| Won | Defeated | Date | where | Comments |
| No one | No one | 02/15/02 | Friday Night Heat | ODJ took the title from Hill as an exchange for a shot at the European title. Because no one takes this title seriously, ODJ decided to pull the plug on it, and retire it. |
| Warrick Hill | The Mozz | 04/13/01 | Friday Night Heat | Mozz didn't want the belt so he sold it to Warrick Hill for $5.00 and 2 ounces of mozz cheese. |
| The Mozz | Cyryn | 04/10/01 | Tuesday Night Fights | John Steel forfeited the belt for the European title. Mozz and Cyryn fought for the vacant title. The Mozz's first singles title reign. |
| John "The Real Deal" Steel | Kriss Havok | 03/06/01 | Tuesday Night Fights | John Steel second singles title reign in the ICWF. |
| Kriss Havok | Booch Freeman | 02/27/01 | Insane Massacre II | TLS vacated the title when he got a World Title shot.. Kriss and Booch earned the chance to fight for it. This is Kriss' first singles title in the ICWF. |
| The Lost Soul | Reaver | 2/09/01 | Friday Night Heat | Fatal 4 Way match, TLS third singles title win. |
| Reaver | 6 other participants | 1/25/01 | Genesis 2 Genocide PPV.. | Reaver's first singles title win. |
| Kylo | Dynamic Dynamite | 7/14/00 | Friday Night Heat | Second Singles Title won by Kylo. First Universal Title Reign. |
| Dynamic Dynamite | "Showtime" Mike Hall | 6/30/00 | Bad Blood PPV | Title was vacant, Dynamic Dynamites first title reign in the ICWF. |
| Enigma | Maddness | 1/7/00 | FNH | Belt was vacant, Everlast did not returned to the ICWF.... Enigma retired the belt.... |
| Everlast | Sledgehammer, Lucifer, Artic | 8/26/99 | Clash of the Champions PPV | New Vacant title, Everlast became the first ever Universal Champion |
