Kyle made his Halloween Foosball debut in 2000 and his first match was one of the most memorable in Halloween Foosball Tournament history. Back in the days when games could be decided by a single point, Kyle actually held a game point advantage over Jim in the first round. Kyle actually led Jim 4-2, before Jim scored three consecutive goals to win the match in a remarkable comeback.
Kyle faced Angel in 2001 and lost that match 5-3. 2001 was also the debut of his partnership with Nicky in the doubles tournament. In 2002, Kyle and Nicky once again teamed up, but an early loss in the tournament caused Nicky to snap. He blamed Kyle for the loss. As fate would have it, Nicky and Kyle would face in the Halloween Foosball Tournament that night. After Kyle lost that match, Nicky "busted 10 caps in his ass." But Kyle did get a little bit of revenge against Nicky, when Steve fired his brother as a scorekeeper and inserted Kyle into his spot.
