Please be advised that this page is in no formal or informal way connected to
the Saskatchewan Union of Nurses. The observations made here as well as any
opinions and speculation are strictly those of this writer.
Pay equity with their Federal counterparts.
This could be a bit of a reach even for a willing employer. The spread is
nearly $9000.00 dollars and there are 9000 nurses. Not all of them would get
the full amount but a majority would as the nurses population is old enough to
be mostly senior staff.
Just a healthy raise would probably do the trick. It could come in several
forms.
Un-sociable shifts are a fact of nursing that goes unrewarded, unlike danger
pay or isolation pay. Nurses might as well be in the far north or on the moon
when they are working three 12 hours shifts on a week-end, or any time. They
get peanuts for a shift differential and it should be increased by a
significant amount.
Over time is often double time, which would probably be adequate if the regular
salary was adequate.
A nurse who is mandated in to work is currently paid at a normal overtime rate.
This is ridiculous! A mandated shift should be at least triple time, if for no
other reason than to discourage the employer from failing to provide staffing
in the first place.
They want to have a day off where they can count on the phone not ringing at
5:30 in the morning for them to come in to work. It really is awful to have to
install name and number display just so you can avoid picking up a call which
might result in being mandated in to work.
Nurses would like to be treated to a benefit package, half as good as some of
the "crowns". There are those who can attend to a sick spouse for weeks and
receive partial salary.
If a nurses spouse dies, they get three days off and its back to work! If the
spouse or kids are sick its too bad for them!
A health care plan might be nice too. Nurses have partial coverage of basic
dental care and no drug plan or optical coverage. In fact nurses may have the
leanest health care coverage in the entire public secter!
More than a bit ironic.
Nurses would not only like to be paid to keep abreast of education in their
field but would like an opportunity to do just that.
As are teachers, who bring in speakers and organize seminars on their "paid
education days".
For $243.00 a year, per nurse (that would be between $500-$750 per stall) for
parking, nurses would like to be able to plug in a car warmer for a few weeks
in the winter, so that when they finish the 12 1/2 hour shift they don't have
to sit on a rock hard frozen car seat for 15 minutes while their car warms up
enough to drive home.
When 100% of nurses in an area bring an item to the attention of their employer;
such as how ridiculous it is for nurses to be paid to take time out from
patient care to empty garbages, hand out food trays or clean toilets, when
cleaning, kitchen or maintenance staff are available for those duties they
would like to not have to fight tooth and nail to make their point.
Cost of living clause:
With a 1% trigger. The cost of everything on the planet is going up daily so
nurses need a cost of living clause just to keep pace with the obvious
financial demands of our society (not to mention the governments own,
all-too-regular-increases for everything from vehicle registration, telephone
service, gas and power to taxes).
They want a lot more than they have now, and I think they have waited long
enough and work hard enough to deserve a lot more!
What they actually get may depend more on how many people phone up their
"Member of the Legislature" and
tell them they better look after the nurses or else!
If you want to learn all about our current Health Minister or perhaps complain
about the shabby treatment of nurses you may find that the present "ministers"
have biographical web pages up.
In fact feel free to cut and paste this web page address should you decide to
send an e-mail. The Minister will almost certainly get the message.
(and if you are the Minister. . . let me wish you the best of luck negotiating
with SUN and with CUPE.
These front line health care workers have been starved for a long time now and
it will be a tough job to bring them all up to a fair wage!
Today, March 03, 1999, the Leader Post reported on the negotiations between
nurses and SAHO. The article was on page C8, just below yesterdays weather.
It's a fact, the Leader Post reports yesterdays weather! Even more remarkable
is the fact that they relegate the most current news of our provinces nurses to
the same lonely backpage as "yesterdays weather".
I noted in this article that a new labour relations consultant is being brought
in from British Columbia to help to "facilitate the negotiations for both sides.
In the interests of the nurses I have decided that I will offer my consulting
services right here for free until the gov't ante's up some cash money for the
nurses.
Remember, strikes are a touchy business and early talk of a strike worries me.
The gov't has a way a manipulating strikes and strikers into something that
they are really not.
SUN should plan on rotating strikes by unit only and never a total walk out.
Why? Two reasons. A total walk out puts huge dollars into the hands of the
gov't and the managers and it creates bad public opinion. The public already
knows nurses have a 74% strike mandate, there is no need to show off about it.
SUN should plan on inconveniencing managers with small rotating strikes.
Managers need to be reminded that 5 of them, cannot do the work of 5 nurses,
for even a few days any more than 3 nurses can do the work of 5 nurses, even
for a few days. And they need to be taking that message back to upper
management on a regular basis after covering for a series of rotating strikes.
SUN should remember that there is no rush to settle. The only rush that is on
is to keep the voting public informed.
SUN should try to get some better press coverage than yesterdays weather and
keep in mind that two or three months of rotating strikes dragging on and on,
means really great "bad press" for this gov't. Which in turn means, a better
chance of a better contract!
SUN needs to absolutely ensure that it does not settle it's negotiations until
"after" the gov't concludes it's negotiations with CUPE. It would not be fair
for SUN to rush it's business in ahead of CUPE. After all CUPE is made up
mainly of health support workers who not only keep the hospitals and facilities
running for the nurses to work in, but who, coincidentally have some of the
same issues on the bargaining table as the nurses.
Nurses should offer a good deal of support to CUPE and their negotiation team,
as those negotiations will almost certainly be precedent setting in regard to
SUN negotiations.
SUN should publicize all the little perks that the "crowns" and other sectors
of employment get that nurses don't get.
For example the most responsible of employees who don't use or abuse their sick
time in other sectors get paid out at a rate of a third. (I think) So for the
nurse who is nearing retirement and has 6 months or a year of unused sick time,
the gov't could offer to pay out a third, which would amount to a few months
pay. The alternative of course is for the gov't to treat the nurses in the
traditional shabby fashion and the nurses will respond in kind and start taking
those sick days off, as retirement approaches.
In this scenario the gov't pays a younger nurse straight "double time" to
replace that sick call. (And don't even think about criticizing a 60 year old
nurse for taking a sick day when they feel really shabby even if they could
manage
to get through the day!)
April 08 1999 and the nurses have given strike notice, the hospitals have been cleared of all the non-life-threatened patients, the Premier has spent the day intervening in what should be SAHO's business and the nurses have decided to go to work and continue to collect their paycheques. No doubt this will demonstrate to the gov't that two can play the "best of intentions" waiting and propaganda game. (I couldn't have planned it better on my best day!)
What is the next move for SUN? Step up the Public Awareness Campaign; and I am sticking with small rotating strikes and pickets as the best method. Also SUN must continue to demonstrate to the gov't that the "big picture" requires greatly increased nurses salaries and benefits or Saskatchewan will be even further behind the other provinces in three years than they are now!
Interestingly, the surgeons at the General Hospital have continued to do open heart surgery's on a daily basis and yet the media has only reported that "elective surgery's" have been cancelled. SUN definitely needs to counter this propaganda measure with the fact that surgical nurses continue to assist in surgery's which shorten the waiting lists for the public every day so far!
As well, SUN needs to broadcast the fact that post surgical care has continued to be provided throughout the pre-strike manuvering by both sides.
What is the next move for SUN? SUN is walking out!(April 08 1999)
Yup! I guess the Premier was less effective than he wanted to be. Perhaps he has failed to recognize that the solution to the whole of the healthcare crisis is to bring the nurses wages up to speed.
This provinces nurses cannot "nurse", our crippled health care system back to health without more nurses, and no more nurses will come here while our nurses salaries trail far behind those of the neighbouring provinces.
April 06 1999 and the Saskatchewan Nurses Union is poised to strike for all the
usual reasons, plus a few unusual ones.
April 06 1999 and Premier Roy Romanow summons the Leader of SUN and the Leader
of SAHO to meet with him so that he may "do his best" to help with the problems
which seem to be keeping the two sides apart.
April 06 1999 and I am pretty sure I saw Mr. Arliss Wright on T.V. telling
reporters that $9000.00 dollars was just too much money for the nurses to get
from SAHO!
April 06 1999 and I ask myself what the Premier thinks he can do after
preaching and blaming SAHO for all the health care problems of the last several
years as SAHO was supposed to operate in an autonomous fashion without
political influence of any kind!
Not to mention Mr. Wright has already made up his mind that the negotiations
are over on that monetary issue!
And while we are on the subject of $9000.00 dollars, without argueing the
wherefores of it being a raise or a simple wage parity issue lets just say the
nurses would accept a 6% salary increase per year for three years, that would
not sound quite the same as $9000.00 dollars would it?
April 06 1999 and it looks like a photo opportunity for the Premier. I predict
that he will be passing the buck on this one too, and he will do it right after
his meeting April 06 1999.
April 06 1999 and SAHO managers are rushing around suddenly realizing that all
those people hooked up to machines post surgery and post trauma are literally
filling the hospital.
In the not too distant past all the really sick people were in Intensive Care
Units (ICU) or Critical Care Units (CCU), but not in this day and age!
April 06 1999 and managers realize that over the last few years nurses have
aquired the skills to maintain the very ill on the regular units. Just as
patients who would never have left the hospital are now recovering in the
community so are the critically ill being treated on the various hospital
floors.
So on April 07 managers who may not have actively nursed for 5 or 10 years are
going to find out that the nurses who want an extra $9000.00 may just deserve
it, for having taken on the responsibility for operating Intravenous infusion
pumps, pulling out pleural tubes (that only the physician would
have touched a few years ago) and for taking on these and other
responsibilities outside of the ICU or CCU environment and for a dozen or more
patients each!
April 07 1999 as predicted, the buck passing has started on the front page of
the LP. "Heatlh District Officials said they have no quarrel with their nursing
staff. The nurse's quarrel, they said. is with the provincial government".
April 07 1999 and Mr. Murray Mandrake has presented the best article to date
concerning the nurses issues on page A - 11 of the Regina LP. I normally get
the feeling that Mr. Mandrake must be on a cash retainer by the NDP but not
this time! He has presented the facts, as well as the related issues together
with a good analysis of all sides of the situation. Read it!
According to the figures from Mr. Mandrakes article which I just mentioned I
would have created a better look at the math and the dollars involved using
Ontario, British Columbia, Alberta and Saskatchewan in comparison to the
current wage offer.
A chart detailing nurses salaries is located at the
Nurses Dollars
Page
I will almost certainly have more sage advice for the negotiating committee
soon. So stay tuned.
What is the plan? Civil disobedience would not be economically practical nor
would it win public support. That's my opinion!
For those who may not have heard; SUN members are going for
"civil disobedience",
in spite of my opinion!
There are several things the nurses can do as a group as well as on an
individual basis:
SUN has been making a huge mistake!
They have consistantly allowed the wrong message to be sent to the government as
well as the media and the public.
All anyone has heard for the last several weeks were the words RAISE and
$9000.00. What message would have been better?
The nurses and SUN want SAHO and the Saskatchewan government to address the
significant disparity between our provinces health care system and the other
provinces. In particular Alberta, which not only boasts the sales tax advantage
and geographical proximity, but which
currently pays its nurses more
than this NDP government has "legislated" for Saskatchewan nurses for each of
the three years from now until 2001.
This message clearly demonstrates to all (except card carrying NDP'ers
perhaps?) that
the nursing shortage will be increasing and more beds will be closing over the
next three year period. It further demonstrates who ought to shoulder the blame!
(Failure on the part of SUN to instruct its members as to the correct,
appropriate and consistant message to be delivered to the media and the public
may have already cost the members a great deal. If the public hears, "raise"
from the nurses they will forget about the
big picture
if they ever knew about it in the first place and even though a raise for
nurses improves the
big picture
the
"focus"
of all SUN communication should be on the
big picture
.)
Perhaps at this time of confrontation there is no more important item for SUN
and its members than to maintain clarity in its message to the public of
Saskatchewan, the NDP government and the whole of Canada.
Were the nurses returning to work . . . I would have this sage advice for them
as follows.
Public Awareness Campaign - Every blunder and short coming of management must
find its way to the SUN office and the media! Also all methods available must
be utilized to educate the public as to the ramifications of underfunding
nurses as well as the whole system!
No instance of understaffing should be allowed to go un-reported.
Every mandated shift worked needs to be reported to the SUN office, recorded
and reported to the media on an on-going basis.
Any work situation involving a question of safety for either the patient or
the staff ought to have a complete incident report filed with management, as
well as reported to the SUN office.
Any type of communication on the part of managers toward SUN members that is
not 100% business like and professional, ie harassment of any kind, insistance
on duties or activities outside the job description or errors in shifting or
payroll ought to be pursued and / or grieved.
How should nurses respond when asked how they "feel" about the strike and the
governments actions? They should feel like any free citizen of the world, they
should feel "ashamed", ashamed to be associated in any way, shape or form with
this type of deception and heavy handed political self-serving manipulation on
the part of our Saskatchewan Government.
SUN must set policy concerning over-time and how much nurses will be available -
keeping in mind that the less voluntary over-time the higher the numbers will
be that are reported to the media for mandated work.
Remind everyone that CUPE has not settled their contract yet and other public
sector employees are on the verge of being forced to strike by
"dictator style" government
at this very moment!