Note: All bonus wrestlers will be marked with an asterisk (*).

• Alex Wright
  
• Arn Anderson
  
• Bam Bam Bigelow *
  
• Barry Windham
  
• Bobby Blaze *
  
• Bobby Duncum Jr.
  
• "Beautiful" Bobby Eaton *
  
• Booker T
  
• Bret "Hitman" Hart
  
• Buff Bagwell
  
• Chavo Guerrero Jr.
  
• Chris "The Crippler" Benoit
  
• Chris Jericho *
  
• Curt Hennig
  
• Diamond Dallas Page
  
• Dean Malenko
  
• Disco Inferno
  
• Doug Dellinger *
  
• Eddy Guerrero
  
• Eric Bischoff *
  
• Ernest "The Cat" Miller
  
• Goldberg
  
• Hollywood Hogan
  
• Horace Hogan
  
• Jimmy "The Mouth of the South" Hart *
  
• Juventud Guerrera
  
• Kanyon
  
• Kaz Hayashi *
  
• Kenny Kaos
  
• Kevin "Big Sexy" Nash
  
• La Parka
  
• Lash LeRoux *
  
• Lex Luger
  
• Lizmark Jr
  
• "Macho Man" Randy Savage
  
• Mean Gene Okerlund *
  
• Norman Smiley
  
• Prince Laukea
  
• Psychosis
  
• Raven
  
• Rey Mysterio Jr.
  
• Ric Flair *
  
• Rick Steiner *
  
• Sgt. Buddy Lee Parker *
  
• Perry Saturn
  
• Scott Hall
  
• Scott Norton
  
• Scott "Big Poppa Pump" Steiner
  
• Sonny Onoo *
  
• Steve "Mongo" McMichael *
  
• Stevie Ray
  
• Sting (standard)
  
• Sting (Wolfpac) *
  
• Wrath
  

EA told IGN64 that the list above may not necessarily represent all the bonus wrestlers featured in the game. A few secrets should be expected.