|
Score
|
5 or 4
|
3 or 2
|
1 or 0
|
| Ideas and Content |
Information is accurate and current
Ideas come mainly from primary sources
Authors show knowledge and insight
Effective use of technology demonstrated
All information relates to the overall purpose
|
Information not always clear
Primary source use is not always clear
Content connections not always clear
Does not relate content to larger context
No way to check validity of information
Strong purpose not demonstrated
|
Information incomplete or inaccurate
Information not from primary sources
Little or no overall context for information
Value of information is unclear
No way to check validity of information
Lacks sense of purpose or central theme
0
|
|
Score
|
5 or 4
|
3 or 2
|
1 or 0
|
| Organization |
Inviting opening page draws the visitor inside
Details are logical and effective
Layout of pages provides good direction
How to explore an idea is clear
Each page begins with a clear transition
Easy to navigate through the pages
|
Inconsistent structure of pages
Sequencing is inconsistent
Some pages incomplete
Some links disjointed; lack purpose
Unclear connections among sections
Sense of being lost or unsure navigating
3
|
No orientation for visitors
Sequencing unclear
Pages lack closure
No focus for links
Pages are inconsistent
Difficult to navigate in an organized way
|
|
Score
|
5 or 4
|
3 or 2
|
1 or 0
|
| Language and Conventions |
Organizational structure is clear and coherent
Grammar and usage are correct
Punctuation is accurate
Spelling is generally correct
Site needs little or no editing
5
|
Long or incomplete paragraphs
Minor problems with grammar or usage
Internal punctuation sometimes missing or wrong
Spelling is usually correct
Site needs some editing
|
Paragraph structure is missing
Errors in grammar or usage noticeable
Many punctuation mistakes
Frequent spelling errors
Site needs extensive editing
|
|
Score
|
5 or 4
|
3 or 2
|
1 or 0
|
| Presentation |
Web site is clearly identified; easy to find
The layout is clear and easy to follow
Backgrounds and text work well together
Graphical elements are used consistently
Multimedia adds to the main purpose
Links are appropriate
|
Web site easy to find
Layout of most pages is easy to follow
Backgrounds are text were not effective
Inconsistent or inappropriate graphics
Multimedia sometimes doesn't add
Use of links is unclear
2
|
Web site hard to find
Layout is confusing or inappropriate
Backgrounds and text not effective
Graphics only decorative or confusing
Multimedia unrelated to the topic
Too many unrelated links, or too few links
|
|
Score
|
5 or 4
|
3 or 2
|
1 or 0
|
| Technical |
Links work properly
Graphics are optimized
Works in all browsers
Works in text only mode
Multimedia resources work properly
4
|
Not all links work properly
Graphics are generally optimized
Pages don't work in all browsers
Text-only mode could be improved
Multimedia resources work most of the time
|
Links don't work properly
Graphic elements not optimized
Specific browsers needed
Text only mode does not work
Resources fail to work
|
