Site hosted by Angelfire.com: Build your free website today!

 

















[ Index ]
 

 
We urge the Cabinet to avoid disrupting thousands of schools affecting three millions primary school children in the country. Most Malaysians agree that we must raise the proficiency and popularity of English without forgetting the mother tongues. S
Statement by Dr Tan Seng Giaw, DAP National Vice-Chairman and MP for Kepong on the Malaysian Cabinet decision to persist with the Government formula to teach Mathematics and Science in English. 14.11.2002.

 
Most Malaysians agree that we must raise the proficiency and popularity of English without forgetting the mother tongues. The Government has made a decision to teach mathematics and Science in English from primary one to improve Engish and to gain knowledge.

The Government has politicized the issue of English Maths and Science. Yesterday, after the Cabinet meeting, the Deputy Prime Minister Dato' Seri Abdullah Ahmad Badawi said : "It should not be politicizedˇ­there should not be any contention that the Government is trying to undermine the position of the Chinese language. The majority has accepted the move which is intended for all and not Chinese students only." The action of the Government will show whether it does or does not undermine the position of the mother tongue.

We should not politicize the issue. However, if the Government is serious about it, it should be more open and more ready to accept alternatives. After all, we don't know if the Education Ministry's formula including 2-4-3 will work. If it doesn't, what do we do next?

Can the Government be sure that alternatives such as 1-2-3 formula

would not be effective? Introducing English early as a separate subject with good teachers is logical. Learning Maths and Science in primary schools in the mother tongue or home language is natural.

The Cabinet has decided that there will be "no turning back" on the issue. English will be taught in the ways judged by the Government.

DISRUPTION

As the Government makes the decision, about 10,000 schools are in quandary. Nearly three millions children in primary schools will be affected. To some extent, about two million students in secondary schools have new syllabuses.

The schools are closed for two months' holidays. They have to plan for 2003 such as teachers, syllabuses and textbooks. Now, they are waiting for the Education Department to brief them on the details of the Cabinet decision.

To bulldoze over the teaching related to English does not augur well. The disruption to schoolteachers and students is bad. There is unhappiness. The Government should keep the disruption to the minimum. One way is to stop riding roughshod over the people.


Dr Tan Seng Giaw

 

 
[ Home | Political | Medical | Personal ] Article #418
[ Recent | Archives | Forum | Feedback ] [ Index ]