Year 1 Awards
| 2002 NFL Scoring Awards | Player | Team |
|---|---|---|
| League MVP |  Ricky Williams |  Cup O Noodles |
| Scoring Bowl MVP |  Zack Crockett |  Miami SandSharks |
| Rookie of the Year |  Clinton Portis |  Lickliter Phalangees |
| Sleeper of the Year |  Michael Vick |  PA Tacklebreakers |
| 2003 NFL Scoring Awards | Player | Team |
|---|---|---|
| League MVP |  Priest Holmes |  Red River Dragons |
| Scoring Bowl MVP | Priest Holmes | Red River Dragons |
| Rookie of the Year |  Anquan Boldin |  New York Ironclad |
| Sleeper of the Year |  Jamal Lewis | PA Tacklebreakers |
| 2004 NFL Scoring Awards | Player | Team |
|---|---|---|
| League MVP |  Peyton Manning | Miami SandSharks |
| Scoring Bowl MVP |  Muhsin Muhammed |  Auburn Dolphins |
| Rookie of the Year |  Ben Roethlisberger |  Cali Crawdads |
| Sleeper of the Year |  Antonio Gates |  Big Blue Machine |
| 2005 NFL Scoring Awards | Player | Team |
|---|---|---|
| League MVP |  Shaun Alexander |  LA Raiders |
| Scoring Bowl MVP |  Chicago Defense |  Hotlanta Bulldogs |
| Rookie of the Year |  Carnell Williams | Hotlanta Bulldogs |
| Sleeper of the Year |  Larry Johnson | Miami SandSharks |
