I left Karachi in 1983, for college. Each time I returned, it was with the
critical eye of a growing political consciousness. Karachi was curfew,
sniper-fire, slums; corrupt police, trigger-happy rangers, boundary walls
that grew ever higher and more forbidding. Karachi was neighborhoods where
friends and family lived - replete with trees and gardens and clubs - and
neighborhoods to pass by or pass through with the car windows rolled up.
This Karachi was about words - words like "Muhajir," "democracy,"
"feudalism" and "martial law."
When I returned to Karachi in 1996, it was with a mission, both
intellectual and aesthetic, to make sense of the city of my birth - through
photography. It is deceptively easy to visually "know" Karachi - a city
that began as a fishing village named for a dancing girl (Kolachi) and
rapidly developed into a cosmopolitan sea port under colonial rule. You
find the familiar divisions of cantonment and native town in Karachi -
grid-like city quarters bordering winding mohallas. You see neo-gothic
cathedrals and make-shift dargah sharifs; imposing mosques and national
monuments, and crumbling Sikh and Hindu temples. There are vivid traces of
the populations that have fled; and a polyphonic, sensory clamor of the
populations that have arrived. The city expands, ever wider, ever higher;
more and more villages on the outskirts are getting "incorporated" into the
city; innumerable concrete high rises now tower beside colonial buildings
of yellow gizri stone.
It is tempting, when photographing the city, to revel in architecture,
skyline, reti and bajri. But Karachi is a place where all too often, the
people get forgotten. Who cares about yellow gizri stone and colonial
monuments, when there are heroin addicts crouched in front of them,
shielding spoon and match from the westerly wind? I was determined, both
aesthetically and politically, that people be in the foreground of these
photographs, and the buildings, the landscape, their background. The first
photographs I took when I returned to Karachi in 1996 for my year-long
odyssey were remote, far off, passer-by visions - of tiny people, vistas,
horizons. I was dissatisfied; I wanted my "proximity senses" to
participate in what I was to "know" about this city - thus, the addict's
face, the sweet smell of burning hashish, the sting of mati on my neck.
And I moved in closer.
Karachi is an extremely difficult place to photograph. In addition to the
heat, lack of adequate materials and severe water shortages, one is
confronted with the undeniably violent tenor of the city: after only two
short months I had been beaten up twice by street toughs, had my car
stolen, and had numerous unpleasant encounters with the notoriously corrupt
Karachi police, seeking to extort money from hapless citizens. There is a
kind of safety in skylines, horizons, that you forego when you move in
closer. When I look at these photographs, I can't help but hear the sounds
of this dangerous intimacy: the scuff of laathis on white starched police
uniforms; the crackle of film buckling in the intense humidity; the snap of
a fresh magazine being loaded into a casually-held kalashnikov.