| Player Name | Pos | Team | Actual Points |
| Garcia, Jeff | QB | SF | 314 |
| Warner, Kurt | QB | StL | 297 |
| Favre, Brett | QB | GB | 280 |
| Gannon, Rich | QB | Oak | 276 |
| Manning, Peyton | QB | Ind | 249 |
| McNair, Steve | QB | Ten | 247 |
| McNabb, Donovan | QB | Phi | 245 |
| Brooks, Aaron | QB | NO | 219 |
| Stewart, Kordell | QB | Pit | 215 |
| Fiedler, Jay | QB | Mia | 204 |
| Plummer, Jake | QB | Ari | 185 |
| Culpepper, Daunte | QB | Min | 181 |
| Collins, Kerry | QB | NYG | 176 |
| Griese, Brian | QB | Den | 170 |
| Brunell, Mark | QB | Jax | 166 |
| Flutie, Doug | QB | SD | 160 |
| Johnson, Brad | QB | TB | 155 |
| Green, Trent | QB | KC | 148 |
| Brady, Tom | QB | NE | 140 |
| Weinke, Chris | QB | Car | 135 |
| Testaverde, Vinny | QB | NYJ | 132 |
| Chandler, Chris | QB | Chi | 126 |
| Grbac, Elvis | QB | 124 | |
| Miller, Jim | QB | Chi | 119 |
| Kitna, Jon | QB | Cin | 111 |
| Couch, Tim | QB | Cle | 110 |
| Banks, Tony | QB | 110 | |
| Van Pelt, Alex | QB | Buf | 103 |
| Batch, Charlie | QB | Pit | 93 |
| Bouman, Todd | QB | Min | 67 |
| Hasselbeck, Matt | QB | Sea | 64 |
| Dilfer, Trent | QB | Sea | 59 |
| Johnson, Rob | QB | TB | 55 |
| Carter, Quincy | QB | Dal | 54 |
| Vick, Michael | QB | Atl | 37 |
| McMahon, Mike | QB | Det | 33 |
| Frerotte, Gus | QB | Cin | 33 |
| Wright, Anthony | QB | Dal | 32 |
| Cunningham, Randall | QB | 32 | |
| Matthews, Shane | QB | Was | 30 |
| O'Donnell, Neil | QB | Ten | 20 |
| Bledsoe, Drew | QB | Buf | 17 |
| Stoerner, Clint | QB | Dal | 16 |
| Feeley, A.J. | QB | Phi | 14 |
| Graham, Kent | QB | Hou | 14 |
| Brees, Drew | QB | SD | 13 |
| Maddox, Tommy | QB | Pit | 13 |
| Quinn, Jonathan | QB | KC | 11 |
| Huard, Brock | QB | 11 |
