| Rank |
Wrestler |
Wins |
| #1 |
*Nature Boy Billy Z |
62 |
| #2 |
*Thrash (HOF) |
43 |
| #3 |
*John "The Bloodstone" Kresse |
40 |
| #4 |
*Tiger Devil |
38 |
| #5 |
*Billy Veneno |
38 |
| #6 |
*Baron Skull |
36 |
| #7 |
*Rude Boy |
35 |
| #8 |
*Slick Rey Williams (HOF) |
33 |
| #9 |
*Triple X |
31 |
| #10 |
*Jim Bowen |
28 |
| #11 |
*Dan "The Earthquake" Cameron (HOF) |
28 |
| #12 |
*Parental Advisory |
28 |
| #13 |
*James Salensky |
26 |
| #14 |
*Carnifex |
25 |
| #15 |
Payne |
24 |
| #16 |
*Dilly Dawg |
24 |
| #17 |
Maximum Limit (HOF) |
23 |
| #18 |
*Dominic "Fury" Furio |
23 |
| #19 |
"Sadistic" Robbie Kozma (HOF) |
22 |
| #20 |
*Jon "Megaforce" Zazula |
22 |
| #21 |
*Psychodonkey |
22 |
| #22 |
*The Spoiler |
22 |
| #23 |
*Mike Hollywood |
22 |
| #24 |
*Slash |
21 |
| #25 |
Eze |
20 |
| #26 |
Viper (HOF) |
20 |
| #27 |
*Xtreme Kid |
20 |
| #28 |
*Blair Williams |
19 |
| #29 |
*Michael Bishop |
19 |
| #30 |
Catastrophy |
18 |
| #31 |
*Chris Moyles |
17 |
| #32 |
Sammael |
17 |
| #33 |
*Hardcore Harry |
17 |
| #34 |
*"Hardcore Warrior" Kris Karnage |
17 |
| #35 |
*Dingo Warrior |
16 |
| #36 |
*Jamie Mack |
16 |
| #37 |
Golem |
15 |
| #38 |
Lord Humongous |
15 |
| #39 |
*Masked Prince |
14 |
| #40 |
Darken Rahl |
13 |
| #41 |
Stone Cold Steve Austin (HOF) |
13 |
| #42 |
*Mask Machine |
13 |
| #43 |
Jack Frost |
12 |
| #44 |
Cy Kopath |
11 |
| #45 |
Demonkind |
11 |
| #46 |
Hooligan |
11 |
| #47 |
Plasma Fire |
11 |
| #48 |
Mike Braeden |
11 |
| #49 |
*Grant Keaton |
11 |
| #50 |
Kronos |
10 |
