What Women Don't Want To Hear From Men
(a work in progress by Fazeel Azeez Chauhan, 4-22-04)
Preface:
This is a beginning and not yet complete. Underneath any content which
includes frustration, there is sadness on behalf of both men and women,
specially the children of divorce. The purpose is not to blame, but is
to identify the major problems, so that both men and women can work together
to find the much needed solutions to the crisis in the Muslim family:
A) Introduction:
In one generation, the divorce rate among American Muslims has gone from 1 to 35%. Many American Muslims in their twenties and thirties are having trouble getting married and staying together. Some career women have been very vocal, asking "Why is it so hard". It's like Bush asking rhetorically, "Why do they hate us". What they seem to have forgotten is: A man seeks to get married to a woman, for love. By nature, women are complex and men are simple. It takes a feminine woman and a masculine man to create a mutually rewarding relationship and a functional family.
The most influential member of the family is the woman. The major problem
single Muslim women have these days is immaturity and role confusion. It
is also a legitimate complaint that often single men are found to be immature.
The solutions are "not that hard" but the Muslim community seems to like
the pain it's in, and therefore don't feel they require pre-marital training
courses. Such (semester) long term lectures and labs would provide the
tools and wisdom required for overcoming immaturity and role confusion.
B) Analysis of the Problems:
In the mean time, if women want constructive feedback, here are some of the problems that men see:
1) Men Have Not Gone Insane:
A man seeks a woman for marriage who loves him unconditionally. He
needs to be trusted and respected. He requires loyalty and mature communication.
He wonders, "How Hard Can It Be" for her to do that?
2) Erosion of Women's Relationship Skills:
The best book containing time-tested wisdom on relationships, for women
is: "What Really Works With Men", with the subtitle "Solve 95% of Your
Relationship Problems and Do Something About the Rest". For example, the
author, A. Justin Sterling asks a question to working women:
Do you want to be a career woman or a woman with a career?
3) The Endangered Species: Honorable Men:
The landmark book for men is "Iron John" with the subtitle "A Book
About Men". The author, and famous American poet Robert Bly started doing
seminars called "A Gathering of Men", which showed on PBS starting around
1992, and promoted the men's movement. He states, that for thousands of
years, boys in most cultures went through "Rites of Passage". This "Initiation
into Manhood" is often a process of two to seven years, in which the elder
men teach the boy everything he needs to know to survive as a successful
man. Thus the ancient wisdom of how to be a man, was handed down generation
after generation
4) The Downfall of the Muslims:
It is a tragedy that in the Muslim community, no such training exists.
It is obvious that parents have not been able to provide the required knowledge
to their children, to prepare them for a healthy marriage. So a man lacking
maturity can end up in divorce because he had no pro-active or long-term
help available from a masjid. Also, a Muslima who lacks maturity, could
end up marrying a non-Muslim man, as a result of a bitter divorce
5) Crimes of the Father:
A father's job toward his son is to teach him everything he needs to
be successful as a man. He serves as the example of a man, to his daughter
who ends up choosing a husband like her father. But instead, often the
father behaves like a dictator, ordering around family members, expecting
them to obey blindly. He emphasizes university education to his children,
but doesn't teach them how much individuals need nurturance from their
families for survival. The children spend four to ten years in universities,
learning how to make money. But they don't spend even one semester learning
about family dynamics and how to create a healthy marriage
6) Mama's Boys:
The mother needs to break from the boy so that he can grow up to be
a man. This is why it is not uncommon to see a fifty year old man who is
emotionally dependent on his mother as if he's still a boy. It is extremely
common for example in the South Asian culture that the wife thus has to
compete with her husband's mother
7) Like Mother Like Daughter:
It is mainly the mother's responsibility to train her daughter and
teach her how to create a mutually rewarding relationship with her future
husband. Most of the mothers of Muslima's were housewives, born and raised
in other countries. They have not been effective in training their daughters,
specially those who have careers. When the daughter starts making money,
she gets a taste of independence. This newness and unfamiliar terrain of
independence can get confused with ego, or arrogance, or rebellion, or
a power trip in the politics of relationships
8) Lack of Good Examples:
A woman learns about womanhood from other women. A woman can't really
teach someone how to be a man, because she isn't one. A man needs to learn
how to be a man from other men. Around 1990, the Christians started "The
Promise Keepers" program to achieve this goal. Some "Muslim" nations have
a lot more money than "Christian" or "Jewish" nations. But other than that,
in general, the Muslim community has a lot of catching up to do with the
other nations. For example, there is no desire to be a part of any Muslim
group like "Promise Keepers". So the new American Muslim community lacks
a progressive attitude, and has been unable to provide a comprehensive
set of tools to individuals, to ensure a 100% success rate in a marriage
9) Happily Single versus Doubly Miserable:
Why does anyone want to get married in today's world? America's a free
society and when Muslims want to date in public or in private, no one can
stop them. They don't want to be tied down with the "wrong" person who
will make them both miserable. So instead, some single Muslims keep dating
while searching for that ideal soul mate
10) Surrender Toward God and Devil's Advocate Toward Fellow Muslims:
Confused Muslims tend to fight tooth and nail, to make sure they don't
agree with each other. The individual's purpose seems to be "I want to
be right by making the other person wrong", even when the other person
may be saying something truthful. An immature and egotistical Muslim feels
that if she agrees or listens to the other person, she will be perceived
as a loser. So there is a constant one-upmanship battle going on. Muslims
have become so mistrustful of each other that it looks like we're paranoid.
Our communities are full of cynical, arrogant, self-righteous, closed minded,
skeptics who enjoy playing the game of the devil's advocate. Any thinking
individual can't tell the forest from the tree, and so even he's restricted
to operate on an island like the other Muslims
11) Dating as Marriage:
Many Muslims today are entering into marriage with the premise that
if it doesn't work out, oh well, divorce will be okay. Often it is exactly
like dating, except it has a label of marriage. But according to Islamic
teachings, divorce is just past the haraam line, and is the least desirable
among halal actions. The American TV culture of dating has infiltrated
and defeated the culture of marriage
12) Shortcutting and Skipping Steps:
First, the person has to know themselves. Second, she should make a
list of qualities she seeks in a man, with whom she is willing to give
her all, to make a marriage work. Third, the spouse with that criteria
needs to be found. Fourth, a lifetime commitment needs to be made while
marrying the person. Fifth, the daily sacrifice and devotion needs to be
made to make the marriage last a lifetime. Sixth, a mutually rewarding
relationship is further developed so that the children can be provided
proper parental guidance to help them succeed in a very challenging world.
The premise should be "I will make this marriage work, resolving any obstacles
which come in the way". Starting many years before getting married, the
Muslim's daily actions need to indicate an honorable commitment to the
construction of a loving family environment. But instead, most of the time,
couples skip steps one through five and are shocked to find themselves
unable to reach step six. They end up in a miserable state, living as roommates
who can't get along.
13) Divorce as Suicide:
A depressed individual needs to make a decision that suicide is not
an option. This helps him to focus on a large number of other options on
the spectrum of possible actions. Similarly, when a person decides that
like suicide, divorce is not an option, then she will spend her efforts
on positive actions like marriage counseling, self help books on relationships,
assistance from some wise elders, personal development, educating himself
about the roles and responsibilities of males, versus females, etc. etc.
Beginning the marriage with a committed view that "I will not get divorced",
can help the couple to lay down a pro-active pattern, working toward that
goal. In the West, marriage is celebrated on the wedding anniversary and
on Valentines day. Yet, to develop a deep and lifelong bond, the relationship
needs consistent attention three hundred and sixty five days of the year
14) The Auto-Pilot Expecting Miracles:
Often the condition of a Muslim is the hands-off, passive attitude,
letting circumstances rule his life. He blames his lazy life in the comfort
zone, on God's Will. Before marriage, she has inadequate preparation, and
puts no effort in trying to understand how to make a relationship successful.
She expects her knowledge and life will be miraculously transformed after
the wedding day. She leaves her relationship skills on auto-pilot, before
and after marriage, pretending that things will work themselves out, on
their own. When the natural tendency of entropy leads to disorder, she
then blames the man for the crashing relationship
15) Using Selfish Relationship Models:
Men's lives didn't change much in the last few decades. But women changed
significantly as they entered the work force. The American woman became
independent even from her husband and children. This freedom model failed
for the general American population, where half the marriages end within
three years and 75% of marriages end within seven years. Perceiving themselves
to be modern, powerful and free, Muslim women started following this faulty
American model of relationships, which doesn't work even for Americans.
Progressive Americans on the other hand, are going back to the traditional
model and build upon those fundamentals. A forward thinking Muslim woman
needs to focus on the traditional Islamic model also, while finding positive
ways to correct the mistakes of their parents' example
16) Having Fun versus Having Vision:
There are basically two types of relationships. The first is dating
for fun, sex, fashion, looking good and impressing others. The pleasure
principle of desiring instant gratification, achieves superficial rewards.
The second kind of relationship is marriage, which requires maturity, commitment,
responsibility and self sacrifice. The main purpose is, to create a loving
partnership so that good parental guidance can be provided to the children.
Some Native Americans support long term vision in this way: Before making
any major decision in life, imagine what effect you will cause on the next
seven generations
17) Form versus Content:
Over-stimulation by TV, teaches a person to emphasize physical images.
Good looking, slender bodies which have an appealing form, often have a
contrasting ugly content which is unable to create contentment in a relationship
18) If Your Priorities are Superficial, That's What You'll Get:
Distractions of the American lifestyle encourage a Muslim man to think
with a dating perspective. A man who dates, usually looks for superficial
physical beauty. So if he chooses a woman for her face or figure, often
that is mostly what he will get from her in the long run. Many good looking
women are very demanding and the price they require for maintenance is
very high. Often she thinks that by being pretty, she is doing more than
enough favors to her Muslim husband. A mature man seeks a priceless gem
of a Muslim woman whose traditional approach will create a loving home
with him
19) Be My Shining Light:
The mature and generous Muslim woman is a beacon of light to her family
and her community. Her children, her husband, her Muslim community and
humanity are all in desperate need of her flexible feminine nature, and
her deeply caring motherly abilities to nurture, teach and inspire us
20) He's Never Good Enough:
Some women saw their mothers bickering and complaining to their fathers.
Some Muslim mothers talk badly about the father, behind his back. Combine
this with the image of the father portrayed on American TV since the 1950's
as a distant, cold, fool. Some women thus have such a negative prejudice
against men, that no matter what the husband does, it is impossible to
make her happy
21) A Control Freak Who's Out of Control:
An insecure woman uses her subjective opinions to make up self-serving
rules to control her husband. She re-invents the wheel every day. An infantile
vision assumes there's nothing to be learned from the wisdom of the past.
She then expects the man to pretend that he was born yesterday. Even if
her subjective method doesn't work, she wants it all today, at the expense
of trashing what worked in the past
22) The Beauty of Motivation:
When the woman decides that she will not listen, there is no way a
man can convince her to change her mind. On the other hand, women have
much more persuasive skills to maneuver a relationship with a man
23) What Have You Done For Me Lately versus Gratitude:
A selfish woman sings this song because she becomes a bottomless pit.
As hard as the man might try, he cannot fill her needs. When he doesn't
get the appreciation at home, this drains his emotional, physical and spiritual
energies. Thus the woman helps him to fail in life. Not being grateful
is a part of kufr. So her lack of gratitude makes herself fail, not only
in marriage, but ultimately she's a loser in her personal life also
24) Behind Every Successful Man There's A Supportive Woman:
If a man has to fight life's daily battles alone, he gets exhausted
after some time. Like her, he needs love and a supportive home environment
to re-charge his batteries. He needs the wife to be on his side and to
enjoy his wins in life together. Joy is increased by sharing, and sorrows
are decreased by sharing
25) Man Seeks Husband:
From a man's point of view, what is the extra bonus in a woman if she
has a good career? More money for the home? It is the woman who usually
looks for a man with a good career. And the man looks for a woman who has
developed the fundamental skills for being a wife and mother. If he wants
achievements in the corporate world, partnership with a career-oriented
woman would be helpful to him. Instead, what he really wants is a family-oriented
woman who is not confused about roles
26) Money Can't Buy Her Love:
If love is a high priority, she will focus on her family life. If money
is her high priority, then she will focus on her career. Thus a career
woman shouldn't be surprised when she has lots of money, plus lots of loneliness.
She will have to choose devotion to family or dedication to career, as
the highest priority in life. Would she rather neglect her career or neglect
her children?
27) The Unmarriageable Woman:
The Prophet was not intimidated by Hazrat Khadija's money and business.
But Islam says the best reason for marrying a woman is for her Deen. Hazrat
Khadija excelled in Islamic teachings and was not following the corporate
deen of the time, that is why she was not an unmarriageable woman. Today's
career woman justifies her ego and upside-down priorities by emphasizing
Hazrat Khadija's business skills, while brushing under the rug the family
and relationship skills of the Prophet's wife
28) Woman Seeks Butler:
Usually, one spouse has to be more family-oriented. So an ideal for
a career woman might be to find a man who sits at home. Of course, this
doesn't work, because it is very contrary to a man's natural tendencies,
and a woman hates to see a man who sits at home
29) It's All About Me:
It is a masculine trait, to be career-oriented. It is a feminine trait,
to be family-oriented. For the family to survive, a man's career has to
be a high priority. A mature man finds a way to successfully integrate
his work, family and personal lives. Traditionally, for the successful
woman, the highest priority has to be the children, then her husband, and
lastly herself. In the area of family, also for the man, the highest priority
has to be the children, then his wife, and lastly himself. The major problem
today in family life is selfishness, where either the husband or wife,
make their individual self the highest priority
30) The Hell of Marriage:
When the marriage starts going downhill, the husband doesn't care how
many PhD's his wife has. What he prays for at that time is a caring, feminine
woman who brings out the best in him. For the children of divorce, it is
no consolation that their mother prefers her job over their father
31) The Death Sentence - Divorce:
Children are traumatically effected when their parents get divorced.
The children prefer to deal with the death of both parents. Divorce means
putting the children's lives in danger. In a family and community, divorce
is the weapon of mass destruction
32) What's Common Between Suicide, Warfare and Divorce?
Suicide is not an option, warfare is the very last option, divorce
is very close to the border of being haraam. First, the person needs to
make a commitment that he will not commit suicide, which is an extreme
on the spectrum of actions. Then he can start working on solutions. The
same thing with warfare, nations have to be committed to negotiation and
peacemaking. At the time of marriage, both people promise they'll make
it work. But when trouble happens, they kill the family by getting a divorce
33) Only My Way, Not a Bi-way:
Insisting that one partner must adopt the dictates of the other creates
too much resentment. If the current method is not working, then the family
deserves a second method to make the relationship prosper. The woman has
to be open, and to admit it when her way is not working. So she can read
books, seek counseling, and find another way that really works with men
34) The Bargain Hunter:
A relationship is a two way street. But the selfish person wants to
do very little and get a lot in return. The bargain hunter wants to get
a better deal while giving the other person the short end of the stick
35) Dictator versus Student:
Instead of being a dictator, it works better to have a student's point
of view, with the willingness to learn
36) The Masjid Can't Save a Troubled Marriage:
Many Muslims make the excuse that they don't need to go anywhere for
help "because all the answers are in the Quran". At the same time, they
don't follow the general teachings of Islam. In case of physical injury,
they don't run to the masjid, they go to a doctor. But after being emotionally
and psychologically injured in marriage, they go to seek help from the
masjid. At the masjid, the imam usually does not provide referrals in his
self-righteousness, and the couple is not advised to seek professional
marriage and family counseling
37) Not Selling Out the Marriage:
It is good for a woman to be well educated. But in the process, if
her family values and relationship skills are destroyed, then she has actually
defeated herself. A successful woman is the one who is family oriented
first, and uses her education and job, to enhance the pre-requisite of
her relationship skills
38) Wishful Thinking vs. Reality:
As a community, we make the "Dawa" or proclamation that Islam is the
best religion and Muslims are the best humans. We give plenty of emotional
lip service, but don't back it up with actions, to prove the excellence
of Islamic teachings. The best dawa is by living as a good example. A non-Muslim
person would see the value in becoming a Muslim if he gets a good answer
to the question: Can Muslims give me a program which creates a fulfilling
marriage and avoids divorce? The answer is, no such practical training
exists today. Though the theories are strong in Islam, 35% of Muslims in
America still end up in divorce. Similarly, can Muslims help an alcoholic
to quit drinking? No such practical program exists among Muslims, but millions
of people have received the solution through Alcoholics Anonymous
39) Me vs. the Prophet:
As individuals, we make the "Dawa" of being good Muslims, but in practice,
the relationship between husband and wife proves we don't practice the
Prophet's teachings. For example, a wife wants her husband to follow her
own personal desires, whims and opinions. Or the man follows his ego instead
of higher principles
40) Getting Real:
Some people call themselves Muslim but say "Get Real! We are not prophets,
we are ordinary humans". Using this excuse, they actually say that they
don't need to follow the example of Prophet Muhammed
41) That Was Then, This Is Now:
When a Muslim says that Islamic teachings are outdated and don't apply
in today's complex world, it is an indication of lack of faith. Adaptation
is useful, but throwing the baby out with the bath water is self destructive
42) Judging a Book by its Cover:
The leader at the masjid has a very bad reputation and needs to make
great efforts to undo the stereotypes which are commonly believed about
him. It is thus easy to not be able to see a good tree in a forest of bad
examples. Many Muslims don't trust men who have beards or who look "religious".
Many Muslims also think that in the hijab is a good woman. But a beard,
robe, hat or hijab can also be used as a mask to hide hypocrisy. On the
other extreme, a modern American "Muslim" wife sometimes wants a divorce
because she thinks her husband is too religious or too oppressive
43) Bollywood vs. Familyhood:
Indian movies and Network American TV, promote a romanticized view
of life and relationships. Some viewers start believing that movies are
truthful depictions of practical life. Thus they develop unreasonable,
high expectations, desiring a perfect marriage partner who should be prince
charming or a super model. The male gets brainwashed and seeks a beautiful,
slim, spunky, sociable woman. The female viewer gets conditioned into believing
that the romanticized version of life presented in soap operas and movies,
is real, and the norm. She envisions a rich socialite, with fast cars and
a palace. And when her husband does not match the romantic model on TV,
she hates him
44) The Prima Donna Material Girl:
Some "Girls Just Wanna Have Fun" and dance, yet want to be seen "Like
A Virgin", as if they are fit for worship like the original "Madonna",
mother of Prophet Jesus. She wants her man to prostrate and litter her
feet with expensive gifts and sacraments
45) The Gold Miner / Doc Hunter:
As long as he has plenty of money, she's happy. The doctor or wealthy
man could have poor manners, or bad character, but this she can overlook.
But if he gets sued for malpractice, loses his license, and thus can't
maintain the old standard of living, then she says "sorry honey, bye bye,
I'm just not in love with you any more"
46) Nice Girls Finish Last?
He could take her for granted and think she's a pushover. So he pushes
the boundaries further and further by mistreating her. Similarly, for some
women, it's easy to take advantage of nice guys
47) The Bigger Better Deal:
The more you make, the more you spend. For an upwardly mobile, all
American Muslim, an upgrade is always overdue, for a newer car, a bigger
house, and a better partner. The present situation is never good enough
because material consumption cannot fulfill spiritual hunger
48) He's Good Enough Only When He's Dead:
After the husband's death, she may start singing his praises. But while
he was alive, he did not receive much thanks or respect from her
49) Ready for Marriage But Only in Your Imagination:
The individual communicates to parents, family, friends and through
matchmakers and internet matrimonial ads that she is ready for marriage.
But her attitude and actions show that she's just having fun, flirting,
enjoying the attention, and not yet serious about settling down into a
marriage commitment
50) Playing the Victim Role:
Blaming others by pretending to be the victim and not taking ownership
of her own life and actions. Milking negative events of the past to control
the partner
51) Playing Dum:
Still in the playing phase, pretending to be naive, in order to manipulate
the partner. Stating that "I don't know" is a good way, of escaping from
taking responsibility
52) A Sorry State of Affairs:
Thinking that saying sorry should be enough for the harmed partner.
Hoping to avoid any consequences or accountability, of any action (large
or small), by simply saying "I'm Sorry" and refusing to look deeper at
the issue
53) Spoiled Rotten Princess Seeks Miracle Worker:
Part of bad training by the parents is to give the daughter whatever
she wants, whenever she wants it. She grows up thinking that her husband
should also grant all her wishes and work miracles
54) The Empty Nest On the Hill:
Unfortunately, there has been a lot of bad news for women. It's true
they work hard at school, and at work, develop rewarding careers, but still
feel unfulfilled without the love of a man. All the material and career
gains don't make her family dreams come true
55) Do Feminists Hate Men?
Til the early 1990's, there was no agreed upon definition of "Feminism".
The feminist movement demanded human rights for women, but also did a lot
of damage to family life. Many pioneers in the feminist movement are homosexual.
Often women went overboard and tried to become like men, because they received
mixed messages from feminists
56) Homosexual Teachers of Relationships vs. Heterosexual Teachers
of Marriage:
Wisdom can be learned from Gandhi, and from feminists too, but the
meat and potatoes are to be found in our own tradition, in the example
of the Prophet and his wives. Couples who follow these traditions as a
foundation of their relationship, will need to make only minor adjustments
to survive in the modern world. But since they haven't had good parental
guidance, they require relationship training based on the Prophet's family
traditions
57) Men Cannot Become Women:
Americans are realizing the truth that "Men are from Mars, Women are
from Venus", and are turning toward traditional models to make marriages
work in today's world. Unfortunately, Muslims are still behind, because
they're following the failed modern models of American relationships
58) Lack of Knowledge:
One can be the president, a priest, a doctor or a PhD and still be
prejudiced. Education and degrees are not a cure-all, and they don't make
a human a know-it-all. Knowledge about business and sciences cannot be
used as a replacement for lack of knowledge in relationships. 99 % of people
with degrees didn't take a single class on relationships, or on being a
man or on being a woman. As if on auto-pilot, dreaming to suddenly develop
on the wedding day, a high quality of masculinity, fatherhood, femininity
or motherhood
59) Women Don't Trust Men:
Emphasizing equality, women have lost the long term vision of family.
They have trouble finding trustworthy men. But if she trusts a man and
gives him her best, an honorable man will give her in return, a lot more
than he receives. But since she holds back, he follows her example
60) Looking For Love in All the Wrong Places:
Television and magazine ads, sell images. People start believing that
reality equals marketing. When she mimics the western woman's image, the
Muslima is rewarded by men who give her more attention. She feels she's
more in demand when she talks, walks, dresses, and acts like an Americanized
woman. Low cut tops and jeans do get her more attention, but it's from
men who are usually interested in a short-term recreational relationship.
When people are giving attention to her physical shape, she might mistake
it to mean they are giving her love
61) "Save Me From Homosexuality":
Some women from Muslim families develop the view that men are not able
to make them happy. Some try sexual relationships with women, and blame
the community that high quality of Muslim males were not made available
to them, so they went elsewhere. Some women say they will stop being with
women, for the right man. Some women offer this deal to their Muslim husbands
to be: I'll let you have two wives at a time, if you let me have a girlfriend
on the side
62) The Unwilling to Sacrifice Ego:
Most of our mothers were not well educated, and our fathers generally
oppressed them. So the daughters see this model, and in their rebellion
against it, they go to an extreme. With a good salary to back her up, she
wishes to dominate the husband to take revenge on her mother's behalf.
A woman with only a high school degree will tend to have a smaller ego,
and will find it easier to make compromises with her husband. The higher
the degree, the bigger the salary, and the bigger is her ego, and the less
is the caring. And so a careless career woman is much less likely to keep
her ego in check. Her big ego will make her think in a masculine way. Jihad
against others is easier than Jihad al-rooh, meaning it's difficult battle
to looking inside one's own self. So her degree and salary can become the
demons (if she lets them), who stop her from doing Jihad al-Nafs, which
is required to make a marriage work
63) The High Maintenance Brat:
In a severe role-confusion, the woman wants the marriage to be 50/50.
She holds back, giving only a conditional 50%, becoming lazy and overly
demanding of her husband. She may feel like a super woman, a super achiever,
who becomes super demanding. There is no super man who is willing to become
a super slave to provide her such an unrealistic high standard of maintenance
64) Feminized Men and Masculine Women:
A woman is supposed to be feminine. Very rare Muslim men are looking
for a masculine woman. Men's masculinity hasn't changed much in the past
few decades. But since the 1960's, on the path of competing with men in
the work environment, then competing with men at home, women have become
less feminine and more masculine. This is a big turn off for men. Usually,
wimpy men and macho women are not considered desirable by the opposite
sex. Instead, both need to be empowered and well rounded individuals so
they don't need to be in political power struggles
65) Eat Your Corporate Competition For Breakfast:
A woman who experiences "success" at work, unconsciously applies the
corporate model at home. But the family environment gets destroyed if in
the home there's a dog eat dog, rat race
66) "Treat Me Like a goddess":
Some parents give the fantasy message to a daughter that she is perfect
and she starts believing she can do no wrong. The Muslim woman in college
and work, sees all her colleagues dating. Specially if she's good looking,
she is constantly asked out on a date. Men will lift her to the heavens
with their compliments, telling her how exotic she is, til she starts believing
she's a goddess. She may refuse the dates, but expects the same fantasy
treatment and lies from her husband. Some women actually say to their husbands
"while dating, I have been treated like nothing less than a goddess". The
man has to slap himself to make sure he's awake cause he hasn't met any
walking "god" in his life, only idols
67) Dating the Husband:
There are basically two types of relationships between a man and a
woman: Short-term is dating for fun and temporary, sensual gratification.
Long-term is mature, spiritually intimate, serious, for marriage and kids.
The career woman may think that a long-term relationship requires the low
level of "commitment" of a short-term. Some are proud to say "lie to me".
In that model, she will end up a single parent, adding to her children's
confusion
68) Women Are Better Than Men in Almost Every Way:
Men and women are different, and have their own strengths. So there
is no need to compete. According to psychology, women are social and relationship-oriented.
While men are individual and rule-oriented. Using her God-given superior
skills in relationship management, a feminine woman can enlist her husband's
cooperation
69) Confusing Pieces of the Puzzle:
What sons and daughters are taught at home, in the masjid, at school
and at work, is mixed messages. Thus we end up shooting in the dark, using
tools which give hit and miss results. What's needed is clarity on the
basics of the roles, through a semester long Islamic course called "Fundamentals
of Marriage"
70) Making Yourself Right til Divorce:
There are such programs available in the non-Muslim arena. But Muslims
are unwilling to learn from those sources. Muslim couples would rather
get divorced than to resolve their issues by going to a psychologist who
provides marriage counseling. When the troubled couple goes to the masjid
for "counseling", usually the administration is not qualified enough to
help save their marriage. The Imam at the masjid is usually too pompous
to refer the couple to a psychologist for relationship counseling. An ideal
treatment would be by a Counselor who has training in psychology, and combines
those tools with Islamic teachings
71) Prejudice Against the Muslim Male:
Having lived with the parents' model which required the wife to be
like a maid, in the presence of a dictator, the backlash today is that
the career woman wants to dictate her own terms which would only work with
a domesticated man who behaves like a male maid. Based on that prejudice,
she is shut down to this type of feedback from a mature male. The career
woman tends to believe that a Muslim man is only out to oppress her
72) Incoherent Priorities:
The career woman behaves like a man, when she expects her husband to
make the wife as the number one priority in his life. At the same time,
her number one priority is her career. Her second priority is herself.
Her third priority is her children. And the way she treats her husband,
proves that he is at the bottom of her priority list. So why would he want
to get married to a woman like that? The cons far outweigh the pros, in
the man's view
73) She Needs a Man She Can Lean On:
In the past few decades, the role of a husband hasn't changed. He always
went to work and was the main provider. He needs to make a small change
in the traditional model, which is to honor his wife more. He also needs
to stop being an insecure Mama's Boy and grow up to be a well-rounded,
mature man
74) The Most Sacred Ambition:
For a Muslim woman who follows in the footsteps of the Prophet's wives,
the most sacred ambition is to be known as the best wife and best mother.
Being the best doctor, lawyer and professors should be secondary. Otherwise,
a woman for whom career ambitions are the highest priority; feels empty
inside, and as she grows older, she becomes harder, more bitter, and even
less desirable
75) Excellence in Career But Incompetence in Marriage:
The reality is that Muslim women have worked hard for their education
and careers, at the expense of not working hard toward marriage and family
life. Frequently, she's proud doing an excellent job at school, at work,
treating her boss, colleagues and clients in the best way, but mistreating
her husband at home
76) Freedom or Corporate Slavery:
A career woman gets a false sense of freedom from her degrees, career
and salary. Deep inside she knows that her feminine instincts long for
a fulfilling relationship with a loving husband. If she's lucky, she realizes
her predicament, and changes before age 36. Since women are much more skilled
than men in relationships, hopefully they will focus more on their feminine-self
development to attract mature men, as the biological clocks keeps ticking
away
77) A Virtuous Woman:
A fundamental reason for the decline of the Muslim family, specially
the divorces in America, is the lack of virtuous women and honorable men.
The Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) said: "The world and all things
in it are valuable; but the most valuable thing in the world is a virtuous
woman." {Sahih Muslim, Hadith 704}
78) Empty Pride in Being a Muslim:
We can't be proud of making the "Dawa" that the divorce rate among
Muslim Americans is better than the American norm of 50%. The divorce rate
of American Muslims is going up from 35%. What's more tragic is, there
are no statistics on the damage done to the children of divorced homes.
Such a child suffers abandonment issues and often blames herself for the
parents' divorce
79) The Ability to Empathize:
A child develops certain cognition skills around age five. This is
when playing peek-a-boo doesn't work. Because before then, she doesn't
have the mental ability to look from the point of view of the other person.
When the parent hides behind a wall, the infant thinks they have disappeared.
After age 5, the child develops the ability to put himself in another's
shoes. This quality is called empathy, which is one of the highest spiritual
principles. An immature person has a lot of trouble looking at the other's
point of view
80) Mature Men and Women Help Us Win:
The result of immaturity and role confusion is that the whole family
is defeated. Is it worth it if somebody's career wins? As an extension
of the family, the whole Muslim Community loses
D) Solutions:
1) A Muslim scholar teams up with a psychologist to develop the contents of semester long training courses. Each class should meet once a week for three hours, over a period of four months. Some beginning courses would be:
IS 101: Fundamentals of Becoming a Real Muslim Woman
or
IS 102: Fundamentals of Becoming a Real Muslim Man
IS 110: How to Create a Healthy Marriage Which Will Last a Lifetime
IS 120: How to Provide Excellent Parental Guidance
IS 130: Your Roles and Responsibilities in Uplifting the Muslim Community
IS 140: Constructive Community Service:
Volunteer for Improving the Condition of Humanity
2) A Halaqa organization needs to be created and supported, like the Muslim version of the Christian PromiseKeepers. Men will meet once a week and help each other in personal development. Through the program, an individual will also learn how to become a better husband and father. As the condition of the individual is improved, this will have a very positive impact on his relationships and surroundings
3) A similar women's organization needs to be created, where females help each other in self development, in how to be a better wife and mother
4) The women's group and men's group meet together to do community service projects which result in community construction and empowerment