| QB |  Peyton Manning, Indianapolis Colts |
| QB |  Ben Roethlisberger, Pittsburgh Steelers |
| WR |  Joe Horn, New Orleans Saints |
| WR | 
Larry Fitzgerald, Arizona Cardinals |
| WR |  Antwan Randle El, Pittsburgh Steelers |
| WR |  Eric Moulds, Buffalo Bills |
| WR |  Joey Galloway, Tampa Bay Buccaneers |
| RB |  Curtis Martin, New York Jets |
| RB |  Fred Taylor, Jacksonville Jaguars |
| RB |  Michael Bennett, Minnesota Vikings |
| RB |  Maurice Morris, Seattle Seahawks |
| RB |  Marcel Shipp, Arizona Cardinals |
| RB |  Derrick Blaylock, New York Jets |
| TE |  Dallas Clark, Indianopolis Colts |
| TE |  Courtney Anderson, Oakland Raiders |
| K |  Sebastian Janikowski, Oakland Raiders |
| K |  Jeff Wilkins, Saint Louis Rams |
| LB |  Ray Lewis, Baltimore Ravens |
| LB |  Zach Thomas, Miami Dolphins |
| LB |  Dan Morgan, Carolina Panthers |
| LB |  Brian Simmons, Cincinnati Bengals |
| LB |  James Farrior, Pittsburgh Steelers |
| DB |  Ed Reed, Baltimore Ravens |
| DB |  Ken Hamlin, Seattle Seahawks |
| DB |  Sean Taylor, Washington Redskins |
