Saturday, August 2, 2008 - 2:30 AM EDT
Name:
"Anne"
Home Page:
https://www.angelfire.com/planet/zerofret
Hi Lew,
I checked into this a little bit, and yes, I see exactly what you're saying. Fortunately, it seems I did my tab from the full version of the song. I was given a couple of April Wine songs and asked if I could get around to having a look at them. The version of "Tonite" I was given was from the anthology CD The April Wine Collection. After reading your comment, I looked into what version of the song you got if you bought it from an mp3 site off of Harder...Faster. And you're absolutely right, the version now being sold on "HF" is an edited version.
For anyone wondering about the changes, have a look at the tab here: https://www.angelfire.com/planet/zerofret/cantab/aprilwine-tonite.txt. Go down to the measure that says "free time begins" under the staff (half way through the Bridge). The version of the song on current editions of Harder...Faster include this measure, and the next two, but then it edits out the next four bars (including the bass lick that was referred to) and goes right to the bar with the drum fill that leads into the main guitar solo. So a whole section has been cut out of that free time, trading licks part. I'm assuming the original vinyl release of H...F had the full, longer version of the song. From what you're saying, Lew, that seems to be the case.
It's weird, because usually the exact opposite is done. Usually, edited versions of songs often appear on anthologies to make room for more songs. In this case it's the reverse. If someone wanted the full version of "Tonite", they'd be better off buying The April Wine Collection (http://www.aprilwine.ca/April%20Wine%20-%20Discography%20-%20The%20April%20Wine%20Collection.htm) than they would be buying Harder...Faster, the album on which it originally appeared. The person who posted the song at YouTube (which I added to the Video Page of the site) posted the version from The Collection, so it's the full song. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OHA0P5gcjH0)
What's troubling about this is that it means if you buy Harder...Faster on CD or mp3 now, you're not actually getting the "real thing", the original recording of the album. Why would they tamper with the content of the album? No idea. I'm sure there's no problem fitting it on a CD. Albums weren't overly long back then.
Interesting point, Lew, thanks for mentioning it.
I'm often suspicious of anthology CDs because of that tendency to edit songs. Now it looks like I'm going to have to be suspicious of the CD versions of all my old vinyl, wondering if I'm going to get the whole original album if I re-buy it on CD.