| Round 1 | Round 2 | Round 3 | Round 4 | Round 5 | Tournament Champion |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Da Brain Pimp | "The Icon" Sean Williams | Cell | Cell | Pain Express | Damian Edge |
| "The Icon" Sean Williams | |||||
| Korn Keg | Cell | ||||
| Cell | |||||
| Lord Cuttersby | Paulie Jefferson | Paulie Jefferson | |||
| Paulie Jefferson | |||||
| PepperJack | "The Natural" Stephen Adams | ||||
| "The Natural" Stephen Adams | |||||
| Kris Kogan | Tweek | Tweek | Pain Express | ||
| Tweek | |||||
| Lunacy | Lunacy | ||||
| Chris Roberts | |||||
| Dr. Grim | Pain Express | Pain Express | |||
| Pain Express | |||||
| Ant Fox | Ant Fox | ||||
| Rico Suave | |||||
| Hugh Jim Pact | Hugh Jim Pact | Hugh Jim Pact | David "Wolverine" Cote | Damian Edge | |
| Slimey | |||||
| Boston Brawler | "Hell's Hitman" Gideon Frost | ||||
| "Hell's Hitman" Gideon Frost | |||||
| David "Wolverine" Cote | David "Wolverine" Cote | David "Wolverine" Cote | |||
| Gas Huffer | |||||
| "The Animal" Nguyen Tobbits | "The Animal" Nguyen Tobbits | ||||
| "The God of Pain" Bane | |||||
| "Mr Showtime" Brian Steel | "Mr.Showtime" Brian Steel | The Gunslinger | Damian Edge | ||
| Space Man Trent Greene | |||||
| The Gunslinger | Gunslinger | ||||
| The Incredible Bulk | |||||
| Taylor Bridges | Damian Edge | Damian Edge | |||
| Damian Edge | |||||
| Brimstone | Brimstone | ||||
| Chuck "The Poser" Williams |
