Thursday, 18 February 2016
What It Doesn't Say
On the Linn County Republican Central Committee, there are times when we have trouble with what things say.
For instance, in the "New Member" handout, there was a document titled:
Roadmap to Victory 2016
2015 - 2016 Plan for the Linn County Republican Central Committee
Start Here:
Organize > Caucus>> Conventions >>>Primary >>>>2016 Election Victory
It was presented as a plan moved by the Executive Committee, and voted on and accepted by the Central Committee.
It is one of three versions I have seen so far.
The problem, however, is that none of them are the same.
The differences seem to occur in the section for the
Membership & Meeting Setup Team.
In the first two versions, the team leader was listed in bold type.
Version 1 said:
Membership & Meeting Setup – Membership records, meeting setup, credentialing for voting (Justin Wasson, Mike Dupree, Deb Dupree)
Version 2 read:
Membership & Meeting Setup – Membership records, meeting setup, credentialing for voting (Mike Dupree, Deb Dupree, Justin Wasson [uncommitted])
Version 3 is the version that was inserted into the yellow folder containing the new member handouts. It read:
Membership & Meeting Setup – Membership attendance records, meeting setup, credentialing for voting
I suppose it does not make a lot of difference in Version 3 that they left off the names of the team members and Team Leader.
But if you are going to present something as an item of business that has been voted upon and passed,
Maybe you should not add and/or omit words.
Because if you do, you run the risk of appearing to be corrupt in your intentions.
We can also see that between the time of the 1st version (the one that was actually voted upon, and passed) and the second, they have evidently "reconsidered" who they wished to be Team Leader.
This attempt to"reconsider" was rejected by the Central Committee, since the Committee had voted for Justin Wasson to be Team Leader.
Then, they made the most interesting discovery.
They informed the Central Committee that in Robert's Rules of Order, it says:
It is the duty of the Secretary to keep a register or roll of the members.
So, by golly, it was, according to them, the SECRETARY who should be the Team Leader.
Notice how they discovered this only after their first attempt to displace Mr. Wasson failed.
This attempt by the Executives to usurp the authority of the Membership & Meeting Setup Team Leader was also soundly rejected by the Central Committee.
Now, we have a mostly NEW Central Committee.
And that might be why our Secretary kept making the claim that he is in charge of the membership records.
Now, I could point out that the Secretary also keeps the record of the minutes of the general meeting, but does not run the meeting.
This, however, is not necessary.
While our By Laws DO say,
IX. RULES OF ORDER Robert's Rules of Order Revised shall prevail unless modified by these by-laws;
Our by-laws, as it should happen, are also pretty specific about the duties of the Secretary.
3. The duties of the Secretary are to keep the minutes of the meetings and read them at the following meeting, unless waived.
Do take note that in our By-Laws, the duties of the Secretary do NOT say:
3. The duties of the Secretary are to keep the minutes of the meetings and read them at the following meeting, unless waived. and any other duties mentioned in Robert's Rules of Order.
So, despite the desires of our Secretary, Mr. Gary Ellis, and the rest of the Executives, the legitimate Team Leader remains the one elected by the Central Committee.
That Team Leader happens to be Mr. Justin Wasson.
To paraphrase the late Justice Scalia, the By-Laws
"Say what they say and don't say what they don't say."
And never should the past be altered to reflect what one should wish it would say.
Monday, 15 February 2016
The Caucus Behind The Curtain
We live in an era of Revisionist History.
Everything seems to be rewritten to fit an agenda.
Those of us who experienced the recent Linn County GOP caucus,
Came away with certain impressions that the Executive Committee do not share.
They have been broadcasting how excellent they were.
To quote our Chair:
"After our record-breaking Caucus, we are on our way to a successful 2016 Republican Election victory."
I must say it was record breaking, if the records you wanted to break were in: Chaos, driving people away in frustration, and total pandemonium.
If those are the records to break, then the Mega Caucuses at the Double Tree, and to a lesser extent, at Kirkwood, were roaring successes.
I have some video clips of the crowded conditions and a couple of opinions given by people who attended--and who don't seem to agree with our leadership.
Crowd 1 Crowd2 Interview 1 Interview 2
Just click on the link to download the clip and then open the file.
Sunday, 14 February 2016
From The Same People Who Brought You Mega-Caucus
The Founding Fathers were concerned about tyranny, that of the despot and that of the majority.
Which is why they set up our government with checks and balances and formed a constitutionally based Representative Republic.
Our Linn County Republican Central Committee is also set up with checks and balances, a constitution, and bylaws.
One of the foremost tools to prevent abuse of power is found in the section on the Executive Committee in the County Constitution:
The Executive Committee is subject to the orders of the Linn County Central Committee, and none of its acts shall conflict with actions of the Linn County Central Committee.
Regretfully, we have an Executive Committee which is convinced that due to the purity of their intent.
If there is a section of the County Constitution, the By-Laws, or the Rules of Order which forbid their actions,
Such strictures are optional.
They are not adverse, either, in creating a faux crisis and engaging in what one might term "creative reality" to achieve their goals.
Last year, during the first meeting of the Committee after the officers' election they, breathlessly informed the body that
Robert's Rules of Order stated that all actions--motions, committees, etc., established before the officers' election were voided by it and had to be replaced.
THIS WAS NOT TRUE.
The also informed the body that a gentleman who is in Republican circles in Iowa, the "go-to guy" for parliamentary procedure, had told them this.
THIS WAS NOT TRUE.
And of course, all of this meant they we had to completely redo all these things they claimed that were NOT TRUE,
RIGHT NOW,
And that there was not time to think about it and debate it at a later month's meeting.
So, we adopted their motion, which contained a few poison pills.
The thriving sub-committees, including Finance, which handled all of the budgeting decisions; Communications, which included web activities and press releases; and Credentials, which ensured that the voting was consistent with the by-laws and limited to only elected committeepersons; were all eliminated, and replaced with "Teams."
Previously, anyone could join a subcommittee and have voting rights, but the "Teams" were limited to five voting members, including the "Team Leader." The "Team Leaders" had already been appointed by the Executives, and most of the voting members had already been chosen by the Executives, the Team Leader would decide who could be on a team.
Then at a later meeting, they presented their opinion that the Executive Committee Secretary should replace the "Team Leader" of the "Membership & Meeting Setup" team.
This was, of course, AFTER they tried to edit the original motion to replace the Team Leader voted in with someone else, and were called on it.
Did I mention they engage from time to time in creative reality?
I have a copy of the second version which includes the wording:
To accomplish this, the Executive Committee moves to accept the following plan for 2015-2016 Election Cycle: APPROVED BY VOTE OF THE LCRCC 3/17/15
The problem was this section:
Membership & Meeting Setup – Membership records, meeting setup, credentialing for voting (Mike Dupree, Deb Dupree, Justin Wasson uncommitted)
You see, the version that was actually VOTED on,
Had Justin Wasson as the Team Leader. Not Mike Dupree.
Now, they have found a section of Robert's Rules of Order which states that the Secretary keeps the records of the membership list.
So, they decided to replace the Team Leader again with someone else this time--the Secretary.
The Central Committee, by a resounding margin, rejected this and reaffirmed Mr. Wasson as the Team Leader.
This was almost a year ago.
Yet, it now seems they have decided upon a new tactic.
We had recent precinct caucuses, and the Form As have all the new committee persons listed.
The Executive Committee has not seen fit to deliver this information to the Membership and Meeting Setup Team, which was given the duty by the Central Committee to handle:
Membership records, meeting setup, credentialing for voting
Recall that this is the wording of their own motion to the body, which was adopted, and now they do not wish to abide by it.
I head some muttering that the Form As need to be..."credentialed?"
Anything resembling "credentialing" is accomplished when the Caucus Chair and Secretary sign them.
No, this is yet another blatant power play by the Executive Committee, which chooses not to follow the County Constitution, where it says:
The Executive Committee is subject to the orders of the Linn County Central Committee, and none of its acts shall conflict with actions of the Linn County Central Committee.
Friday, 12 February 2016
Is That The Ice Cracking I Hear?
I just got an interesting IM on Facebook
Xxxxx wants to know when the next GOP central
committee meeting is so he can go talk about caucus
fiasco. I showed him your blog this morning. I don't know
if he had time to read it thoroughly. Yyyy
So we have somone who has never read this blog and because they need to know when the Linn County Central Committee meet is, they have not much experience with the Committee meetings
I do not know how much experience they have had with Caucuses but from the wording of the message they are not pleased with what they have had.
I for one would be interested in they have to say, Shoud they attend.
Our meeting may be a tad like Fat Tuesday
Thursday, 11 February 2016
Byzantine Book Keeping
The Numbers associated with this Years Caucuses certainly were as convoluted as any complex book keeping in the Byzantine Empire
From someone associated with the last Caucus I got the news that this one only took in 12K which meant it was 10K below what was in the bank account when our Present County Chair took over
But then someone associated with the Present Caucus said No it was the 2012 Caucus which took in 12K.
Dan Lincoln bag donations increased about $7000 from 4 years ago and exceeded the 1.50 per person threshold. You may want to correct your recent post. I believe the Lincoln bag number from 4 years ago was around 12k. The number you are thinking of includes delegate fees that were collected caucus night 4 years ago.
What they had in common was each was wrong about the other Caucus
I did get some accurate figures on this Caucus from the Treasurer
Total funds depostited after the Caucus $27,503.17 and he
informed me the split in funds were about 19K for LCRCC donationa
and 8K for the Convention Fees.
My Correspondent for this years Caucus did provide me with the DR-2 forms for the 2012 Caucuses.
You can access them HERE
He also informed me there were more Cedar Rapids Sites than I mentioned in a previous article
Also there were 6 sites with Cedar Rapids precincts. In addition to the 3 you listed you have New Covenant, New Life Church, and King of Kings.
I stand corrected on the number of Cedar Rapids Caucus site, but in truth I do not think that has any bearing one the pandemonium and chaos of he Mega-Caucus sites and I recall NO ONE who was happy with the situation
As a matter of fact I was almost not elected to be a Central Commitee Person because one person made the claim that anyone who had been previously on the Committee should not be re elected
I told them I had nothing to do with the Disaster of the Double Tree Caucuses and had tried to prevent it.
A young friend who has been active in the Central Committee weeded out the information for the 2012 Caucuses from the DR-2s for me, for which I gratefully sprung for a steak dinner
The results from 4 years ago were
The following is information regarding financials from the 2012 caucus:
-
- Unitemized pass the hat money on caucus night - $16,113.26
- Itemized pass the hat money on caucus night - $2682
- Total contributions on caucus night - $18795.26
- Total paid on caucus night for conventions - $4950
- 25 people paid for convention at the following monthly meeting. Many paid shortly after that and we accepted payment at the door.
Also something worth noting, pass the hat in January of 2012 was $225.81 which was a fairly typical amount every month back then.
It would appear donations to the Committee were about the same. Pre-paid Convention fees were up
That latter point is very welcome because this time any unused seats of the 167 allocated for Linn County must be paid for,
I am however confused on what we will pay, I seem to remember the State figure for the District and State Conventions being $50 and what was collected for that Feb 1 was $60 .
So do we owe RPI $60 per seat or did our Executives just decide to charge our members an extra $10 for collecting the State's Fees?
We can find out how much we got stuck for at next weeks Central Committee meeting
It will also be interesting to see how close we come at the meeting to the bucket collection of 4 years ago of $225.81
That's about 3 times what the bucket has been collecting
And yes I know we have made the $125 dollar room fee for quite a few months.
But I also know there is a member of the Committee who each month writes a check to cover what the bucket does not and that is why I say $225.81 is about 3 times what the bucket has been collecting.
Still we need to keep in mind the real problem is not that we did not take any more money in than 4 years ago while we spent at least 10K more but it is the total chaos that ensued
And the number of people who got frustrated and left
If anyone needs to be reminded or was fortunate enough not to Caucus at a Mega site let me remind you.
And if a picture is worth a thousand words, I wonder that a video is worth
Friday, 5 February 2016
Pig In A Poke
It will not come as a surprise to anyone that the Tea Party was not the first to object to excessive Taxation.
In order to avoid taxation on piglets farmers and their customer used to rendez-vous in the dead of night to make the transaction,
The pig was often in a poke,
Problem was sometimes it was not a pig but a cat that got let out of the bag later.
The Linn County Republican Central Committee just recently had a similiar experience with the outcome of our Leadership's new concept of how the Presidential Caucuses should go.
I refer to the Pig in the Poke meme because with the exception of two of our members almost everyone who had REAL experience with setting up Caucuses was shut out of the planning
The rest of the Committee was also shut out,
We were told that the Caucus Team Leader was invoking his "Singular Authority" to declare the Caucus Team Meetings closed.
Oh and two member that did have experience?
It was not deemed necessary to allow them to have a vote on the Team
Central Committtee members will recall when the new Team Organization was rushed through committee hidden was the detail that only 5 Team members on a Team could vote and it seemed like the Exectuives decided who they would be.
That describes the Pig we thought we were buying
And what can describe the Cat that was let out of the Bag during the Caucus debacle?
Well first as our Chair Cindy Golding told us at our last meeting before Caucuses
There WAS a rumor that all the Precincts would meet in ONE location
That was NOT the case as our Chair Cindy Golding pointed out
But like Mark Twain's description of the "Best Way to Tell A Lie"
Ms Gokling left a few things out.
Which was for the first few months of their deliberations the rumor that all of the GOP Precinct in Linn County would met in a single location came from
The Caucus Team
Who were asked that quesiton on several occasions
Until another rumor emerged that to have it in one location would cost several times what we had in the Bank account.
So we ended up with quite a few locations in the County most having 2 or 3 Precints in one location
And 3 for ALL of Cedar Rapids
One at Bethany Lutheran.
Some at Kirkwood
And 30 Precincts at the Double Tree (in 3 rooms)
Other things which emerged like Cats being let out of a bag was the intense frustration many felt at the crowded and chaotic conditions.
There were thousands of people at the Wreck of the Double Tree who were very upset with the process. Among the problems were the inability to check-in, trouble finding your caucus location, way too few seats available, starting more than 30 minutes late, not getting to break out into your precinct until 8:30pm, no one could hear their caucus chairs because of all the surrounding noise, no place to count ballots, limited to no handicap and elderly accessibility, poor signage, too few check-in people, and the list goes on.
I sure hope you do not do this horrible caucus system again
for a presidential caucus. It was too disorganized, did not
start on time and many potential caucus goes left because
they could not get registered to vote? More than anyone
would want to admit.
If anyone wants to know if the statement many potential caucus goers left because they could not get registered to vote is an exageration.
Well they do way a picture is worth a thousand words
And if a picture is worth a thousand words, I wonder that a video is worth
What is really sickening is to run the numbers for this event
Last time we spent about twice what Johnson County did which is not surprising as we have twice their population
THIS time we spent about TEN THOUSAND Dollars more than we did last time
To put that in REAL perspective we spent around One Thousand Dollars TOTAL last time.
And what did we get for our extra Ten Thousand Dollar expendature?
The Buck Bags we sent around for donations were
DOWN by
TEN THOUSAND DOLLARS
Yes our Pig in the Poke Mega Caucus Media Event
Cost 10K more and took in 10K less.
You do the rest of the Math
The ONLY thing that keeps Linn County Iowa from being the laughing stock of the Nation is what happened in Polk County
The lets decide a Precinct Caucus by flipping a coin.
For those involved in the planning of Monday Night there is one bright light
That this was an event held by the Linn County Republican Central Committee.
Had it been run by say the Mafia?
Those responsible might be resting at the bottom of the Cedar River with brand new shoes on.
Wednesday, 3 February 2016
A Successful Iowa Republican Caucus
This was our ONLY single Precinct Caucus site and is a good example of how
thigns SHOULD go. Reported by Bill Dahlsten
Linn County Republicans in Cedar Rapids precinct 24 (CR-24) caucused on Feb. 1, 2016. It was a large caucus. It was a presidential caucus. It was a successful caucus.
Other Republicans in Linn County say their caucus the same evening was not successful. Why did CR-24 have a successful caucus?
Republicans in CR-24 ran a standalone caucus. About 15 Republicans in CR-24 organized and ran the caucus. CR-24 was not part of a mass forced together beyond the critical point of chaos. This almost did not happen.
CR-24 was originally supposed to be part of a mass caucus site at Cedar Rapids downtown Double Tree Hotel. As the word of this spread, some Republicans in CR-24 were not pleased. Bruce Lindholm and I looked at sites ourselves and found Bethany Lutheran Church was available as a caucus site.
Bethany Lutheran is CR-24's polling place. Bethany Lutheran has a large events room. Bethany Lutheran has a good sized parking lot. CR-24 Republicans filled Bethany Lutheran on Feb. 1st. .
A precinct caucus is not held to convenience office seekers. A precinct caucus is not held as a circus to draw media attention. A precinct caucus is held for residents of the precinct.
What the presidential candidates themselves had to say had already been paid broadcast and blast called to all. A member of the caucus got two minutes at the podium to advocate for each presidential candidate.
What mattered to the advocating speaker was heard. It was what each caucus speaker believed their candidate could bring for the good of all. It was a fresh take on the message in contrast to consultant provided sound bites tested before focus groups.
All in CR-24's caucus heard what the speakers said. There was no cross talk over another caucus, or worse yet multiple caucuses jammed in together.
Balloting commenced a little around 7:30. Bruce Lindholm thankfully discarded the tiny, blank ballots supplied in the caucus kit. Blue paper ballots with names preprinted produced by Bruce expedited ballot counting. Just before 8:00 Dr. Don Nelson reported CR-24's presidential results to Des Moines.
280 and presidential ballots were cast in CR-24. Most of those present left after the announcement. About 15-25 stay for electing county central committee and other party business. That is about the same number of CR-24 Republicans who caucus in off years.
$806 was collected in the Lincoln Bag. Required reports were filled out and turned in.
Many who caucused in CR-24 expressed gratitude they were not mass caucusing in downtown Cedar Rapids. Many said they never would have attended such a caucus. That number included a few of approximately 15 people who volunteered to help run the caucus.
The most rewarding aspect of single site caucusing was seeing the elderly participants. Bethany Lutheran was easily accessible for them. The distance to walk from the front door to a chair was short.
I attended my first Iowa Republican caucus in 1972. That caucus was a small gathering held in the living room of Fred and Sally Bell in Burlington. Other than the number caucusing, my 22nd Iowa Republican caucus at Bethany Lutheran Church in 2016 was much the same.
Republican neighbors gathered within their precinct to caucus. They got down to business. They debated and discussed issues in an orderly manner. They kept the caucus process moving and went home happy at a decent hour.
William H. Dahlsten
CR-24 Linn County Republican Party Central Committee
The Republicans of CR-24 commenced their caucus on time. The caucus flowed at a steady pace. Candidates did not interrupt CR-24's caucus. There was better candidate advocacy to be heard.
Tuesday, 2 February 2016
Charge of the Infernal Caucus
In the annals of the human race, there are instances of situations where if those involved had been given a choice beforehand, they might have declined altogether.
Among these are the Charge of the Light Brigade, Dante's Inferno, and the 2016 GOP Linn County Iowa Caucuses.
For those who think my use of the image of a herd of stampeding Elephants is hyperbole, may I present this link to a video of the pandemonium?
THAT is what you get when you try to squeeze 30 Precincts into one location.
Most people would realize that your average person might show up at the last moment, and if your expected numbers are going to be between 3500 and 4000 at that location?
It will not be tidy.
I told all my friends, in particular, the ones who told me they had been informed to arrive about 6:30,
"No NO NO!
"5:30 or earlier!"
As for myself, I took a cab downtown at about 4:00, got a bite to eat, and then went and checked things out.
Sometimes things are even worse than you imagined.
I counted the seats for my precinct and thought,
Not enough.
I was right.
People for my precinct and others ended up standing.
It seemed like it took until about 8:00 for the Presidential addresses to start.
By the time they finished the Presidential addresses, it was around the same time we had finished the entire Caucus four years ago.
Then the question was,
Where to count the ballots?
It wasn't like there were tables available to place them on and count them.
How could there be tables, when there wasn't even enough room for all of the chairs we would have needed?
I spotted a bare portion of wall with some space in front of it.
Our candidate witnesses and counters knelt down, much like a football huddle.
They put the ballots in the middle and counted them there.
While they were counting, almost everyone left.
At our last presidential year caucus, OVER 90% of ours attendees stayed for the rest of the business.
This year I don't think 10% stayed.
To put this in persepctive:
Presidential polls did not take place during Iowa Caucuses until the 70s.
Their original purpose was to conduct party business:
To elect County Central Commitee persons to represent the precincts for the following two years;
To appoint members of the County Convention committees: Organization, Credentials, Rules, and Platform;
And to appoint delegates to the County, District, and State Conventions.
As far as fulfilling the original purpose of the caucus in Linn County--at least, at the Doubletree--this year was an abysmal failure.
As for the Presidential poll?
Considering how many people decided to leave and not participate even before the Presidential voting,
There is no way of telling how much damage was done and to whom.
I do not know how others may view the Doubletree Cataclysm.
But as for me?
I give our leadership a score of ONE DUMP.
Wednesday, 20 January 2016
Executive Orders
There has been some discussion in Republican, or maybe Conservative and Libertarian circles;
About the decision of our current President to handle with Executive Orders things which he feels are not being handled the way he wishes by Congress. This is, in the opinion of many, side-stepping the Constitution and the Rule of Law.
It would seem this attitude is not limited to Barack Obama on the Federal Level, but can also be seen in the attitude and activity of the Linn County Republican Central Committee Chair, Cindy Golding.
Two months ago, at our November meeting, a motion was made to continue holding our monthly meetings at the Longbranch, where our committee has met for the better part of several decades. The motion was tabled, as the time was approaching 8:30--the chair's firmly enforced adjournment time!
However, at our January meeting, our Executives announced that rather than honoring the Motion in Force to debate and vote on the status of where our meeting should be held, they had instead DECIDED;
That they were going to do a "SURVEY" of the subject after the Caucus.
On the surface, there might be some logic in this, as after the Caucus, there will be a brand new Committee.
Of course, if it were not for their insistence that we adjourn at a set time, rather than after the business we have before us is finished, this issue would have been dealt with months ago.
But the REAL issue is that the Executives DO NOT HAVE THE AUTHORITY to override a decision of the Body with one of their own.
And doing so is a VIOLATION of the Constitution of the Republican Party of Linn County, which states:
The Executive Committee is subject to the orders of the Linn County Central Committee, and none of its acts shall conflict with actions of the Linn County Central Committee.
It was, in fact, the right of the Committee to make that decision rather than the Executives.
I rose on a Point of Order to bring this out,
And the above-mentioned requirements of the Constitution were ignored by the Chair, Cindy Golding.
That was not the only dubious action by the County Chair, Cindy Golding, at the January meeting.
She also kept bringing up the subject of previous rumors of the Linn County Caucuses being held in a single location.
It is true that there WERE in the past rumors to that effect.
The source of those rumors were the Caucus Team, whose members were asked several times in the first few months if this were true, and answered in the affirmative.
We later heard that after they determined that the cost would be two, maybe three times the amount of money we had in our entire treasury, it was decided to have some Caucuses in more than one location. Of course, that was also just a rumor.
Still, all of Cedar Rapids' 44 precincts will be in a very few locations, the largest of which being the Downtown Double Tree Hotel and Convention Center, with a whopping 30 Precincts packed into three rooms.
It should be an interesting Caucus.
As to the Constitutional issues that arose at the LCRCC January meeting, there are several campaigns who seem to have very good ground games.
They might end up placing some of their people on the County Central Committee.
The Candidates seem to honor the Constitution and the Rule of Law.
I hope to see that their supporters, should they end up on the Central Committee, choose to Walk the Walk rather than Talk the Talk;
And also honor Constitutions and the Rule of Law.
Especially since it appears that the Linn County Republican Central Committee Chair, Cindy Golding...
Does NOT.
Saturday, 16 January 2016
First Ever We Are Breitbart - Cedar Rapids Meetup
We Are Breitbart - Cedar Rapids
20 Happy Warriors going, including:
| "I'm a God fearing, conservative, red headed, full bearded, red blooded Texan. I..." |
| "Intl law & trade, food/water/property/human rights and health interest me. Avid reader,..." |
Had enough of Obama’s trampling of the Constitution and squelching of American freedoms? Join like-minded conservatives and make new friends as we discuss and share ideas about liberty, politics, and culture at the first-ever We Are Breitbart - Cedar...
LEARN MORE
Newer | Latest | Older
