Warning: This story has some slash content. There is some male/male contact in it. If you are uncomfortable with it, please go back or leave this site.
Disclaimer: I do not know Nsync, BSB, or O-town although I wish I did. Please do not ask me how to contact them as I have no idea.
Lance patiently sat in a chair, waiting for the doorbell to ring. Nsync was having a party and they had invited O-town and BSB over. It was going to be the first all guy party they had in ages. Their back-up dancers, Chantal, Kristin, Annalisia, Michelle, and Diana, had all gone to visit their families for a while so the guys would have time to just be guys. Although they missed the girls it was a relief to finally have some time to just be with each other again.
Despite the party about to take place, everything was unusually quiet in the Nsync house. Lance sat in the chair, waiting to answer the door, Justin was upstairs taking a shower, Joey and JC were getting the snacks ready, and Chris was reading. The only sound was the occasional clanging of dishes in the kitchen. However, Lance did not find this odd. It seemed to always happen this way in his opinion. The house was always rowdy when it was just them but it was always quiet when they were expecting company.
Finally, after what seemed like an eternity, the doorbell rang. Lance got up out of his chair to answer it. He threw the door open to find BSB standing on the doorstep. Lance smiled and stepped aside to allow them access to the house. He was just about to close the door when he spotted O-town coming up the walk. So, he left the door open until they had entered the house and shut it behind them.
“Hey guys,” Joey said, coming out of the kitchen with a vegetable tray in his hands. “Glad you could make it.” He set the tray down on the coffee table and smiled at the guests. “JC has the drinks and the chips; he’ll be out in a minute.” As if on cue, JC came out of the kitchen, his arms loaded with chips, dip, wine coolers, and beer bottles.
“Here, let me help you with that,” Howie said, taking half of JC’s loot from his arms and setting it on the table.
“Thanks,” JC said, setting the rest of the stuff down.
“No problem, glad to be of help.” At that time, Chris and Justin entered the room and plopped on the floor. The others all took seats, Lance in his chair, Joey in the other chair, JC, Dan, and Kevin on the couch, and everyone else on the floor with Justin and Chris.
“So what are we doing tonight?” Trevor asked as he reached for a chip, dipped it, and stuck it in his mouth. He was looking at Lance who had surprisingly been the one to come up with the idea to throw the party. Lance’s eyes narrowed and his smile turned into a devilish smirk, an expression that wouldn’t normally be caught dead on Lance’s face.
“I thought we’d try a little experiment,” he replied in a wicked tone that surprised everyone.
“What kind of experiment?” AJ asked curiously. He picked up a beer bottle, popped the cap, and took a long swig. He looked back at Lance with wide eyes.
“Well, first we have to move into the den. It’s the only room with enough space for us all to sit in a circle.” The others glanced at one another before getting up and heading into the den. Erik and Howie helped JC and Joey carry the snacks and drinks into the den, where they set it all down neatly in the middle of the floor before taking their seats in the circle that had already formed. When they had settled themselves, they all turned to look at Lance again.
“Now what?” Chris asked in a pleading voice. They watched as Lance produced an empty beer bottle from behind him. “Where’d you get that? No one’s finished a beer yet.”
“I got it from the recycling bin. It’s a previously drunk bottle.” They all watched with curiosity as he carefully moved the snacks to the outside of the circle and placed the empty beer bottle in the middle. Nick groaned.
“Are we playing ‘Spin the Bottle’? Man, that game is so old.” Lance smiled at him.
“That’s why I’m adding a twist.”
“A twist?” Justin asked. He was getting more and more curious by the minute. It was obvious that Lance had not notified his group of what he had been planning to do.
“What kind of twist?” Erik asked with interest. Lance smiled at him just as he had smiled at Nick.
“I am going to combine ‘Spin the Bottle’ with another popular party game.” The others glanced at each other again and looked back at Lance.
“What game would that be?” Jacob asked. Brian, who was sitting on Jacob’s right side, nodded to second the question.
“Truth or Dare,” Lance said shortly. He watched as all their eyes widened but none more so than Ashley’s, who was the youngest of the fifthteen of them.
“How do you plan on doing that?” Ashley asked, rather hesitantly.
“Simple. First you spin the bottle. Then, instead of kissing the person it lands on, you ask them truth or dare. If they say truth, you ask them a question and they have to answer it, no exceptions. If they say dare, you give them a dare, which they have to do or else they get a death penalty. Then, it is their turn to spin the bottle and ask another person truth or dare.” For a third time that night, the others glanced at each other. Then, one by one, a smile spread across their faces.
“I like that idea,” Joey said. “It’s so much more daring than just playing one or the other.”
“Exactly,” Lance responded. “And, you have to be open to anything. That means if your dare is to French kiss someone else, you have to be willing to consider it at least.” The others nodded in understanding. “So, are we ready to play?”
“Yes!” they all cried.
“Good. I’ll go first since it was my idea.” He reached out his hand, placed it on the beer bottle, and gave it a powerful spin. It took a few seconds to stop, coming to rest on Trevor. “Alright Trevor, truth or dare?” Lance asked him. Trevor seemed to be thinking about it for a moment.
“Truth,” he said finally. Lance thought for a moment.
“Okay, which of your group mates would you most like to kiss?” Trevor looked momentarily stunned before glancing at his group mates and turning back to Lance. He was about to say something when Lance added, “And why?” Trevor took a deep breath.
“Ashley,” he said, turning to look at him. “His lips just look so soft like an angel’s.” Ashley blushed deeply and looked down at the floor.
“Really?” Trevor nodded. “Okay then, it’s your turn.” Trevor reached out and gave the bottle a spin. It landed on Kevin.
“Truth or dare, Kevin?”
“Truth,” Kevin said immediately.
“Have you ever kissed a guy before?”
“Yes, once,” Kevin responded without hesitation. Trevor was again stunned. “My turn.” He spun the bottle. “Truth or dare, Joey?”
“Truth.”
“Which of your group members do you most admire and why?” Joey thought for a moment.
“Lance, because he’s always so organized and together.” Lance beamed at him. Joey smiled and spun the bottle. “Chris, truth or dare?’
“Dare!” Chris cried. “I’m not afraid of anything!”
“If you say so. I dare you to flash everyone your cock so we can see why you’re so self-conscious about it.” Chris glared at him for a moment.
“I’m going to get you for this Joseph!” he said in a threatening voice. He stood up and began unbuttoning his pants. Out of the corner of his eye, he could see Ashley, who was sitting on his left, watching him with fascination. He finished unbuttoning his pants and pulled them down.
“Boxers too,” Joey said.
“I know, I know,” Chris snapped at him. He took a deep breath and pushed his boxers down, revealing his manhood. He glanced around the circle. Most of the guys were nodding approval but Ashley, who had never seen another man’s cock before, gazed at the large slightly pink cock with wide eyes.
“Don’t see why you’re so self-conscious,” Joey said. “You have a beautiful cock, Chris.”
“You really think so?” Chris asked, blushing. Joey nodded. Chris beamed around at them before pulling up his pants and sitting down again. He beamed a second time and spun the bottle. “Okay Nick, truth or dare?”
“Dare,” Nick said. Chris smiled.
“I dare you to take off your shirt, the beater too.” Nick gulped. Everyone knew he was body shy.
“Do I really have to do that?”
“No, if you want a death penalty and they’re a lot worse.” Nick gulped again. He thought for a moment, and sighed.
“Alright, I’ll take the dare.” He took several calming breaths before reaching up and pulling off his shirts. His chest was nicely toned and well tanned.
“Wow, your body is beautiful!” Lance cried. “I don’t see why you’re so body shy.” Nick smiled weakly and quickly put his shirts back on.
“That wasn’t so bad now was it?” Chris asked. Nick glared at him.
It took a few moments but finally Nick calmed down enough to spin the bottle. It landed on Ashley. The man they called the heartbreaker gulped nervously and looked up at Nick. “Truth or dare?” Nick asked him softly. Ashley glanced around quickly.
“Truth,” he said quietly. Nick gave him a warm smile.
“Alright, I’ll go easy on you. Out of the rest of O-town, who is the most like a brother to you?”
“I have to say Dan,” Ashley responded after a moment. “He’s like a big brother to all of us, even though he’s the second youngest in the group.” Dan smiled at him.
“Thank you Ash, that was sweet.”
“You’re welcome.” He reached out a hand to spin the bottle. It came to rest on Erik. “Truth or dare?”
“Dare.” Ashley thought for a moment, looking around the room. He noticed that AJ was chewing gum.
“I dare you to take the gum from AJ’s mouth without asking or using your hands.” Erik did not seem nervous but Ashley was sure he was. He watched as Erik studied AJ for a moment. AJ however, wore a satisfied smirk on his face.
After a minute or two, Erik got up and crossed to where AJ was sitting. He plopped down in front of him and gently cupped AJ’s face in his hands. Then, he leaned in and forcefully pressed their lips together. He wasted no time begging entrance into AJ’s mouth with his tongue. Everyone else watched with interest as AJ allowed Erik’s tongue to enter his mouth. Only seconds later, Erik pulled away and turned to face the rest of the group. A moment later, they saw him begin to blow a bubble. He had completed his task. The group applauded and cheered as Erik returned to his seat.
“I guess it’s my turn now,” he said, popping the gum. He gave the bottle a spin and a wide smile spread across his face as it landed on AJ. “Truth or dare?”
“Truth. I want to save my dare for later.”
“Okay. Did you enjoy what I just did?” AJ smiled widely.
“Oh yes, very much indeed.” He thought he saw Erik blush just a little. His smiled widened even more and he spun the bottle. “Truth or dare, JC?”
“Truth.”
“Who would you most like to date from Nsync?”
“Lance,” JC responded quickly. “Definitely. Kay, I’m gonna spin it now.” The bottle landed on Jacob. “Truth or dare?”
“Dare.”
“I dare you to strip completely and sit naked for the rest of the game.” Jacob shrugged, stood up, and began stripping his clothes off. As he did, Brian glanced at him, up and down.
“Mmmm,” Brian said. Jacob looked at him and smirked. “I think I know who I want to spend the night with tonight.” Jacob smirked even more. He finished stripping and sat down again. Brian grabbed his cock and Jacob gasped. He playfully smacked Brian’s hand away and gave the bottle a spin. He was delighted when it landed on Brian.
“Truth or dare?”
“Truth!” Brian said quickly. He smirked as Jacob groaned. He knew he wanted to give him a dare.
“Have you ever slept with a guy before?”
“No, but I’m definitely interested in doing it.”
“Ooooo,” Kevin cried and Brian gave his cousin a devilish grin.
“My turn.” His spin of the bottle chose Dan as its victim. “Truth or dare?”
“Dare.”
“I dare you to French kiss JC.” Dan was briefly surprised but leaned across the circle. JC didn’t hesitate; he leaned forward and pressed his lips to Dan’s. Dan had never felt such soft lips before. He took in the warm, pleasureful feeling as their lips caressed each other. Only a moment went by and JC parted his lips to allow Dan’s tongue to enter his mouth. Dan moaned softly as JC massaged his tongue with his own. When the kiss was finally broken, both of them were gasping for breath. Dan waited till he caught his breath and then spun the bottle.
“Truth or dare, Justin?”
“Truth.” Dan thought for a moment and then smirked.
“Do you have a crush on any of your band mates?” Justin looked around and took a deep breath.
“Yes, I do.” The other members of Nsync glanced at each other, wondering who it was. “And it’s not just a crush. I have strong feelings, like love feelings for this person.” This made the rest of Nsync really shocked. No one noticed but Lance gulped just as Justin reached out and spun the bottle. He wasn’t surprised though when it landed on him. “Truth or dare, Lance?”
“Truth.” Justin smirked.
“What is your true sexuality?” Lance’s eyes widened and he gasped. He looked around at everyone. No one looked as though they were about to laugh.
“Isn’t that a bit too personal?” Trevor asked.
“No,” Lance said finally, “I’ll answer it. The truth is,” he took a deep breath, “I’m gay.” Everyone looked a bit surprised but to his relief no one seemed offended by it. He let out a sigh and gave the bottle another hard spin. It stopped on Howie. “Truth or dare?” Howie was taken aback when Lance seemed to have returned to normal. He took a moment to recover before he answered.
“Dare. I want to get it out of the way.”
“I dare you to give Jacob a blow job.”
“Whoa!” Howie cried. He glanced at Jacob who looked just as surprised. Brian was glaring at him with a look that said, Do it and I’ll kill you. However, Howie was not a coward. He got up and crossed the circle. He knelt in front of Jacob who was still naked and took a breath. He saw Jacob shut his eyes and wondered if he was scared. Howie didn’t waste time thinking about it; he lowered his head and took Jacob’s cock in his mouth. He heard Jacob gasp and took as a sign of pleasure.
Howie took his time, swirling his tongue seductively over the tip and around Jacob’s cock. He could feel it getting hard in his mouth as Jacob neared orgasm. He gasped when he felt his own cock begin to press against his jeans. The feel of Jacob’s cock in his mouth was giving him an erection. Finally, he tasted salty but sweet cum in his mouth as Jacob came. Howie pulled away and returned to his seat. Everyone could see a few drops of cum drip off Jacob’s cock. Jacob was breathing heavily, his eyes still closed. Howie took a few breathers before spinning the bottle. It landed on Chris.
“Truth,” Chris said before Howie could ask.
“Are you going to stop being so self-conscious about your cock now?” Chris did not answer. Instead, he hesitated a moment and then nodded his head. He reached out and spun the bottle. “Truth or dare, Erik?”
“Truth.”
“Okay, did you enjoy what you did to AJ?”
“Yes,” Erik said immediately. He gave the bottle a good spin. “Truth or dare, Kevin?”
“Dare.”
“I dare you to jack your cousin off.” Kevin looked at him blankly for a moment. Brian unbuttoned his pants and pulled out his already throbbing cock. Kevin gulped and took it in his hand. He slowly began to run his hand up and down and gradually got faster. Brian let out moans of pleasure and it wasn’t long before Kevin felt his release dripping all over his hand. He picked up a paper towel and cleaned his hand off. He smirked. The game was more than half-way over and by now, everyone had had at least one beer, even Ashley. He reached out and spun the bottle.
“Truth or dare, JC?”
“Dare.”
“I dare you to do a strip dance for us.”
“Okay!” JC stood up and left the room. He came back with a radio and turned it on. He began to dance seductively, stripping his clothes off slowly. It was about five minutes before he had even just stripped his shirts off. The other guys were whistling and cheering. JC looked at them seductively as he slowly but sexually unbuttoned his pants and rocked his hips to send them sliding down. He stepped out of them and dipped low, coming up slowly, running his hand up his body. Placing his hands on his hips, he shimmied out of his boxers, pushing them down as he did. The group watching cheered louder than ever and threw him money. He turned the music off, collected the money, got dressed again, and sat down. Then he delicately spun the bottle. “Truth or dare, Dan?”
“Truth.”
“Did you enjoy yourself when you were kissing me?”
“Yes,” Dan replied after a moment. He spun the bottle as JC smiled with triumph. “Truth or dare, Nick?”
“Truth.”
“Would you ever do your little brother?” Nick thought for a moment.
“Yes, I would actually.” He gave the bottle a spin and it landed on Lance.
“Dare,” Lance said without being asked.
“I dare you to,” he stopped and pulled a bottle of whipped cream from his bag, “Eat whipped cream out of Trevor’s mouth.” He turned and sprayed the cream into Trevor’s mouth. Trevor leaned his head back and Lance got up. He walked over and slowly lowered his head to Trevor’s mouth. He took the time to carefully scoop the whipped cream out with his tongue. When he got to the last bit, he closed his mouth over Trevor’s. Trevor moaned. Justin suddenly glared at Trevor with angry eyes. Lance pulled away and returned to his spot. He didn’t notice Justin’s look as he spun the bottle. He again found himself posing the question to Trevor.
“Truth or dare, Trevor?”
“Dare.” Lance beamed.
“I dare you to kiss Ashley.” Trevor smiled. Ashley looked a bit scared. Trevor made his way over to him carefully. He cupped Ashley’s face in his hands.
“Don’t worry, it’ll be okay,” he whispered and slowly pressed his lips to Ashley’s. Ashley’s eyes went wide shortly before closing and he leaned into the kiss, pressing back and making it deeper. Finally, after what seemed like an eternity, the two broke apart and Trevor spun the bottle. “Truth or dare, AJ?”
“Dare.”
“I dare you to tell us who your best fuck ever was.”
“Well, I have only slept with one guy and he was better than all the girls I slept with. So, my best fuck, would have to be Nick.” Everyone looked slightly shocked but Nick turned red. He gave the bottle a spin and it landed on Howie. “Truth or dare, Howie?”
“Truth.”
“Did you really like giving Jacob a blow job?” Howie blushed.
“Yes,” he said and spun the bottle.
“Ashley, truth or dare?”
“Dare,” Ashley said quickly and surprised himself.
“I dare you to tell us how that kiss you shared with Trevor made you feel.” If Ashley thought he couldn’t go redder than he already had, he was wrong.
“Well, it was amazing. To be honest, it felt right. I felt complete. I have never felt the way Trevor made me feel before. I think it may be easy for me to fall in love with him.” Trevor smiled. Then he got up and went to sit behind Ashley. He wrapped his arms around him and Ashley gasped.
“I could fall in love with you too, Ash.” Whatever anger Justin had had towards Trevor was gone. This bit of information seemed to satisfy him. Ashley leaned back against Trevor and lazily spun the bottle. It landed on Brian.
“Truth or dare?” Jacob looked displeased and Brian smirked again.
“Dare.”
“I dare you to lick chocolate off of Dan’s chest.” Dan looked pleased. Ashley pulled chocolate out of Dan’s bag as Dan pulled off his shirt. Brian came over just as Ashley had finished spreading the chocolate on Dan’s chest. Brian smiled and bent his head down. He slowly slid his tongue over Dan’s chest, making sure to give him a great deal of pleasure as he licked the chocolate off. When he finished, Dan moaned and Brian kissed him softly on the lips. He went back to his seat and reached out to spin the bottle.
“Okay Joey, truth or dare?”
“Dare.”
“I dare you to tell us how old you were when you lost your virginity.” Joey smirked.
“I was eleven.” The others gasped in surprise.
“That explains why he’s such a flirt!” JC said. Joey glared at him before spinning the bottle.
“Jacob, truth or dare?”
“Truth.”
“Did you enjoy yourself while Howie was giving you the blow job?”
“Oh hell yeah!” Jacob cried without hesitating. He spun the bottle, the last spin of the night and it came to rest on Justin. “Truth or dare?”
“Dare.” An evil grin spread across Jacob’s face.
“I dare you to French kiss the person you have such strong feelings for.” Justin looked at him strangely for a moment. Finally, he spoke.
“Well, I guess it’s about time he should know.” He got up, walked around the circle, and sat down again in front of…Lance. Lance looked at him astounded.
“Me?” he asked softly. Justin nodded. Not another word was said and neither moved for a moment. Then, Lance surprised Justin by leaning in and pressing their lips together. His hand went up to the back of Justin’s head and entangled itself in his hair. Justin’s arms wrapped around his neck and he deepened the kiss. Lance pulled Justin closer and begged entrance into his mouth. Justin allowed Lance’s tongue to enter and he gently massaged it with his own, still hungrily kissing Lance.
It wasn’t for several minutes that the two finally broke apart and everyone was gazing at them in amazement. Joey declared the party over and he and Chris chauffeured O-town and BSB out the door, Trevor and Ashley holding hands. Lance stared at Justin for a long time, not realizing that Chris and Joey had not returned and JC had left the room. Finally, he took Justin’s hand and began leading him up the stairs.
“Where are we going?” Justin asked.
“To make love in my room.”
“To make love?”
“Yes.”
“Why?” Lance looked at him.
“You love me don’t you?” Justin smiled.
“Yes, I love you.”
“You have no idea how long I have wanted you to say that.”
“You have?”
“Yes.”
“Why?”
“Because Justin, I love you too, I always have.” Justin smiled and pressed his lips to Lance’s in a soft kiss.
“Okay, let’s go.” The two of them disappeared up the stairs surround by the love they had for each other.
The End.
I hope you all enjoyed. Please go to the home page and e-mail me your feedback. Mind you, it took me forever to figure out how to post this with the spacing.
