Site hosted by Angelfire.com: Build your free website today!

Debunking Christians On "Human Soul"


The mystical trend of our time, which shows itself particularly in the rampant growth of the so-called Theosophy and Spiritualism, is for me no more than a symptom of weakness and confusion. Since our inner experiences consist of reproductions, and combinations of sensory impressions, the concept of a soul without a body seem to me to be empty and devoid of meaning -Albert Einstein
What is a Soul
Back in the old days when religious people never heard of biochemistry or neural activity (not to mention that they believe that the sun orbits the earth, but that is a different story), they believe that some sort of ghost that live within us called a "soul". This soul, they believe, is the actual us and not the human body. The human body is suppose to be some sort of shell or container that hold this soul inside of us. Anyway, according to christians (and other religious people), after you die, your soul is suppose to be released out of your body. Think of it like air seeping out of a broken seal of a ziplock bag. After the soul is release, it is suppose to travel to either a astral plane call a heaven or a hell, depending on the actions you done into this world according to their "god". By the way, the human soul is suppose to be an immortal entity, meaning that it can never die.

The Soul Equals to The Mind
According to most christians, in order for there idea of a soul to be meaningful, the soul must either be the mind itself or the soul must have a connection to the human brain. In other words, the mind is somehow actually not connected to the body at all, it is connected to the soul.

We all know that every thought created by the human brain (including feelings, emotions, memories, etc.), are all combinations of the physiological functions (Chemical and electrical activity) of the human brain.

It is also a scientific fact that as the body grow or mature, so does the human mind/brain. For instance, as babies grow from kids to teenagers to adults, so does there knowledge of certain things that goes on in this world. When a person becomes very old (senior citizen over age 65), as the body becomes feeble, so does the mind. The problem here that I don't understand from most christians or other religious people that believes in a "soul" is, how is it, if the mind is born, grows old, and becomes weak with the body, that the mind does not also die with the body? If the body suffers from a fever, then the mind will suffer feverish delusions. How is it that the feverish mind doesn't die with a feverish body?

Also, if the mind and the soul is connected to each other somehow, what about those people that have or are born with mental disabilities and have brain damage like from a car accident for instance, and they have to end up having brain surgery? Or what about some people like senior citizens that have disease or disorder that mainly effects the brain like Alzheimers (sp?) or children that have Attention Deficit Disorder? What effect does this give out to the soul, if it did in fact exist? It is a known fact that surgeries, diseases, and disorders of the brain do causes certain changes in people like changes in their personalities. If the soul is the real you, you ID for this world and who you are, and if the soul is connected to the brain, then how does these disorders and diseases effect the soul then? I mean does their deity purposely put a "damage" soul into a persons body?

Speaking of disorders that effect the brain and causes personality changes in a person, where are memories or information the brain receives is stored at anyway. Are they actually stored in the brain itself or are they stored in the soul? Again some people tend to lose their memory through such cases as alzheimers disease, ADD, through some sort or major accident, etc. How does your soul remember anything if the brain stores memories, but then loses it through some sort of situation? What happens to those memories that are forgotten or lost? Does the soul somehow finds them so that you can remember every single second of your life so you can still be the person that you are in an afterlife, or does it only get those things that your conscious mind can normally remember?

What is the point of a Immortal Soul Anyway?
One thing (out of thousands of things) that I cannot understand about christians (or other religions) idea of a soul is, what is the point in it? Why do some christians in fact preach that life is important when in fact even after someone dies there immortal soul is then released from there dead human body and lives on somewhere else? When you cherish something, it usually means that you can have it, see it, live it, etc. only once and you never see it etc. again. It is true that life on this planet is very important and that you only live once. However, what is the point to the christians of trying to worry about taking care of life on this planet and prevent death when in fact they can live on forever with there immortal soul, the real them and at a better place called heaven?

The idea of a immortal soul and a afterlife defeats the whole purpose of death and dying in the first place (I will discuss this part of the subject on "My Views On Atheism and Death").

Conclusion
My personal opinion on the so called "soul" that christians are ranting and raving about doesn't exist. Everything actions that a human being performs like sex, emotions, moving, running, sleep, etc. are all electrical and neural activities of the brain. Nothing more.

Return to my Main Page