Site hosted by Angelfire.com: Build your free website today!
Nit - Pick || Books || Gringotts || Vault 713 Gringotts Relevancy Mistake

Okay, this one will be short. Trust me. :-) Yeah, right, trust me. Ha ha . . . ha. :-)

Okay, you know and remember how Harry, Hagrid, and the goblin, Griphook went to the vault 713 to collect the Sorcer/Philosopher's Stone (though, of course, we didn't know that at that time), right?

Well, here's the problem: Griphook said that if anyone or anything other than a Gringotts goblin raked his or her finger on the door, they would be sucked in. Then Harry asks when they check it and Griphook sneered the answer "About every ten years."

Now, does anyone see the mistake? The flaw? The thing I'm nit - picking about?

Well, whether or not you see it, here it is: The Philosopher's Stone was in there, meaning so was the Elixir of Life. ::cough:: Excuse me, but this would mean they don't die and would just easily walk out with the stone and elixir when a goblin checks. I doubt the person would get very far, but does anyone see my point? Not that there's much of a point, of course!!! :-)

Back or Home

Email: harrypotter@angelfire.com