| Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 | Round 4 | Round 5 | Round 6 | Tournament Champion |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Rock | Fear | Fear | Fear | Bradley | Bradley | Nash |
| Fear | ||||||
| "Stone Cold" Steve Austin | Austin | |||||
| Dude Love | ||||||
| Scott Hall | Scott Hall | Scott Hall | ||||
| X-Pac | ||||||
| Lord Cuttersby | Nicon | |||||
| Lord Nicon | ||||||
| E-Nuff | Scythe | Hogan | Bradley | |||
| Scythe | ||||||
| Hollywood Hulk Hogan | Hogan | |||||
| Kane | ||||||
| Brian "King of Extreme" Eidson | Eidson | Bradley | ||||
| Texas Yokel | ||||||
| Kevin Nash | Bradley | |||||
| Tommy "Bruiser" Bradley | ||||||
| One-Eyed Willie | Willie | Cactas | Porn Star | Benson | ||
| Keffler Krane | ||||||
| Booker T | Cactas | |||||
| Cactas Jack | ||||||
| the CREATURE | Critchell | Porn Star | ||||
| The Good Guy Craig Critchell | ||||||
| Blank Zero | Porn Star | |||||
| Porn Star | ||||||
| Big Bad Voodoo Daddy | Tobbits | The Crock | Benson | |||
| Nguyen Tobbits | ||||||
| The Crock | The Crock | |||||
| Ash | ||||||
| Ass | Dogg | Benson | ||||
| Dogg | ||||||
| Sting | Benson | |||||
| "The Natural" Dan Benson | ||||||
| Hunter Hearst Helmsley | Blade | Michaels | Michaels | Nash | Nash | |
| The Blade Runner | ||||||
| Juan Cisco | Michaels | |||||
| Shawn Michaels | ||||||
| LIQUID SNAKE | Liquid | Klancy | ||||
| Bradshaw | ||||||
| Mr. Tibbs | Klancy | |||||
| Klyde Kooger Klancy | ||||||
| Armaggedon | Armaggedon | Chicken J | Nash | |||
| "Bad Ass" Billy Gunn | ||||||
| Chicken J | Chicken J | |||||
| THE ELIMINATOR | ||||||
| Real O.G. | Real O.G. | Kevin Nash | ||||
| Thorne Richards | ||||||
| Kevin Nash | *Kevin Nash | |||||
| Frogboy | ||||||
| Fantasticus | Fantasticus | Fantasticus | Fantasticus | Fantasticus | ||
| Goldrush Sadowski | ||||||
| Bad Blood | Bad Blood | |||||
| "Hardcore" hAk | ||||||
| "Badlander" Ben Hamilton | Bagwell | Chicago | ||||
| Buff Bagwell | ||||||
| Chicago Jack | Chicago | |||||
| Apocalypse | ||||||
| "The Extreme F'N Icon" Demolition | Demolition | Waffleface | Terror | |||
| D'ablo | ||||||
| Waffleface | Waffleface | |||||
| Maxx | ||||||
| Undertaker | Undertaker | Terror | ||||
| Shadow | ||||||
| Terror | Terror | |||||
| Chris Jericho |
