[In today's edition of The Independent, Robert Fisk reports on the dramatic letter sent to the survivors of the Sabra and Shatilla massacres twenty years ago by the Coalition of Women for a Just Peace, an Israeli women's peace coalition.

The letter clearly touched the hearts of the recipients, judging from the sorts of responses Fisk reports. Crucially, the letter does not refrain from naming the current Israeli Prime Minister, Ariel Sharon as a war criminal responsible for the massacre, as he was found to be two decades ago by Israel's own Kahan Commission (which said that Sharon was "indirectly" responsible, owing to the fact that he was deemed responsible, through the commanders under him, for issuing orders that Israeli troops surround the camp, allow the Phalange militia into it and not interfere with the murder and mayhem they then proceeded to carry out).

It is also yet another reminder of who has been in the forefront for so long in the Israeli peace camp. When others wilted, confused by the myth of Barak's generous offer and bewildered by the increasing violence between Israel and the Palestinians, women's peace groups in Israel have been steadfast and consistent in their words and deeds in support of peace. Again, feminist peace groups are leading the way toward communication, solidarity and understanding over violence and vengeance. Comparable efforts on the Palestinian side are also taking place daily, as evidenced by the persistence of the Jerusalem Link, an organization that brings together Israeli and Palestinian women for dialogue and joint action. Peace movements outside the region are also moving forward behind the leadership of courageous and wise women. Feminist and women's groups are leading the way to peace. It is up to the rest of us to follow them rather than those who are leading us all to greater death and carnage. - MP]


Prosecute Sharon for war crimes, Israeli women say

By Robert Fisk in Beirut
24 September 2002

In an astonishing letter to the Palestinian survivors of the 1982 Sabra and Shatila camps massacres, nine Israeli women's peace groups have told Palestinians in Beirut that they support their efforts to indict the Israeli Prime Minister, Ariel Sharon, for "war crimes'' committed against them almost exactly 20 years ago.

The women's letter, which was sent via the United States, has amazed the Lebanese lawyer representing the survivors of the massacre, for which Mr Sharon was held "personally responsible'' by an Israeli inquiry. "It is a wonderful gesture,'' Chibli Mallat said yesterday. "It is a wonderful message to receive in these very dangerous and violent times.''

The letter, from the Coalition of Women for A Just Peace in Israel, speaks movingly of the suffering of the Palestinians in 1982. "Our hearts ache to recall the terrible massacre that took place in the Sabra and Shatila refugee camps 20 years ago, which Israeli leaders allowed to take place,'' it says. "We condemn the brutal murderers of your loved ones and we condemn the leaders who must be held accountable for these war crimes, Ariel Sharon above all.''

A Belgian court ruled earlier this year that it could not indict Mr Sharon for the killings, but more than 20 survivors of the massacre, whose lawyers include Mr Mallat, are now appealing against this decision.

Up to 1,700 Palestinians were butchered in the massacre by Lebanese militiamen allied to the Israelis. Israeli troops surrounded the camps as the killings went on but were told by their commanders not to interfere.

Mr Sharon was Israeli Minister of Defence at the time and was forced to resign after the Israeli Kahan commission condemned him and several senior Israeli officers for not preventing the slaughter.

The women's letter recalls how the Palestinians were forced to flee their homes in 1948. " We join you in mourning for those who were killed and maimed [in 1982] and we condemn those who are responsible,'' it says. "We hope you will accept the sincerity of our words and allow us to stand in solidarity with you as we strive to build peace with justice between Israel and Palestine.''

Mohamed abu Rudeina, who as a seven-year-old boy saw his father and other relatives murdered 20 years ago, described the Israeli women's letter as a "moving act'' that would greatly encourage other Palestinian survivors who are seeking justice for the deaths of their loved ones.

The specific mention of Mr Sharon's name is likely to cause considerable discomfort to the Israeli Prime Minister, who hired lawyers to defend him in Brussels and who has not previously experienced any attempt by Israelis to indict him.

Mr Mallat said it was the first gesture of solidarity to the camp survivors from Israelis, 20 years after a lone Israeli, Emile Grunzweig, was killed by a hand grenade thrown into a crowd of protesters in Tel Aviv. "We regard Mr. Grunzweig as an Israeli who died for Sabra and Shatila,'' Mr Mallat said. "Now at last, we seem to have got support from Israelis about the terrible crimes against humanity which occurred in Beirut two decades ago.''

Jewish Peace News (JPN) is an edited news-clipping and commentary service provided by A Jewish Voice for Peace. JPN's editors are Adam Gutride, Amichai Kronfeld, Rela Mazali, Sarah Anne Minkin, Judith Norman, Mitchell Plitnick, Lincoln Shlensky, and Alistair Welchman. The opinions expressed by the editors and presented in the articles sent to this list are solely those of their authors, and do not necessarily reflect the viewpoints of A Jewish Voice for Peace.

A Jewish Voice for Peace (JVP) is a San Francisco Bay Area grassroots organization dedicated to the human, civil and economic rights of Jews, Palestinians, and all peoples in the Middle East.

Donating to A Jewish Voice for Peace is easy. Just go to our website at www.jewishvoiceforpeace.org. There, you can either donate online using your credit card or you can find our mailing address to send us a check. All contributions are tax-deductible. Your support is greatly appreciated.

For more information about JVP, please visit our web site at http://www.jewishvoiceforpeace.org

To SUBSCRIBE to Jewish Peace News, our daily news and information service, please send an email message to:


To JOIN the Jewish Voice for Peace community mailing list (no more than one message per week), which features Middle East peace information and local Jewish community activist updates, please send an email message to: