| First Team |
|---|
| Offense | Defense |
|---|
| QB-Luke Ott, Sr. (St. Norbert) | DL-Chris Staley, Jr. (Beloit) |
| RB-Patrick Bowman, Sr. (Illinois College) | DL-Willie Thompson, Fr. (Illinois College) |
| RB-Troy DeVoe, Sr. (Ripon) | DL-Brian Valentini, Sr. (Monmouth) |
| RB-Jason Augustynowicz, Sr. (St. Norbert) | DL-Jack Kinsey, Sr. (Ripon) |
| WR-Brandy Spoerl, Sr. (Carroll) | LB-Anthony Balthazor, So. (Knox) |
| WR-Dan Henken, Sr. (Ripon) | LB-Casey Urlacher, Jr. (Lake Forest) |
| TE-Nick Vraney, Jr. (Ripon) | LB-Jason Robinson, Jr. (Monmouth) |
| OL-Nate Ray, Jr. (Grinnell) | LB-Jerimiah Janssen, Sr. (St. Norbert) |
| OL-Brett Gerue, Sr. (Monmouth) | DB-Joe Kostiha, Jr. (Beloit) |
| OL-Curtis Maurer, Jr. (Ripon) | DB-Jim Vento, Sr. (Carroll) |
| OL-Jeremy Jackson, Jr. (St. Norbert) | DB-Kevin Keen, Jr. (Knox) |
| OL-Kevin O'Malley, Jr. (St. Norbert) | DB-Travis LeRoy, Jr. (Ripon) |
| K-Pat Dunne, Jr. (Lake Forest) | P-Terry Wood, Sr. (Grinnell) |
| Ret-Brad Guettel, Sr. (Carroll) | ST-Joe Kostiha, Jr. (Beloit) |
| Second Team |
|---|
| Offense | Defense |
|---|
| QB-Jeff Pedersen, Sr. (Grinnell) | DL-Dan Moak, Sr. (Carroll) |
| QB-Brock Bauer, Sr. (Ripon) | DL-Zach Fletcher, Jr. (Grinnell) |
| RB-Scott Muehlemann, Sr. (Beloit) | DL-Matt Lerner, Jr. (Monmouth) |
| RB-Vince Singleton, Jr. (Knox) | DL-Chris Koonce, So. (St. Norbert) |
| RB-Randy Terrell, Sr. (Monmouth) | LB-Mike Dempsey, Jr. (Beloit) |
| WR-Tom Neagle, Fr. (Knox) | LB-A.J. Vassar, So. (Illinois College) |
| WR-Zach Michael, So. (Lawrence) | LB-Scott Dummert, Sr. (Lawrence) |
| TE-Chris McGinley, Jr. (Lawrence) | LB-Tom Counsell, Sr. (Ripon) |
| TE-Mark Schmitz, Sr. (St. Norbert) | LB-Josh Heisler, Sr. (Ripon) |
| OL-Steve Smart, Jr. (Carroll) | DB-Jim Schueller, Jr. (Grinnell) |
| OL-Ryan Van Aken, Sr. (Illinois College) | DB-Jacques Hacquebord, So. (Lawrence) |
| OL-Matt Hancock, Sr. (Knox) | DB-Scott Stanton, Jr. (Monmouth) |
| OL-Ryan Paulsen, Sr. (Lake Forest) | DB-Zack Reblin, Jr. (Ripon) |
| OL-Ryan Pearson, Sr. (Monmouth) | P-Pat Dunne, Jr. (Lake Forest) |
| OL-Aaron Ziesch, Sr. (Ripon) | ST-Antonio Harrison, Fr. (Grinnell) |
| K-Chris Griffin, Jr. (Ripon) | ST-James Gallagher, Jr. (St. Norbert) |
| Ret-Ryan Brown, Sr. (Grinnell) |
|
|
| Honorable Mention |
|---|
| Offense | Defense |
|---|
| QB-Brad Dement, Jr. (Carroll) | DL-Andy Brown, Sr. (Beloit) |
| QB-Derek Leonard, Sr. (Illinois College) | DL-Jacob Bodi, Fr. (Carroll) |
| QB-Mike Erwin, Jr. (Knox) | DL-Wes Prickett, Sr. (Grinnell) |
| QB-Rob Purlee, So. (Monmouth) | DL-Josh Hart, Sr. (Knox) |
| RB-J.C. Radliff, Sr. (Lawrence) | DL-Vince Srejma, So. (Lake Forest) |
| RB-Nick Martin, Sr. (Monmouth) | DL-David Bleitner, Fr. (Lake Forest) |
| WR-Ryan Brown, Sr. (Grinnell) | DL-Tobias Dickerson, Jr. (Monmouth) |
| WR-Jake Peterson, So. (Grinnell) | DL-Jared Simon, Sr. (Ripon) |
| WR-Erik Karhilker, Fr. (Illinois College) | DL-Jason Joush, Sr. (St. Norbert) |
| WR-Nick Rossie, So. (Lake Forest) | LB-Trevor Cassell, Jr. (Grinnell) |
| WR-Randy Williams, Sr. (Monmouth) | LB-Rich Stott, Jr. (Illinois College) |
| WR-Dave Archibald, Jr. (St. Norbert) | LB-Jeff Burke, So. (Knox) |
| WR-Nick Llanas, Jr. (St. Norbert) | LB-Gary Wojdyla, Fr. (Lake Forest) |
| OL-Sam Jones, Fr. (Grinnell) | LB-Rob Rogers, So. (Monmouth) |
| OL-John Allison, Sr. (Illinois College) | LB-Andy Uecker, So. (Ripon) |
| OL-Cory Bonstead, So. (Knox) | LB-James Gallagher, Jr. (St. Norbert) |
| OL-Ben Larkin, So. (Lake Forest) | DB-Frank Quatrino, Sr. (Beloit) |
| OL-Brad Day, Jr. (Ripon) | DB-B.J. Harvey, So. (Illinois College) |
| OL-Dan Lutter, So. (Ripon) | DB-Seth Kopf, So. (Knox) |
| K-John Godish, So. (Grinnell) | DB-Nate Keller, Jr. (Lawrence) |
| K-Chris Griffin, So. (St. Norbert) | DB-Justin Oertle, Jr. (Monmouth) |
| Ret-Travis LeRoy, Jr. (Ripon) | P-Willie Thompson, Fr. (Illinois College) |
| OL-Ryan Reigle, Sr. (St. Norbert) | ST-Scott Stanton, Jr. (Monmouth) |
| | |
