| Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 | Round 4 | FINAL | Winner |
| rvd_rocks51 ( 13 ) | |||||
| VS | rvd_rocks51 | ||||
| taker4life ( 7 ) | rvd_rocks51 | ||||
| silentninja292 ( 9 ) | |||||
| VS | slamball4life | rvd_rocks51 | |||
| slamball4life ( 11 ) | |||||
| asian_legend3 ( 12 ) | |||||
| VS | asian_legend3 | ||||
| rurouni_kenshin2 ( 4 ) | hulkhogan75 | rvd_rocks51 | |||
| zim3003 ( 3 ) | |||||
| VS | hulkhogan75 | ||||
| hulkhogan75 ( 12 ) | |||||
| highflyinjeff ( frozen ) | |||||
| VS | _duaa_ | ||||
| _duaa_ ( bye ) | davebatista | ||||
| davebatista ( 9 ) | |||||
| VS | davebatista | _wwf_wwe_ | |||
| wrestlemania_x9 ( 0 ) | |||||
| hello_wit_lots_of_ke ( 1 ) | |||||
| VS | _wwf_wwe_ | ||||
| _wwf_wwe_ ( 8 ) | _wwf_wwe_ | rvd_rocks51 or harryhumberton | |||
| unknown792 ( 5 ) | |||||
| VS | unknown792 | ||||
| lupe_lover_911 ( 4 ) | |||||
| lita_2extreme ( 2 ) | |||||
| VS | harryhumberton | ||||
| harryhumberton ( 10 ) | harryhumberton | ||||
| rockygurl12345 | |||||
| VS | swantonhardybomb | harryhumberton | |||
| swantonhardybomb | |||||
| lil_antonio_garold | |||||
| VS | lil_antonio_garold | ||||
| the_great_ali | lil_antonio_garold | harryhumberton | |||
| ricanchulo4ya | |||||
| VS | ricanchulo4ya | ||||
| darrennnn400 | |||||
| jeff_hardy_rocks50 | |||||
| VS | princey99 | ||||
| princey99 | hurrisquall | ||||
| hurrisquall | |||||
| VS | hurrisquall | hurrisquall | |||
| nwo_star | |||||
| ultimate_wrestler | |||||
| VS | ultimate_wrestler | ||||
| VACANT | the_whole_dam_show14 | ||||
| the_whole_dam_show14 | |||||
| VS | the_whole_dam_show14 | ||||
| renegade368 | |||||