Outstanding Wrestler Award 1999 -Sean Schellenger 1991 - Todd Moulder 1998 - Sean Schellenger 1990 - Todd Moulder 1997 - Haneef Lumpkin 1989 - Erich Moulder/Ted Weiss 1996 - Haneef Lumpkin 1988 - Leroy Weber 1995 - Chad Rhoades 1987 - David Hemingway 1994 - Bear Stephens 1986 - Neil Heineman 1993 - Ron Detwiller/ Bear Stephens 1985 - Mike Moskel 1992 - Todd Moulder
Most Dedicated Wrestler Award 1999 - Chris Walton 1998 - Dave Enghofer
Most Valuable Wrestler Award 1997 - Haneef Lumpkin 1990 - Todd Moulder 1996 - Pete Springer 1989 - Erich Moulder 1995 - Chad Rhoades 1988 - Ted Weiss 1994 - Ron Detwiller 1987 - David Memingway 1993 - Bear Stephens/Ron Detwiller 1986 - Bob Talton 1992 - Todd Moulder 1985 - Mike Moskel