Did NASA Edit these?

Some people claim that these images are proof of NASA editing the raw footage. They claim that the missing areas were obviously edited with a photo editor to remove something that NASA didn't want us to see. What I have done on this page is simply show that were they REALLY edited as claimed, that with a little more work, NASA could have easily fooled people by recreating the images rather than leaving them in such an "Edited" state when they got posted. This simple page is designed to demonstrate that if NASA was really attempting to hiding things they could do a far better job, and that the reason that the images are posted as they are is because that is how they were recieved, not that they were edited.
A poster, Slinted, on the Bad Astronomy Bulletin Board explains it this way.

The rovers are commanded to take a subframe image of a feature on the rock wall, and the subframe is at the bottom of the real 1024x1024 image. They point the camera at the wall so the center of the subframe lines up with their target. The sky now resides inside the bins that will not 'be counted' for the subframe. The autoexposure algorithms onboard MER work like this :
they wait for a certain % of the image subframe to reach brightness X. Unfortunetly, in the time it takes for those CCD bins in the subframe to reach their requested brightness, the brightness of the bins outside the subframe that contain sky become saturated, and beyond. As the image keeps exposing, long after the sky portions of the fullframe have saturated, those saturated pixels begin to bleed down into the bins below them. The amount of bleed will correspond to the length of the exposure, which fits perfectly with what we're seeing on his webpage. The rocks within Endurance crater are brightest in L2 and least bright in L7, which means to get to the requested brightness, L2 images need to expose for much shorter times than L7's. The L2's show the bleeding effect, but to a very small degree. The L7's show a very large amount of bleed (almost 1/8 of the image), as they have been exposed much, much longer. The amount of bleed increases between L2 and L7 accordingly.


The second point in this is that NASA are not under any obligation to publish any images at all, so why bother cutting chunks out and then publishing obviously damaged images at all? Why not just delete them so they are never seen outside of NASA?

(All of the Altered Images below were done using Paint Shop Pro 7 and took me round 2 hours of work)

Original Photos

(What NASA released)
Red (L4) Filtered Image
Red (L4) Filtered Image
Green (L5) Filtered Image
Green (L5) Filtered Image
Violet (L7) Filtered Image
Violet (L7) Filtered Image

Altered Photos

(I added the missing parts back in with PSP 7)
Red Filtered Image
Red Filtered Image
Green Altered Image
Green Altered Image
Violet Altered Image
Violet Altered Image

Colourized Altered Photos

(Each of the three is colourized, again with PSP 7)
Red Colourized Image
Red Colourized Image
Green Colourized Image
Green Colourized Image
Violet Colourized Image
Violet Colourized Image

My Fake Colour versions

(The layers added together with PSP 7)
False Colourized Image
False Colourized Image
Edited and Color Tweeked Image
This final colourized image has been manipulated to remove the last traces of editing and had its colours tweeked to give a better looking image.