Fic Recommendations:

These fics are what I consider the "cream of the crop."  They're definitely worth checking out.  However, if you are not comfortable or ready for material with sexual content, please do not read the ones marked with the the asterisk and warning.  If you do, it is through no fault of my own since I've warned you.  All of the recommendations here are completed fics.  

After All Is Said & Done by Kilby located at Kilby's Fan Fiction  *exercise caution
Animal Crackers by Evie
Anticipation by Bitsy located at Bitsy's Web  *exercise caution
Behind the Screen by Maddie located at Dawson's Creek Fiction by Maddie  *exercise caution
The Best Man by Kilby located at Kilby's Fan Fiction  *exercise caution
Better or Worse by Pilar
Dawson's Creek Season 4 by Cariann (this is a collection of her version of season 4)
Episode 1: Summer Lovin'
Episode 2: D Day
Episode 3: Sex On My Mind
Episode 4: Me Myself and I
Episode 5: Baby Steps
Episode 6: The Future Is Now
Episode 7: Heartbreak Hotel
Episode 8: Happy Birthday
Episode 9: Music of the Night
East Side Story by Bitsy located at Bitsy's Web 
The End by Kaytee located at True Love Fanfic
Garden of Eden by Bitsy located at Bitsy's Web  
I Feel You by Witter Woman  *exercise caution
I'll Be Waiting by Tay 
The King of Pick-Up Lines by Rinny
The Last Dance by Kilby located at Kilby's Fan Fiction 
The Last Picture Show by Ophelia 
Long Ago... by Jade [the first in Jade's series]
Love and Other Catastrophes by Dana
Love Me When I'm Old by Ophelia  *exercise caution
Mr. Wonderful by Jade
Nothing But The Truth by Dana
Oops by Kaytee located at True Love Fanfic
Possession by Kaytee located at True Love Fanfic
Promises by Ophelia
The Reunion Series by Adrienne
Same Time Next Year by Liz
Some Kind Of Wonderful by Dana
The Story Of Us  by Jade [the third in Jade's series]
This Is When It All Began... by Jade [the second in Jade's series]
A Whisper In The Dark by Evie