| Overall Record | |||||||||
| Team Name | W | - | L | PCT | Notes | ||||
| Sacramento River Cats | 387 | - | 261 | 0.597 | CRL Champion - 1963, 1964 | ||||
| Ocean City Bulldogs | 381 | - | 267 | 0.588 | |||||
| San Francisco Golden Seals | 379 | - | 269 | 0.585 | |||||
| Los Angeles Angels | 364 | - | 285 | 0.561 | CRL Champion - 1966 | ||||
| Cincinnati Buckeyes | 351 | - | 297 | 0.542 | |||||
| Chicago River Dogs | 349 | - | 299 | 0.539 | |||||
| Texas Rangers | 344 | - | 305 | 0.530 | |||||
| Albuquerque Dukes | 334 | - | 314 | 0.515 | |||||
| Oakland Oaks | 329 | - | 319 | 0.508 | |||||
| Pittsburgh Pirates | 324 | - | 324 | 0.500 | CRL Champion - 1965 | ||||
| Wyoming Rustlers | 297 | - | 351 | 0.458 | |||||
| Boston Beaneaters | 293 | - | 355 | 0.452 | |||||
| Cleveland Indians | 289 | - | 359 | 0.446 | |||||
| Seattle Red Barons | 273 | - | 375 | 0.421 | |||||
| Queens Kings | 266 | - | 382 | 0.410 | |||||
| Columbus Redbirds | 225 | - | 423 | 0.347 | |||||
| 5185 | - | 5185 | 0.500 | ||||||
