| Name | Date | Location |
| Buddy Rogers | April 1963 | |
| Bruno Sammartino | May 17, 1963 | New York City, New York |
| Ivan Koloff | January 18, 1971 | New York City, New York |
| Pedro Morales | February 8, 1972 | New York City, New York |
| Stan Stasiak | December 1, 1973 | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania |
| Bruno Sammartino (2) | December 10, 1973 | New York City, New York |
| Superstar Billy Graham | April 30, 1977 | Baltimore, Maryland |
| Bob Backlund | February 20, 1978 | New York City, New York |
| Antonio Inoki | November 30, 1979 | Tokushima, Japan |
| Bob Backlund (2) | December 12, 1979 | New York City, New York |
| Bob Backlund (3) | November 23, 1981 | New York City, New York |
| Iron Sheik | December 26, 1983 | New York City, New York |
| Hulk Hogan | January 23, 1984 | New York City, New York |
| Andre The Giant | February 5, 1988 | Indianapolis, Indiana |
| Randy Savage | March 27, 1988 | Atlantic City, New Jersey |
| Hulk Hogan (2) | April 2, 1989 | Atlantic City, New Jersey |
| Ultimate Warrior | April 1, 1990 | Toronto, Ontario, Canada |
| Sgt. Slaughter | January 19, 1991 | Miami, Florida |
| Hulk Hogan (3) | March 24, 1991 | Los Angeles, California |
| The Undertaker | November 27, 1991 | Detroit, Michigan |
| Hulk Hogan (4) | December 3, 1991 | San Antonio, Texas |
| Ric Flair | January 19, 1992 | Albany, New York |
| Randy Savage (2) | April 5, 1992 | Indianapolis, Indiana |
| Ric Flair (2) | September 1, 1992 | Hershey, Pennsylvania |
| Bret Hart | October 12, 1992 | Saskatoon, Saskatchewan, Canada |
| Yokozuna | April 4, 1993 | Las Vegas, Nevada |
| Hulk Hogan (5) | April 4, 1993 | Las Vegas, Nevada |
| Yokozuna (2) | June 13, 1993 | Dayton, Ohio |
| Bret Hart (2) | March 20, 1994 | New York City, New York |
| Bob Backlund (4) | November 23, 1994 | San Antonio, Texas |
| Diesel | November 26, 1994 | New York City, New York |
| Bret Hart (3) | November 19, 1995 | Landover, Maryland |
| Shawn Michaels | March 31, 1996 | Anaheim, California |
| Sycho Sid | November 17, 1996 | New York City, New York |
| Shawn Michaels (2) | January 19, 1997 | San Antonio, Texas |
| Bret Hart (4) | February 16, 1997 | Chattanooga, Tennessee |
| Sycho Sid (2) | February 17, 1997 | Nashville, Tennessee |
| The Undertaker (2) | March 23, 1997 | Rosemont, Illinois |
| Bret Hart (5) | August 3, 1997 | East Rutherford, New Jersey |
| Shawn Michaels (3) | November 9, 1997 | Montreal, Quebec, Canada |
| Steve Austin | March 29, 1998 | Boston, Massachusetts |
| Kane | June 28, 1998 | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania |
| Steve Austin (2) | June 29, 1998 | Cleveland, Ohio |
| "The Rock" Rocky Maivia | November 15, 1998 | Saint Louis, Missouri |
| Mankind | December 29, 1998 | Worcester, Massachusetts |
| The Rock (2) | January 24, 1999 | Anaheim, California |
| Mankind (2) | January 26, 1999 | Tucson, Arizona |
| The Rock (3) | February 15, 1999 | Birmingham, Alabama |
| Steve Austin (3) | March 28, 1999 | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania |
| The Undertaker (3) | May 23, 1999 | Kansas City, Missouri |
| Steve Austin (4) | June 28, 1999 | Charlotte, North Carolina |
| Mankind (3) | August 22, 1999 | Minneapolis, Minnesota |
| Triple H | August 23, 1999 | Ames, Iowa |
| Vince McMahon | September 14, 1999 | Las Vegas, Nevada |
| Triple H (2) | September 26, 1999 | Charlotte, North Carolina |
| "Big Show" Paul Wight | November 14, 1999 | Detroit, Michigan |
| Triple H(3) | January 3, 2000 | Miami, Florida |
| The Rock (4) | April 30, 2000 | Washington, D.C. |
| Triple H(4) | May 21, 2000 | Louisville, Kentucky |
| The Rock (5) | June 25, 2000 | Boston, Massachusetts |
| Kurt Angle | October 22, 2000 | Albany, New York |
| The Rock (6) | February 25, 2001 | Las Vegas, Nevada |
| Steve Austin (5) | April 1, 2001 | Houston, Texas |
| Kurt Angle (2) | September 23, 2001 | Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania |
| Steve Austin (6) | October 8, 2001 | Indianapolis, Indiana |
| Chris Jericho | December 9, 2001 | San Diego, California |
| Triple H (5) | March 17, 2002 | Toronto, Ontario, Canada |
| Hulk Hogan (6) | April 21, 2002 | Kansas City, Missouri |
| The Undertaker (4) | May 19, 2002 | Nashville, Tennessee |
| The Rock (7) | July 21, 2002 | Detroit, Michigan |
| Brock Lesnar | August 25, 2002 | Uniondale, New York |
| The Big Show (2) | November 17, 2002 | New York City, New York |
| Kurt Angle (3) | December 15th, 2002 | Fort Lauderdale, Florida |
| Brock Lesnar (2) | March 30th, 2003 | Seattle, Washington |
