Convicted for the rape of Dr. Gloria Nathan. Dr. Nathan assumed that O'Reily had the rape set up, and O'Reily admitted to it because that's what she wanted to hear (although it was never revealed that Ryan didn't set up the rape). Hoyt would always get into fights with Keenan in Unit B. Ryan had a talk with Keenan one day in the gym and asked Keenan what it was like to rape Gloria. After hearing the story, O'Reily bashed Keenan's head in with a weight and ripped off his shamrock necklace and put it in on Dr. Nathan's desk with a note attached "ALL FOR YOU GLORIA".