The Milwaukee Bonecrushers were a rather late offseason addition to the CIFL. The team was not very competitive with any teams in the league, but did manage a win at Muskegon. In 2009, four quarterbacks combined to throw for just 13 touchdowns compared to 27 for the opponent. The Bonecrushers' second season was not much better than the first, but did get its first home victory with 33 seconds to go against Wheeling, 35-32. The team was outscored by an average of 19 points.