Site hosted by Angelfire.com: Build your free website today!

Typology of Deviance

TYPOLOGY OF DEVIANCE
(by Marshall B. Clinard and Robert F. Meier)
(Sociology of Deviant Behavior...1995)

This is a general typology of deviance. Although separate types of deviance...different ways we socially define Deviance...they also are linked together and in a sense, complete each other. Each by themselves have limitations or "problems". Much, if not most, of the deviance in our society can be identified by the individual type or their synthesis.





1. STATISTICAL/NUMERICAL DEVIANCE

-majority/minority numerically

--departure from an average or mean
-----weight
-----poverty line

-PROBLEM: ANY minority is deviance/ANY majority is "normal"
----------the "what is" can be hidden by the numbers
----------what's really going on in terms of interaction

2. ABSOLUTIST DEVIANCE

-absolute values are constant standards at all times and in all situations

-values are always very clear and laid out in advance---always the same

-deviance = morally wrong
-----deviance is sin and or sickness (morally)
-----------PROBLEM
----------------full of "should be's" and oughts/ideals
----------------whose morals?
----------------source of those morals?

3. REACTIVIST DEVIANCE

-reactions of society are paramount here

-behavior or conditions LABELED as deviance
-----"deviance" is a process
-----"deviance" is NOT in the act itself...must be defined that way

----------PROBLEM
---------------doesn't DEFINE the deviance in the first place
---------------doesn't clarify BASIS FOR reactions
---------------being NOT discovered/not reacted to = no deviance

4. NORMATIVE DEVIANCE

-deviance is a violation of norms, folkways, mores

-sanctions used a lot

-Prescriptive norms = ways we ought to behave

-Proscriptive norms = ways we should not behave -what we should or should not do/think/say under given circumstances

-answers what BASIS for reactions

-----PROBLEM
----------doesn't identify WHOSE norm it is
----------depends on interests of groups (or individuals)
----------POWER variable...to establish and enforce norms and sanctions



ANOTHER TYPOLOGY

1. PURE DEVIANCE

-----objective rule-breaking

2. SECRET DEVIANCE

-----hidden from others
-----if known, nothing done about it
-----victimless behaviors
-----consenting participants

3. FALSELY ACCUSED DEVIANCE

-----no objective rule-breaking
-----but perceived by others as deviance
-----alternative lifestyles
-----often confused with being "different"
-----no labeling, but seen to be annoying and/or undesirable