Warfare, Good vs. Evil, iPods, and Chiang Mai
Saturday, January 10, 2004
9:43
Chiang Mai YMCA
Last night I went to see the Return of the King with the other teachers who are here early. I had been planning to go see it anyway, and so when I ran into them and that?s what they were doing, I agreed to go with them. During the evening, I was reminded that this is why it?s more difficult to be with Americans my own age than to be with my students -- being with these teachers only reminds me of how much better it is to be with Jason, Mollie, Anna, my old friends from high school?I sat in the dark theatre wishing I were sitting next to Jason. I sat there remembering the Fellowship of the Ring and The Two Towers, both of which I saw with the Bakke?s on opening night. I remembered talking at IHOP late into the night after the first one - or, more correctly, listening as Seth and Jason talked about interpretations, allegory, and philosophy. I sat there thinking of David Hudson standing up after the movie was over and shouting out the story of the true return of the King for all the moviegoers to hear.
I enjoyed the movie, though I wished desperately that I hadn?t read the article on Slate.com talking about ?hobbit-love? in the movie, accusing the hobbits of closet homosexuality. Yep, that ruined a bit of it for me. There was another article on Slate that I didn?t read, but that apparently dealt with the question ?Why don?t girls like the Lord of the Rings?? and I thought about that as I watched it. I do like Lord of the Rings, and I?m a girl, and I know a lot of girls who like the trilogy, even a few who are slightly fanatical about it.
But the thing I thought about most as I watched was the battle, the climactic battle between good and evil. I could never be a soldier, or a warrior, I thought as I watched the men fight towards certain death -- death for what? For honor, because they are ?men of Rohan,? and that?s what men of Rohan do? Because it is Right? Because it is against Evil? War requires such moral certainty. To be willing to march towards death, knowing how slight your chances of survival are - being willing to kill, not to mention taking joy in it as you keep a count of how many you?ve slain - certainly you must be completely convinced that you are in the right.
In Middle Earth, it?s true, right and wrong are clearly delineated. The Good are Beautiful (Aragorn, Legolas?) and the Evil are too hideous to name. And so, maybe in that case, maybe in Middle Earth, I could ride to war. Maybe in that place I could be a hero.
But in this Earth, sometimes evil is beautiful, and good is difficult to recognize. I have trouble believing that I, like Frodo and Sam, am involved in a fight of epic proportions, an ultimate battle of good vs. evil. While I can say that I believe, as an objective fact, that such a war is raging, that fact doesn?t influence my daily life, choices, or thought patterns. I don?t think that my personal decisions have any part in or impact on that war.
There are times when Evil is clear. But for the most part, I lack the moral certainty of a warrior. There is too much grey, too much ambiguity or overlap, too many things influencing my own sight and interpretation for me to feel certain enough to argue for Right, much less give my life for it. It?s a weak attitude - maybe an attitude of a scribe on the sidelines, who cannot fight but only report what she sees, recognizing that even that is incomplete and biased - but for now, it?s who I am.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------
The Secret Hand Signals of my Generation (or, how to pick up a Backpacker)
A couple of years ago, a book was published that talked about the Bohemian Bourgeoisie - BoBo?s - the new upper middle class in America. The author was talking mainly about my parents? generation, baby boomers who try to blend the values of WASPy success with the values that they claimed to live by in their earlier hippie phase. He explained the popularity of trends like yoga and backpacking by attributing them to the upper-middle class trying to justify their wealth and make it mesh with the values of the sixties.
But you can see the characteristics of the Bohemian Bourgeoisie in my generation too. For the Bo-Bo?s in their twenties, a stint backpacking overseas is practically mandatory. When I was traveling through Bavaria, I met Mike, who had just finished an internship in Germany and was taking a month for traveling - ?I figured I?d better go ahead and get the college Europe trip out of the way, so I don?t have to do it later,? he said, implying that every college student must complete the ritual backpack through Europe test before being allowed to move into adulthood. He made it sound as if traveling wasn?t really enjoyable, but simply a necessary rite of passage. While hopefully most find a little more pleasure in their backpacking than Mike, his implication isn?t far off from the truth. For most American college Bo-Bo?s, the backpack trip has become an expected ceremonial journey. You can spot us in most any airport or train station, in Europe, Asia, or South America. There are several tell-tale signs, useful not only for recognizing the backpacking Bo-Bo?s, but if acknowledged and returned correctly, useful for hooking up with them.
Of course, the most obvious sign is the backpack. Usually covered with country patches, it?s often a North Face, lowe alpine, or other pricey brand pack. Bad pick up line: ?So, have you really been all those places (pointing to the country patches)?? Better pick up line: ?You prefer an internal frame pack to an external frame?? Knowledge of the terms makes you sound like a coolly seasoned backpacker, while the first question makes you sound like a naive first-timer. Speaking of looking seasoned: if you are in Europe, you should be carrying either Rick Steve?s or Let?s Go, but if you are in Asia, you must have the Lonely Planet guidebook. If you are a true backpacking Bo-Bo, you will know that.
But if you?re in an airport, waiting for a flight, you have to watch for more subtle signs - the backpack is already checked luggage. There are several things to look for at this stage. The best is the Nalgene bottle, which will be covered with stickers like the backpack is covered with patches. The Nalgene bottle itself has become so ubiquitous that it?s not a completely reliable sign, but if you can get close enough to take a look at the stickers on the Nalgene, you can pick up all kinds of information - about nationality, musical interests, and backpacking brands preferred.
The Nalgene is a useful pick-up tool even outside of traveling; in a college English class, the guy sitting next to me said, ?So, do you like camping? I mean, I just saw your Nalgene?? thus opening the way for a nice conversation, leading to a date later that week. Note: If asked about camping, never, never say that you don?t like it. It is death for the Bo-Bo to admit this.
Finally, the most powerful pick-up tool for backpacking Bo-Bo?s: the secret iPod hand signal. Requiring no words, this signal works from all the way across waiting rooms. I?ve used it twice so far, both times very effective. The first was in a train traveling south through Vietnam. Standing outside the sleeper compartment watching the green countryside change through the window, I noticed a guy down the hall doing the same, but with headphones on and the sleek white iPod barely sticking out of his pocket. Hmm, I thought, who is this? The next time I left my sleeper compartment, I too wore my iPod, purposefully avoiding the gaze of the guy down the hall. Finally, he caught my eye and pointed to his iPod and to mine, and murmured something like, ?Nice.?
The second use was in an airport in Thailand. I had already noted these two guys, who carried Nalgenes and thick paperbacks, but I wasn?t sure if they had noticed me. Looking bored, I pulled out my iPod and started playing the old school games it has - solitare, brick, parachute. While ?engrossed? in my games, one of the two guys pulled out his iPod and put on his headphones? thus signaling to me that he was indeed aware and watching and interested.
A final tip for all backpacking Bo-Bo?s, or those wishing to pick them up: Beware of backpackers with laptops, even if they flash the secret iPod hand signal- they might be writing about you.