Lectures for Unit
II: The Age of Revolutions
Back to the Unit Page
The Agricultural Revolution
Pre-Enclosure
-
Peasants work their land + lord’s
-
goal: stable food supply
-
1 of 3 fields left fallow
-
Crops: wheat, barley, beans, oats
Impetus for change
-
pop. jumps
-
bread prices up
-
trad. production slows growth
-
landlords see benefits, gov’t wants taxes
-
peasants resist
Enclosure Movement
-
landlords fence common lands
-
Par. passes laws backing them (squirearchy)
-
Prod. á to support population
-
more food made by fewer workers
New Crops & Methods
-
corn & potatoes
-
clover & turnips renew land & feed livestock
-
reclaimed land (Dutch)
-
Tull’s iron plow & seed drill
-
Townshend’s new rotation
Population Explosion
-
3/4 of billion in 1750, 5 bil now
-
plague gone, less war, better health
-
Explosion forces change in way we live (migration, etc.)
The 1st Ind. Rev.
-
Great Britain leads (freedom, waterways & roads, coal & iron, unified
tax structure, relatively mobile society)
-
textiles, coal, steam & iron
-
putting out can’t keep up
-
flying shuttle demands thread Ô
spinning jenny Ô water frame Ô
-
must move to factory
-
1776- Watt’s Steam Engine allows move from rivers
Increased Consumption
-
more disposable income
-
more people
-
improved marketing
-
goods = prosperity
Growth of "New" Cities
-
1500-1700 growth in established cities, after 1750 it’s new cities
-
enclosure, growth of industry lead to migration
-
around factories, mines, road hubs, sea ports
Poverty
-
infrastructure not ready
-
crowding, disease, slums, etc.
-
prostitution, crime, begging
-
coal soot
Wealth
-
entertainment, opportunity, new inventions, etc.
-
new houses & shops for nouveaux riche
-
new gov’t buildings, museums, cathedrals, etc.
-
wealthy control city gov’t
Caught in the Middle (bourg.)
-
income not from land
-
force behind consumption & industry
-
wealth = social mobility
-
resent nobles, fear poor
-
want reform for own benefit
Artsy Fartsy Artisans
-
stable upper lower class
-
grocers, carpenters, wage earners
-
try to advanced through guilds
-
guilds made obsolete, fade out in Cent. Eur.
-
goal: reestablish a threatened right
-
Bread, religious tolerance, new taxes
-
MC might support vs. nobility
Meanwhile in GB
-
George III turns to Tories
-
Wilkes challenges George, accuses of tyranny, supported by Whigs
-
Wilkes exiled, returns & gets elected to commons (4X)
-
Not seated Ô demonstrations
-
Calls for reform of Par.
-
Tory Par. decides to tax colonies
Back in the Colonies
-
question tyranny & tax authority of GB
-
Appeal beyond political body to public opinion
-
assemblies’ power from consent of governed (you can revolt against the
Ancien Regime)
-
defend "rights of Englishmen", wind up with…
Brand new government
-
No King necessary
-
No nobility or classes by birth
-
Equality for white males
-
Gov’t based on liberty can work
Causes of the FR
-
economic (can’t service debt, sluggish economy)
-
political (weak monarch, noble resurgence, Bourg interest in Enlight.)
-
social (oppressed poor, Bourg. resentment)
Problems with Debt
-
7 yrs. War & Amer. Rev.
-
Can’t tax nobility - claim "only EG can tax"
-
Nobles demand original rights (resurgence)
-
N+B, N vs. B, & conditions suck for poor
Estates General (1789)
-
1st=Clergy, 2nd=Nobility, 3rd=All else (B)
-
3rd Estate gets pumped
-
How to Vote? Nobility demands equal reps for each estate & vote by
order
Cahiers de Doleances
Grievances of the estates: Gov’t waste, indirect taxes, corruption,
Church taxes, etc.
-
Want local admin., more EG, free press (Basic equality)
-
grievances must wait on voting issue
National Assembly
-
3rds refuse to sit separately, so they break off with lower clergy &
form NA on 6/17
-
Take the Tennis Court Oath: "We’ll write a constitution"
Louis XVI Breaks Down
-
Louis says "desist" causing more clergy & nobility join NA
-
Louis realizes he’s toast, asks 1st & 2nd to officially join NA (6/27)
-
this means Gov’t no longer by privileged order
Causes of Revolution
-
Growing pop., rising prices, stable wages, subsistence farming
-
Growing Bourg. threat to nobility
-
Lessening distinctions between classes
-
Weakness of Louis XVI
Storming the Bastille, 1789
-
Louis XVI wants to regain initiative
-
dismisses Necker, musters troops
-
7/14: people of Paris form militia, go to Bastille for weapons
-
troops fire on crowd, they storm
-
This event means Poor are starting to be heard, disturbances spread
-
Louis gives in again, recognizes NCA
Great Fear Spreads
-
Rural uprisings vs. nobility & army
-
opportunity to claim food supply & land, reclaim lost rights, and vent
-
uprisings cause Nobles to renounce rights & privs. (8/4)- decrees make
laws same for all
-
Clears way for NCA to write Cons.
-
sets up NCA & popular masses vs. King & Cons. Nobles
Dec. of Rights of Man (8/27)
-
Statement of principles for Rev.
-
Attacks probs. from Old Regime
-
Enlight & Dec. of Ind.
Provides:
-
Equal before law, enter any office or prof., due process, religious tol.
-
Apportioned taxation, innocence
-
Civic equality & right to property
Impact of Dec. of Rights
-
Women left in separate sphere
-
True end of old regime (civic equality & protection of prop.)
-
Establishes philosophy for Revolution
March on Versailles
-
Louis stalls on Dec. of R, no chow
-
Women march on Versailles (10/5)
-
Louis agrees to D of R of M, forced back to Paris
-
Popular insurrection works, leads to Cons. Mon
-
Relative peace until 1792
-
Start process of "Reconstruction"
Reconstruction of France
-
Cons. Monarchy, rational admin., unregulated econ. (some En.)
-
Protect prop. & limit impact of those without prop.
-
Civic, not social equality
-
Not democracy
Constitution of 1791
-
Legislative Assembly makes laws & taxes), Monarch gets veto
-
"Active" citizens get vote (very limited suffrage)
-
indirect elections for LA
-
transfer power from aristocratic wealth to all wealth (good for Bourg.)
Women Get Left Out
-
Cons. forbids women from voting or holding office
-
Olympe de Gouges rewrites Dec. of Man as Dec. of Women
-
Without women & poor the Revolution is incomplete
Departments are Formed
-
Replace provinces, remain today
-
Uniform courts, elected judges & prosecutors
-
parlements & old courts are gone
Economic Reform
-
Support policies of Louis XVI
-
Suppressed Guilds (Chapelier Law)
-
new land taxes insufficient so they, Finance debt by selling Church prop.
Assignats
-
Bonds backed by church prop.
-
Become so popular they’re used like currency
-
This gives lots of people a stake in the Rev.
-
Issue too many Ô inflation
Civil Cons. of Clergy
-
Departments = Dioceses
-
Election of clergy
-
Tension between Church & State
-
NCA forces clergy to sign
-
Resistors are "refractory clergy"
-
Pope condemns Rev., creates a crisis for devout RCs
Counter Revolutionaries
-
emigres flee to border countries
-
Louis’ bro & Marie convince him to split, he flees & gets caught
at Varennes
-
Makes it clear Louis is anti-Rev.
-
Dec. of Pillnitz: Leopold II (Au.) & Fred II(Pr.) pledge to protect
royal family & Monarchy if necessary
-
Revs. realize they’re surrounded
-
1st Leg. Assembly’s elected, faces big probs.: divisions in LA, demands
of "passive" citizens, outside threats
Foreign Response
-
emigres freak
-
enl. abs. ends (fear of revolt in own country)
-
Burke: doomed to anarchy
-
Pitt: suppresses calls for reform
Start of 2nd Rev.
-
People call for more Rev. (left out, bad economics, no food)
-
Girondins (Mod/Cons. Mon.) want to keep 1st rev.
-
Jacobins (Rad/Republic) require help of sans-culottes
-
LA declares war on Austria (4/92)
-
Austria & Prussia invade(crisis-"severe retribution")
Crisis Continues
-
wars favor A & P early
-
8/10/92 Paris Insurrection(Tuileries), spurred on by recruits from war
-
Commune takes control of Paris
-
LA gives way to Nat’l Convention
-
Conv. declares Republic (9/92)
-
Commune massacres "enemies of Rev.", imprisons Louis XVI
Mobilize for Conflict
-
1/93- Convention executes Louis
-
Defending new values and order (offer to help others)
-
form Executive committees (General Security & Public Safety)
-
Danton, Robespierre, Carnot must "save the revolution"
-
Mtn. allies with sans-cullottes (who prefer rev. to old regime)
Domestic Support for War
-
4/93: war with A, P, GB, Sp, & DR
-
6/93: SCs expel Girondins, Mtn. in control
-
women want right to fight
-
levee en masse=
-
conscript males
-
war production
-
price ceilings
-
squash uprisings in provinces
Republic of Virtue
-
main goal of the convention
-
civic virtue replaces aristocratic corruption
-
republican dress, suppression of plays, rename streets, no wigs
-
must suppress rights to have "equality"?
Society of Women
-
fight internal enemies of Rev.
-
brawl with food hoarders, etc.
-
banned by Jacobins (different goals)
-
Olympe de Gouges gets axed
-
Kept in separate sphere
Dechristianization (starts in 11/93)
-
nation of virtue, not religion
-
change calendar
-
close churches, arrest priests
-
opposition from provinces
-
further alienating the church
Reign of Terror
-
Robespierre & Comm. for PS
-
Marat’s execution lays groundwork
-
targeted "enemies of revolution", definition always changing
-
Marie, then other royals
-
Girondin, then out into provinces against poor who revolted against revolution
(Nantes)
-
Robes axes enrages, then Danton
-
eliminates opposition
-
Law 22
-
25,000 total victims
-
first in chain that includes Hitler & Stalin?!?
Fall of Robespierre
-
Cult of Supreme Being
-
Wild accusations, shouted down & arrested on 9th of Thermidor
-
no support from SC’s or Jacobins
-
destroyed rivals without creating followers
Thermidorian Reaction (7/94)
-
tempers revolution
-
SCs out, Girondin back in
-
continue rev. in moderation
-
Powers of CPS reduced
-
Price controls & regulations removed (shortages)
-
Bourg. emerges triumphant
-
Property=representation
-
Back to old life style (both worship and vice)
-
legal rights & constitution
-
commune outlawed, Jac. Club closed
-
"white terror" execute "red terrorists"
peace with Sp. & Pr., still at war with GB & Au.
Nappy Comes to Power
-
General in Rev. wars
-
Directory’s threat is royalists
-
Big Weener: 1795 at home, then in Italy vs. Austria, then back home in
1797 (very popular)
-
1799- Goes after GB in Egypt (Med.), gets whupped, comes home to support
Sieyes’ coup
Nap pushes Seiyes out
Constitution of Year VIII:
-
universal suffrage
-
checks & balances
-
Council of State
all it really means is…
First Council Nap is da man
Dealing With Enemies
-
Bourg. & Peasants support Nappy
-
1801- Peace with all but GB
-
Wheeler dealer, involves a variety of people in gov’t
-
Suppressing opposition (secret police, cent. bureaucracy)
-
1804- duke of Enghien (end to royalist plots)
Concordat with Church
-
all clergy resign
-
replacements invested by Pope
-
Bishops are elected
-
Church gives up claims to lands
-
acknowledges RC as religion of France
Napoleonic Code
-
1802 Nap is Consul for life
-
Reforms French law
-
protects property
-
no privileges by birth
-
choose officials based on merit
-
labor organizations are banned
-
men are dominant over women
-
applied to all of France (uniformity is important)
Building an Empire
-
Massive military support & French Nationalism
-
No single enemy can match up
-
Go to war with GB again
-
Trafalgar ends hope of invading GB
-
Starts heading east
More on Order
-
cent. admin controls all depts.
-
amnesty for emigres
-
lesser Consuls represent many factions
-
spreads blame for bomb scares
More on Church
-
religion is matter of convenience
-
refractory = CR’s
-
Concordat = Pope recognizes republic
-
Protestant ministers on payroll
Workings of Cons. VIII
-
universal vote for "notables"
-
notables could be in leg. or trib.
-
leg. comes from from Council of State, headed by 1st Consul
Creates the Modern State
-
"Best of Rev. & AR"
-
all loyalty to state
-
offices through ability
-
equitable taxation
-
new social structure
-
military mobilization
Third Coalition
-
Nap wants to invade GB
-
10/05- Dusted at Trafalgar, goes east
Nap the Big Weiner
-
12/05 Austerlitz vs. A&R gives him all of Italy
-
7/06 Confederation of Rhine dissolves HRE
-
11/06 Berlin Decrees control Prussia (Jena & Auerstadt), no
GB imports on continent
Treaty of Tilsit
-
Nap Emp. of West, Alex Emp. of East
-
France & Russia ally vs. GB
-
Nap gets Prussia west of Elbe
-
Installs his family as rulers of Europe
Continental System
-
Goal is "continental" economy
-
Defeat GB (modern Carthage) economically
-
GB blockades in response
-
Luxury goods are what’s missing
-
tariffs & transport are probs
More Continental
-
helps growth of industry
-
U.S. is only trade neutral
-
hurts cont. economies more than GB
-
Income of GBians doubles
Spanish Response & War
-
last piece of coastline
-
peasants devoted to rulers & RC
-
Nap puts bro Joe on throne, supports with army
-
Monks urge peasants to rebel
-
GB’s army supports Guerillas
More Spanish Response
-
1808-1813: "Peninsular War" drains French resources
-
Gruesome atrocities
-
Hope for rest of Europe
Austria Renews Conflict - 1809
-
counting on French weariness & help from German Princes
-
Talleyrand betrays Nappy (overextended) to Alex
-
Alex pissed about Gr. Du. of Warsaw
-
Wagram Fr. win, nobody helps Au.
-
Land & People to France in treaty
-
Nap marries Marie Louise (18, daughter of emp.)
1810- Peak of Empire
-
French Core, dependent states in layers
-
Rome is 2nd City
-
ruled by he & family
-
stages of takeover
-
military
-
satellite government
-
constitution & internal reform
What this means for Europe
-
feudal & manorial systems liquidated
-
Church loses public authority
-
state based on territorial residence
-
guilds abolished, free trade pushed
-
towns & provinces unified with country
-
supported by many locals
-
locally administration
-
nationalistic response
German Response
-
Intellectuals urge nationalism (the romantic kind)
-
things "German" unpopular, become popular
-
Herder & Volksgeist (cultural nationalism)
-
romantics critical of selfish princes
Prussia leads German Response
-
They end serfdom, reform military, use reserves
-
try French reforms in order to hopefully beat French
Russian Campaign
-
don’t like continental (timber sales to GB), Grand Duchy, Holland, marriage
-
1810- Russia withdraws from Cont.
-
Nap builds army to 600,000 & invades
-
Russians Retreat before him (scorched earth)
More Russian Campaign
-
Conditions suck, Nap’s afraid a bad campaign will toast him
-
90,000 die @ Borodino for nada
-
Forced to retreat, hustles back ahead of army
-
Ultimate in military horror
The Squeezer Cheeser
-
Russ., Pruss., & Aust push Nap back with GB $$$ (32 mill)
-
Wellington pushes east
-
Nap wins @ Dresden, loses @ Leipzig
-
3/14 Allies march into Paris, Nap goes into exile
He’s Done, Who Gets Him?
-
Castleragh drafts agreement
-
Quadruple Alliance
-
Bourbons on throne
-
France back to 1792
-
leftover Probs. to …
The Squeezer Cheeser
-
R, P, & A push Nap back with GB $$$ (32 mill)
-
Wellington (GB) pushes east
-
Nap wins @ Dresden, loses @ Leipzig
-
3/14 Allies into Paris, Nap goes to Elba
He’s Done, Who Gets Him?
-
Castleragh drafts agreement
-
Bourbons on throne
-
No reparations or punishment
-
Charter of 1814:equality & reform
-
F’s borders back to 1792
-
leftover Probs. to …
Congress of Vienna
-
9/14 to 10/15
-
controlled by 4 powers (Quad Alliance)
-
recession of French Empire leaves many ?s (France & East Europe)
-
No single state should dominate
A Variety of Goals:
-
Alex wants Poland & Constitutions
-
Castleragh & Metternich want balance on the Cont.
-
Prussia wants more territory
Organizing the map (west)
New states barriers to France:
-
(Neth (incl. Belgium), Genoa)
-
Piedmont & Aust. in N. Italy
-
Pr. gets left bank of Rhine
-
Germany remains dissolute (German Confed.-39 states)
-
Legitimate monarchs over republics (just say no to democ.)
Organizing the map (East)
-
R wants Poland, P wants Saxony
-
A doesn’t want to give up Poland or Prussian expansion
-
F, GB & A form secret alliance
-
Alex & Freddy give in (small Poland, part of Saxony)
100 Days (Nap’s Baaaaack)
-
Army’s loyal, many want his protection, coalition in trouble
-
returns 3/1/15, "I’ll be good"
-
Allies squash him at Waterloo 6/18/15 (Welly + Prussians)
-
makes peace harsher for France
-
feeds dread of rev. & raises opposition to it
Results of C of V
-
Holy Alliance
-
Quadruple Alliance (A,GB,P&R)
-
successful solution to probs. of the day, fails to see into future (ignores
Nat. & Dem.)
-
provides peace for 50 years
-
GB only remaining empire
More Results:
-
HRE officially done
-
No major wars for 100 years
-
no satisfaction for nationalists & democrats
-
transfers people from one gov’t to another (pay later for this)
Few Other Thingies:
-
Territorial Peak (1810-11)
-
Loss of Church authority
-
Metric system
-
Public Works & Art Hoarding
Romantics
-
Emotional response to Enl.
-
emotion+reason= understanding
-
individual experience is important
-
classics: bad - humans not similar across time
-
imagination: God’s work in artist’s mind
-
MA’s good, Gothic revival
Basis in Rousseau
-
Max. freedom, so that education is by trial & error
-
society & progress have corrupted humans (MA’s village)
-
reason & emotions should guide development
Basis in Kant
-
Moral imperative proves God
-
perception alters reality
-
reason in one sphere, emotion in another
-
artists have special power to go beyond simple understanding
English Romantics
-
Coleridge: Mariner, delivered by realizing beauty & unity of
all things
-
Wordsworth: feared he had lost vision, corrupted by aging & life
-
Byron: Mack, adventurer, prototype of romantic revolt
More English Romantics
-
Shelley: imagination liberates the individual
-
Keats: lyrical render what is contemplated (descriptive)
German Romantics
-
Shakespeare as model for breaking classical mold
-
sturm und drung
-
embrace nationalism
-
Schlegel: women (SEX)
-
Goethe: live outside bounds of society, striving for knowledge leads to
pact with Devil, don’t abandon religion
Wesley & the Methodists
-
Methodism provides emotional religion in response to dogma
-
starts in GB, big impact in U.S.
-
inward heartfelt religion
-
inner spirit leads to Godly life
More Romantic Religion
-
RC revival in Fr.
-
Schliermacher: other religions are OK!?!, based on faith in infinite being,
God in nature
-
not dogma or ethics, it’s spirit
Romantic Historians
-
respond to frenchification with German spirit & culture
-
Herder: Humans and society are organic (German is good)
-
Hegel: each period is important because it affects what follows, thesis
vs. antithesis = synthesis
Fichte: Will (conception) of the great defines world
It’s All About Industry
• old way of life passing, 1825-1855: time of transition between
1st IR & 2nd IR
• Affects all aspects of society: living cond., families, women, social
classes, religion
• GB leads (markets, quality of goods, already ahead), others (esp.
Fr. & Ger.) follow
Migration to Cities & Beyond
• late 1700s starts, picks up in 1820
• emancipation of serfs & more fluid labor market (changing jobs
& locations)
• RR’s & roads make moving easier, feed industry (capital investment)
• cities not ready = horrific conditions
Rise of the Proletariat
• working class (no stake)
• wage system = workers no longer control means of production
• end of guilds (FR, liberals) & artisans
• confection sys. (division of labor)
• income to owners
The Proletariat Responds
• sabotage & resistance
• trade unions
• Chartism
• Socialism
• British WC wants Charter (1838), presented to Par. 3 times &
rejected
The Charter’s Six Points:
a) universal suffrage
b) annual elections
c) secret ballot
d) end of prop. req.
e) salaries for members of Par.
f) equal districts
• all met over time, not immediately
Early Unions
• Combination Acts outlawed workers’ associations
• trade unions form in early 1800’s, nat’l assoc. begin to form after
repeal of Comb. Acts
Industrialism & the Family
• mech. weaving = out of home
• fathers use kids as assistants è
• mid-1820’s- spinning & weaving together, men make enough to leave
kids home, supervise poor W&C not from family
• Separate sphere for WC Women
• big probs. with child labor
• Factory Act (1833): 9 hrs., 2 hrs. education, must be 9 yrs. old
• break between home & child, brings in school & factory
• 1847- 10 hr. day for all, families spend more time together
• unit of production + consumption to just consumption
• kids stay home until married
• start to supportive domestic role for WC women (MC before)
• children = assets
• unmarried women work until married (factory instead of house)
• prostitution out of desperation
• lots of new, unskilled jobs
• less arranged marriage
• men more mobile, more illegitimate kids
Thoughts on Urbanization
• draws attention to poor
• Allows poor to organize
• puts poor in contact with world
• GB faces no comp. until 1870
Classical Economics
• extension of Laissez Faire
Gov’t Should:
• maintain currency
• enforce contracts
• protect property & foreign trade
• leave rest to individual
Malthus
• condition of WC can’t be improved
• pop. will overcome food supply
• wagesèmore kidsèless food
• WC needs higher standard & less kids
Ricardo
• Iron Law of Wages- wages è more kids è labor è
lower wages è less kids
• justifies low wages & opposition to unions
Bentham
• utility- greatest happiness for greatest number
• reason+utility will eliminate legal clutter
Early Socialism (LF sucks)
Workers deal w/ probs in 2 ways:
Unions (work w/in system)
Socialism (reform all of society)
• Cooperation better than competition
• Indust. is OK, free market can’t distribute goods, few control
• goods for use, not sale
• Society = community
Early Socialists
• Saint-Simon: capital & prop. should be administered by “elites”
for public good
• Owen: build “utopian” communities of textile manufacturers
• Fourier: “phalanxes” liberated living
• All 3 ignore political reality
Marx
• sci. accuracy, reject reform, need revolution
• inspired by 1848
• Engels
• thesis vs. antithesis = synthesis
Communist Manifesto
• State is Bourg Committee for exploitation
• Workers deprived of wealth they create
• religion is a drug to keep lower classes in order
• loyalty to your class
Impact of Marx’s Theory:
• economic conditions evolve through history (shaped by material conditions)
• Capitalism leads to conflict between owners & workers
• reforms won’t work
• Competition Ô small group of owners & big suffering prolet.
REVOLUTION
• Prolet. will form dictatorship to reorganize society
• eventually dictatorship will not be needed
• prolet. can’t be an oppressor = no oppression
• this is the culmination of history
A Few Final Marxisms:
• shaped by unemployment and deprivation of 1840s
• widely accepted because they seem to be based on scientific fact
rather than theorizing
Anarchism
• remove industry & government to obtain true freedom (dominating
people’s lives)
• Anarchism popular in least democratic states - Movement will get
more violent as time goes on (late 1800’s
• Blanqui calls for proletariat revolution
• Proudhon calls for community of small businesses w/out government