- Do NOT use first person “I” in writing the story.
- Do NOT include any opinions unless they are quoted.
- Do NOT address the reader directly. No no: You may have seen...
- Do NOT speculate about the future. No no: This young man will go far...
| Beginning | “John had the second highest batting average last year because he is so strong because of weight training,” comments teammate Jim Jones. |
| End | Teammate Jim Jones says, “John had the second highest batting average last year because he is so strong because of weight training.” |
| Broken Up | ”John had the second highest batting average last year,” teammate Jim Jones says, “because he is so strong because of weight training.” |
| Partial Quote | John had the second highest batting average last year, says teammate Jim Jones, “because he is so strong because of weight training.” |
| Using “that” | Sophomore Gilda Smithly claims that “he [Geraldo] will be president some day.” |
| *___ | Does the first paragraph include the 5 Ws? |
| ___ | Except for quotes, are facts presented objectively, without opinion? |
| ___ | Is the article full of interesting information? |
| ___ | Is coverage of the story thorough and complete? |
| ___ | Is the story entertaining? |
| ___ | Is there a variety of grammatically correct sentence structures? |
| ___ | Is word choice precise? |
| ___ | Spelling |
| ___ | Vocabulary |
| ___ | Are people or sources meaningfully quoted? |
| ___ | Punctuation Around Quotes |
| ___ | Other Punctuation |
| ___ | Silly, Sloppy, Shameful Errors (see below) |
| ___ | GRADE |
| Sp | Spelling error | Q | Questionable: support with evidence |
| ITS | It's=it is; its=possessive | ? | Meaning unclear |
| AL | Misspelled "a lot" or "all right" | Vg | Vague |
| Ap | Apostrophe needed: POSSESSIVE | Th | Connection to thesis or theme unclear |
| NA | No Apostrophe: PLURAL | REL | Relevance? |
| SUB | if... were, wish...were (subjunctive mood) | Ev | Evidence needed to support interpretation |
| Inf | Use of "I" or "you" too informal for a formal essay | BS | Animal excrement |
| Goo | Baby words | Com | Combine |
| Awk | Awkwardly phrased | R-O | Run-on sentence |
| Pres | Use present tense: Plot never changes | SF | Sentence fragment |
| D | Dangling: re-position | Tr | Transition needed |
| LP | Lack of parallelism | PP? | Point of paragraph? |
| Rep | Repetitive | PSI | Paragraph structure illogical |
| PS | Plot Summary: unnecessary & waste of time | Ill | Handwriting illegible |
| INQ | Commas and periods belong inside quotation marks | Dev | Important. Develop. |
| MIS | Misleading | MEN | Mention in 1st paragraph. |
| WON | Write out numbers | SP | Inconsistent: Singular … Plural |