Arn Anderson
| Wrestler | Won Title | Lost Title | |
| Arn Anderson | 04/06/03 | Current | |
| Chuck Grimes | 03/02/03 | 04/06/03 | |
| Ace | 02/02/03 | 03/02/03 | |
| Chuck Grimes | 05/20/02 | 01/25/03 | |
| Arn Anderson | 08/27/01 | 05/01/02 | |
| Rob Black | 08/12/01 | 08/27/01 | |
| Ace | 10/19/00 | 01/08/01 | |
| Raven*** | 09/28/00 | 10/16/00 | |
| Jason | 08/22/00 | 09/28/00 | |
| Simon Kaine | 08/06/00 | 08/22/00 | |
| Mercenary | 01/06/00 | 01/18/00 | |
| Scorpious | 12/27/99 | 01/06/00 | |
| Crowe | 9/03/99 | 12/23/99 | |
| The Rock | 8/27/99 | 9/03/99 | |
| Ace | 7/23/99 | 8/27/99 | |
| Kevin Nash | 7/20/99 | 7/23/99 | |
| Undertaker | 7/04/99 | 7/20/99 | |
| Triple H | 6/22/99 | 7/04/99 | |
| Ric Flair | 6/09/99 | 6/22/99 | |
| Grifter* | 6/08/99 | 6/09/99 | |
| Stone Cold** | 5/18/99 | 6/06/99 |
**Stone Cold Steve Austin dropped the then Intercontinental Title on 6/6/99 after he won the World Title.
***Raven vacated the title as result of breech of contract.
