2003 Keith Foulke OAK

2002 Billy Koch OAK

2001 Mariano Rivera NYY

2000 Todd Jones DET

1999 Mariano Rivera NYY

1998 Tom Gordon BOS

1997 Randy Myers BAL

1996 John Wetteland NYY

1995 Jose Mesa CLE

1994 Lee Smith BAL

1993 Jeff Montgomery KC

1992 Dennis Eckersley OAK

1991 Bryan Harvey CA

1990 Bobby Thigpen CHI

1989 Jeff Russell TEX

1988 Dennis Eckersley OAK

1987 Dave Righetti NYY

1986 Dave Righetti NYY

1985 Dan Quisenberry KC

1984 Dan Quisenberry KC

1983 Dan Quisenberry KC

1982 Dan Quisenberry KC

1981 Rollie Fingers MIL

1980 Dan Quisenberry KC

1979 Jim Kern TEX

1978 Rich Gossage NYY

1977 Bill Campbell BOS

1976 Bill Campbell MIN

2003 Eric Gagne LA

2002 John Smoltz ATL

2001 Armando Benitez NYM

2000 Antonio Alfonseca FLA

1999 Billy Wagner HOU

1998 Trevor Hoffman SD

1997 Jeff Shaw CIN

1996 Jeff Brantley CIN

1995 Tom Henke STL

1994 Rod Beck SF

1993 Randy Myers CHC

1992 Lee Smith STL

1991 Lee Smith STL

1990 John Franco CA

1989 Mark Davis CHI

1988 John Franco NYM

1987 Steve Bedrosian PHI

1986 Todd Worrell STL

1985 Jeff Reardon MON

1984 Bruce Sutter STL

1983 Al Holland PHI

1982 Bruce Sutter STL

1981 Bruce Sutter STL

1980 Rollie Fingers SD

1979 Bruce Sutter CHC

1978 Rollie Fingers SD

1977 Rollie Fingers SD

1976 Rawly Eastwick CIN