bake McBride | St. Louis | NL |
| Mike Hargrove | Texas | AL | |
| 1975 | John Montefusco | San Francisco | NL |
| Fred Lynn | Boston | AL | |
| 1976 | Butch Metzger | San Diego | NL |
| Mark Fidrych | Detroit | AL | |
| 1977 | Andre Dawson | Montreal | NL |
| Eddie Murray | Baltimore | AL | |
| 1978 | Bob Horner | Atlanta | NL |
| Lou Whitaker | Detroit | AL | |
| 1979 | Rick Sutcliffe | Los Angeles | NL |
| John Castino (co-winner) | Minnesota | AL | |
| Alfredo Griffin (co-winner) | Toronto | AL | |
| 1980 | Steve Howe | Los Angeles | NL |
| Joe Charboneau | Cleveland | AL | |
| 1981 | Fernando Valenzuela | Los Angeles | NL |
| Dave Righetti | New York | AL | |
| 1982 | Steve Sax | Los Angeles | NL |
| Cal Ripken | Baltimore | AL | |
| 1983 | Darryl Strawberry | New York | NL |
| Ron Kittle | Chicago | AL | |
| 1984 | Dwight Gooden | New York | NL |
| Alvin Davis | Seattle | AL | |
| 1985 | Vince Coleman U | St. Louis | NL |
| Ozzie Guillen | Chicago | AL | |
| 1986 | Todd Worrell | St. Louis | NL |
| Jose Canseco | Oakland | AL | |
| 1987 | Benito Santiago U | San Diego | NL |
| Mark McGwire U | Oakland | AL | |
| 1988 | Chris Sabo | Cincinnati | NL |
| Walt Weiss | Oakland | AL | |
| 1989 | Jerome Walton | Chicago | NL |
| Gregg Olson | Baltimore | AL | |
| 1990 | David Justice | Atlanta | NL |
| Sandy Alomar U | Cleveland | AL | |
| 1991 | Jeff Bagwell | Houston | NL |
| Chuck Knoblauch | Minnesota | AL | |
| 1992 | Eric Karros | Los Angeles | NL |
| Pat Listach | Milwaukee | AL | |
| 1993 | Mike Piazza U | Los Angeles | NL |
| Tim Salmon U | California | AL | |
| 1994 | Raul Mondesi U | Los Angeles | NL |
| Bob Hamelin | Kansas City | AL | |
| 1995 | Hideo Nomo | Los Angeles | NL |
| Marty Cordova | Minnesota | AL | |
| 1996 | Todd Hollandsworth | Los Angeles | NL |
| Derek Jeter U | New York | AL | |
| 1997 | Scott Rolen U | Philadelphia | NL |
| Nomar Garciaparra U | Boston | AL | |
| 1998 | Kerry Wood | Chicago | NL |
| Ben Grieve | Oakland | AL | |
| 1999 | Scott Williamson | Cincinnati | NL |
| Carlos Beltran | Kansas City | AL | |
| 2000 | Rafael Furcal | Atlanta | NL |
| Kazuhiro Sasaki | Seattle | AL | |
| 2001 | Albert Pujols U | St. Louis | NL |
| Ichiro Suzuki | Seattle | AL | |
| 2002 | Jason Jennings | Colorado | NL |
| Eric Hinske | Toronto | AL | |
| 2003 | Dontrelle Willis | Florida | NL |
| Angel Berroa | Kansas City | AL | |
| 2004 | Jason Bay | Pittsburgh | NL |
| Bobby Crosby | Oakland | AL | |
| 2005 | Ryan Howard | Philadelphia | NL |
| Huston Street | Oakland | AL | |
| 2006 | Hanley Ramirez | Florida | NL |
| Justin Verlander | Detroit | AL | |
| 2007 | Ryan Braun | Milwaukee | NL |
| Dustin Pedroia | Boston | AL | |
| 2008 | Geovany Soto | Chicago | NL |
| Evan LongoriaU | Tampa Bay | AL | |
| 2009 | Chris Coghlan | Florida | NL |
| Andrew Bailey | Oakland | AL | |
| 2010 | Buster Posey | San Francisco | NL |
| Neftali Feliz | Texas | AL | |
| 2011 | Craig KimbrelU | Atlanta | NL |
| Jeremy Hellickson | Tampa Bay | AL | |
| 2012 | Bryce Harper | Washington | NL |
| Mike TroutU | Anaheim | AL | |
| 2013 | Jose Fernandez | Miami | NL |
| Wil Myers | Tampa Bay | AL |